Jaded jurors in Blac Chyna-Kardashian case express disdain for stars' lifestyles

Potential jurors got to tell the Kardashians exactly what they thought about them in a Los Angeles courtroom

NEW YORK, NY - FEBRUARY 11:  Khloe Kardashian, Kris Jenner, Kendall Jenner, Kourtney Kardashian, Kim Kardashian West, North West, Caitlyn Jenner and Kylie Jenner attend Kanye West Yeezy Season 3 at Madison Square Garden on February 11, 2016 in New York City.  (Photo by Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for Yeezy Season 3)
Beta V.1.0 - Powered by automated translation

Talking trash about the Kardashians is a common pastime for many ordinary Americans. On Monday, a few were able to do it to their faces.

Kim Kardashian, her mother Kris Jenner and her sisters Khloe Kardashian and Kylie Jenner sat in the front row of a Los Angeles courtroom as prospective jurors aired their feelings about the the four women, all defendants in a lawsuit brought by Rob Kardashian's former fiancee, Blac Chyna.

“Anything that has to do with their names is just a big no for me,” one man said. “I don’t think reality TV is good for society.”

Chyna, whose legal name is Angela White, is suing the Kardashians, alleging they destroyed her TV career.

During jury selection her lawyer, Lynne Ciani, asked 47 candidates their feelings about the plaintiff and defendants, and the reality shows from which the case stems.

Another said: “I sincerely hope none of these people get any wealthier because of this."

One woman said her teenage daughter tried to watch Keeping up with the Kardashians when it first came on, but she put a stop to it.

“I don't think they were the best role models,” she said. "I wouldn’t let her watch anything involving them.”

One panel member couldn't even wait to be asked. Told to give his name, occupation, marital status and home town shortly after sitting down, he answered then added: “And I just want to say I have a very negative perception of the parties and I'm not sure I could be unbiased."

The defendants did not seem defensive about the disrespect. They chatted with each other and smiled during breaks.

Judge Gregory W Alarcon was not entirely pleased by the tone, however.

“I appreciate your honesty. You’re certainly not shy,” he told the panel. "But this is the type of case, like all cases, where everybody is entitled to a fair trial.

"There’s a jury instruction that says the wealth of a party or the poverty of the party doesn’t matter."

The jury is expected to be seated later on Monday, with opening statements starting on Tuesday.

The Kardashian women are all expected to testify, and had been expected to attend at least parts of it, but their appearance for jury selection was something of a surprise.

Wearing loose-fitting business suits, the mother in white, her daughters in blacks and greys, they were ushered in by security at the last moment before the jury panel was brought in.

One prospective juror, who has served on other cases, said he did not like the pampered treatment he felt the defendants were getting.

Michael Rhodes, the Kardashians' lawyer, said that courthouse security drove them in and escorted them into the courtroom for a reason.

“Do you understand that there is a dark side to celebrity and that people that are famous sometimes need extra security?” Mr Rhodes asked.

“Does that mean that they need Fiji water hand-delivered to them as they sit in court?” the man responded.

The family also had supporters in the room.

“I am a pretty big fan of the Kardashians so I don’t think I would be able to make an unbiased judgment," one young woman said.

“I also am a big fan of the Kardashians," a young man said. "I’ve been watching it since I was little, so I don’t think I could be very fair.”

The Kardashian fans said they knew who Blac Chyna was but had not developed strong feelings about her.

One woman who said she didn't care for the Kardashians liked Chyna because the two went to the same nail salon and she was “always nice to me".

Chyna, a model and influencer, began dating the lone Kardashian brother, Rob, in January 2016, and by the time the year was over they were engaged, had a daughter together and were starring in their own Keeping up with the Kardashians spin-off called Rob & Chyna, on the E! network.

A second season was being shot when the two broke up, and the show was scrapped.

In 2017, Chyna sued the family for $100 million, saying they had defamed her and illegally interfered with her contracts and business dealings, using their power with producers and executives to drive her out of reality TV.

Rob Kardashian with his former fiancee, Blac Chyna. The pair fought publicly over their daughter, Dream. Broadimage/REX/Shutterstock

The Kardashians denied any wrongdoing and said in court filings that they had legitimate concerns about Chyna and fears for the safety of their son and brother given the “violence and toxicity” of the relationship.

Chyna is also suing Rob Kardashian, but the differences in her allegations against him prompted the judge to sever that part of the case into a separate trial that will follow this one.

The family gained fame through 20 seasons of Keeping up with the Kardashians, which ran from 2007 to 2021 on E! and made them social media superstars and prized product pitchers.

Updated: April 20, 2022, 11:26 AM