Nile dam dispute requires UN action, says Egyptian foreign minister

With Ethiopia set to begin filling the reservoir behind the dam next month, the long-running issue is about to come to a head

• 

  A satellite image of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on the Blue Nile river in the Benishangul-Gumuz region of Ethiopia. Maxar Technologies via AP

• 

  A satellite image of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on the Blue Nile river in the Benishangul-Gumuz region of Ethiopia. Maxar Technologies via AP

• 

  A 2013 photo showing the Blue Nile river flowing near the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa in the Benishangul-Gumuz region of Ethiopia. AP, File

• 

  A general view of construction work at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AP, File

• 

  A general view of construction work at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AFP, File

• 

  A general view of construction work at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AFP, File

• 

  Construction workers are seen at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AFP, File

• 

  A general view of construction work at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AFP, File

• 

  A general view of construction work at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AFP, File

• 

  A view of construction work at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AFP, File

• 

  A general view of construction work at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AFP, File

• 

  A general view of construction work at the site of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam near Assosa, Ethiopia. AFP, File

• 

  Sudan's Minister of Irrigation and Water Resources Yasir Mohamed (C) takes part in a video meeting over the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on June 9, 2020. AFP

• 

  Egyptian Foreign Minister Sameh Shukry. AP

• 

  The Nile in the Sudanese capital, Khartoum. AFP

• 

  The Nile in the Sudanese capital, Khartoum. AFP

• 

  The Nile in the Sudanese capital, Khartoum. AFP

• 

  A pleasure boat carrying tourists and locals sails on the Nile at sunset in Aswan, Egypt. AP, file

• 

  Sayed Ahmed Abdoh poles his boat to check fish traps in the Nile, near Abu Al Nasr village, about 770 kilometres south of Cairo, in Egypt. AP, file

• 

  An aerial view shows the Nile before sunset in the Egyptian capital, Cairo. AFP

• 

  An aerial view shows the Nile before sunset in the Egyptian capital, Cairo on June 20, 2020. AFP

Egypt wants the United Nations Security Council to “undertake its responsibilities” and prevent Ethiopia from filling the reservoir for its newly built hydroelectric dam on the Blue Nile next month without an agreement, Egyptian Foreign Minister Sameh Shukry said, accusing Ethiopian officials of stoking antagonism between the countries.

Ethiopia said on Friday that it would begin filling the reservoir in July, although the latest round of talks with Egypt and Sudan last week failed to reach an agreement on how the dam will be filled and operated.

Egypt formally asked the Security Council to intervene in a letter the same day.

"The responsibility of the Security Council is to address a pertinent threat to international peace and security, and certainly the unilateral actions by Ethiopia in this regard would constitute such a threat," Mr Shukry said in an interview with the Associated Press.

Filling the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam could bring the years-long dispute between Egypt, Sudan and Ethiopia over the $4.6 billion mega-project to a head.

Ethiopia said the electricity that will be generated by the dam would be a lifeline that will lift millions out of poverty. With the start of the rainy season in July bringing more water to the Blue Nile, the Nile’s main tributary, Ethiopia wants to start filling the reservoir.

Egypt, which relies on the Nile for more than 90 per cent of its water supplies, fears a devastating impact if the dam is operated without taking its needs into account. Sudan, which also largely depends on the Nile for water, has been caught between the competing interests.

The US this year tried to broker a deal, but Ethiopia did not attend the signing meeting in February and accused Washington of siding with Egypt. Last week, the US National Security Council tweeted that “257 million people in east Africa are relying on Ethiopia to show strong leadership, which means striking a fair deal.”

Egyptian Foreign Minister Sameh Shukry listens during an interview with The Associated Press at his office, in Cairo, Egypt, Sunday, June 21, 2020. Egypt wants the United Nations Security Council to "undertake its responsibilities" and prevent Ethiopia from starting to fill its massive, newly built hydroelectric dam on the Nile River next month amid a breakdown in negotiations, Shukry told The Associated Press on Sunday, accusing Ethiopian officials of stoking antagonism between the countries. (AP Photo/Nariman El-Mofty)

Mr Shukry said that filling the reservoir without an accord would violate the 2015 declaration of principles governing their talks and rule out a return to negotiations.

“We are not seeking any coercive action by the Security Council,” he said.

In a three-page letter to the council, Egypt asked it to call Ethiopia back into talks for a “fair and balanced solution” and to urge it refrain from unilateral acts, saying that filling the dam without a deal “constitutes a clear and present danger to Egypt” with repercussions that “threaten international peace and security”.

Fear that the dispute could escalate into military conflict loomed large, especially as Egypt — facing what it called an existential threat — repeatedly hit dead ends in its attempt to strike a deal.

Commentators in Egypt’s pro-government media have called for action to stop Ethiopia.

Moustafa Al Saeed said in a Facebook post that starting to fill the reservoir would be a “declaration of war” and urged the government to block Ethiopian traffic through the Suez Canal.

Mr Shukry said that the Egyptian government has not threatened military action, has sought a political solution and has worked to convince the Egyptian public that Ethiopia has a right to build the dam to meet its development goals.

“Egypt has never, never over the past six years even made an indirect reference to such possibilities,” he said of military action.

But, he said, if the Security Council cannot bring Ethiopia back into negotiations and filling begins, “We will find ourselves in a situation that we will have to deal with,” he said. “When that time is upon us, we will be very vocal and clear in what action we will take.”

The National

He called on the US and other Security Council members, along with African nations, to help reach a deal that “takes into account the interests of all three countries”.

Sticking points in the talks have been how much water Ethiopia will release downstream from the dam if a years-long drought occurs and how Ethiopia, Egypt and Sudan will resolve any disputes.

William Davison, a senior analyst at the International Crisis Group NGO, said the Security Council taking up the issue was not likely to change Ethiopia’s stance.

“The US, EU, Gulf powers and African Union should try and convince all parties to make the necessary final compromise to get an agreement over the line,” he said.

This month, ministers from the three countries held seven days of negotiations by video conference, but talks ended on Wednesday with no deal. No date was set for a return to the table.

Ethiopian Foreign Minister Gedu Andargachew told the Associated Press on Friday that filling the dam would begin with the rainy season in July and dismissed the need for an agreement. He accused Egypt of trying to “dictate and control even future developments on our river”.

Mr Shukry said that Ethiopia was backing out of agreed points.

“We have on many occasions been flexible and been accommodating. But I can’t say that there is a similar political will on the side of Ethiopia,” he said.

He called Mr Andargachew’s comments “disappointing,” pointing to “the escalation of antagonism that has been intentionally created.” Starting to fill the reservoir now, he said, would demonstrate “a desire to control the flow of the water and have effective sole determination” of the water that reaches Egypt and Sudan.

After the end of talks on Wednesday, Sudan’s irrigation minister said his country and Egypt rejected Ethiopia’s attempts to introduce articles on water sharing in the dam deal. Egypt has received the lion’s share of the Nile’s waters under agreements dating to the British colonial era. Eighty-five per cent of the Nile’s waters originate in Ethiopia from the Blue Nile.

Mr Shukry said Egypt maintained that an agreement can be achieved, but that it “has to be negotiated in good faith”.

He said any deal on shares of the Nile’s water should take into account that Ethiopia has other water sources besides the Nile.