Girl, 12, asks West Virginia legislators after abortion ban vote: 'What about my life?'


  • English
  • Arabic

A 12-year-old girl criticised West Virginia legislators after they approved an abortion bill that would ban the procedure, with only some exceptions.

The bill would prohibit abortion at any stage of pregnancy with exceptions only in the event of a non-medically viable foetus, medical emergency or ectopic pregnancy.

If passed, West Virginia will become the first US state to pass legislation restricting access to abortion after the Supreme Court removed its status as a constitutional right.

Under the bill, medical providers who perform abortions could face prison sentences of three to 10 years. The House of Delegates earlier this week allowed exceptions for victims of rape and incest up to 14 weeks of pregnancy, provided the victim reports the attack to police.

The bill did not initially allow exceptions. Addison Gardner of Buffalo Middle School posed a chilling hypothetical scenario after the chamber passed the bill.

“If a man decides that I’m an object and does unspeakable and tragic things to me, am I, a child, supposed to carry and birth another child?” she said.

“Am I to put my body through the physical trauma of pregnancy? Am I to suffer the mental implications? A child who had no say in what was being done with my body.

"Some in here say they are pro life. What about my life? Does my life not matter to you?”

State legislators passed the legislation in a special session called by Governor Jim Justice to "clarify and modernise" the state's abortion laws.

After the Supreme Court's ruling last month, West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey said abortion was banned in the state, citing a law from the 1800s. But a Charleston judge on July 18 barred the state from enforcing the ban, ruling that it had been superseded by conflicting modern laws.

During hours of debate in the West Virginia House chamber, protesters chanting and screaming outside could be heard in the chamber. "Face us," the crowd yelled.

  • The Supreme Court has overturned Roe v Wade, the major ruling that for nearly 50 years has guaranteed a constitutional right to abortion. EPA
    The Supreme Court has overturned Roe v Wade, the major ruling that for nearly 50 years has guaranteed a constitutional right to abortion. EPA
  • Abortion rights advocates march outside the Supreme Court in Washington. EPA
    Abortion rights advocates march outside the Supreme Court in Washington. EPA
  • Emily Milford holds her protest sign during a rally in front of the Duval County Courthouse in Jacksonville, Florida. The Florida Times-Union / AP
    Emily Milford holds her protest sign during a rally in front of the Duval County Courthouse in Jacksonville, Florida. The Florida Times-Union / AP
  • People participate in a protest in Foley Square, in New York City, New York, New York. Reuters
    People participate in a protest in Foley Square, in New York City, New York, New York. Reuters
  • Demonstrators march through downtown following a rally in support of abortion rights in Seattle, Washington. Getty Images / AFP
    Demonstrators march through downtown following a rally in support of abortion rights in Seattle, Washington. Getty Images / AFP
  • Demonstrators during an abortion rights protest outside a courthouse in Los Angeles, California. Bloomberg
    Demonstrators during an abortion rights protest outside a courthouse in Los Angeles, California. Bloomberg
  • Demonstrators during an abortion rights protest in Los Angeles, California. Bloomberg
    Demonstrators during an abortion rights protest in Los Angeles, California. Bloomberg
  • Protesters gather at the steps of the Michigan State Capitol in Lansing during a rally organised by Planned Parenthood. The Grand Rapids Press via AP
    Protesters gather at the steps of the Michigan State Capitol in Lansing during a rally organised by Planned Parenthood. The Grand Rapids Press via AP
  • Protesters demonstrate outside the US Supreme Court in Washington. Bloomberg
    Protesters demonstrate outside the US Supreme Court in Washington. Bloomberg
  • Demonstrators gather during a rally in support of abortion rights in Seattle, Washington. Getty Images / AFP
    Demonstrators gather during a rally in support of abortion rights in Seattle, Washington. Getty Images / AFP
  • Abortion rights campaigners demonstrate outside of the US Federal Courthouse in Tucson, Arizona. Reuters
    Abortion rights campaigners demonstrate outside of the US Federal Courthouse in Tucson, Arizona. Reuters
  • Women protest outside a courthouse in Tucson. Reuters
    Women protest outside a courthouse in Tucson. Reuters
  • Demonstrators make signs at a rally in Tucson. Reuters
    Demonstrators make signs at a rally in Tucson. Reuters
  • A woman holds up a flag during a protest in Foley Square in New York. Reuters
    A woman holds up a flag during a protest in Foley Square in New York. Reuters
  • The Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v Wade ends women's right to abortions. Reuters
    The Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v Wade ends women's right to abortions. Reuters
  • People demonstrate during an abortion rights rally in Tucson. Reuters
    People demonstrate during an abortion rights rally in Tucson. Reuters
  • Protesters blocks streets during an abortion rights rally in Tucson. Reuters
    Protesters blocks streets during an abortion rights rally in Tucson. Reuters
  • Demonstrators march in the streets after protesting outside of the US Courthouse in Los Angeles, California, after a draft of the court's decision was released several weeks ago. AP
    Demonstrators march in the streets after protesting outside of the US Courthouse in Los Angeles, California, after a draft of the court's decision was released several weeks ago. AP
  • Demonstrators hold placards and shout slogans during an abortion rights protest in Los Angeles. Bloomberg
    Demonstrators hold placards and shout slogans during an abortion rights protest in Los Angeles. Bloomberg
  • Demonstrators protest outside of the US Courthouse in Los Angeles. AP
    Demonstrators protest outside of the US Courthouse in Los Angeles. AP
  • Two police officers are surrounded by a group of abortion rights demonstrators near Pershing Square in Los Angeles. AP
    Two police officers are surrounded by a group of abortion rights demonstrators near Pershing Square in Los Angeles. AP

“What’s ringing in my ears is not the noise of the people here,” said one of the bill’s supporters, Brandon Steele, a Republican state legislator.

“It’s the cries of the unborn, tens of thousands of unborn children that are dead today. Their blood screams from the ground today that you end this scar on our state, that you remove this curse from this land that was put upon us by a court so long ago.”

Others speaking at the public hearing on Wednesday cried, including a woman who claimed that an abortion saved her life and a mother who said her teenage daughter was raped at a sleepover last year.

Updated: July 29, 2022, 4:09 PM