Jose Mourinho and Man United: Two football giants unite to restore faltering reputations

In accepting the challenge of attempting to drag Manchester United out of the doldrums, Jose Mourinho will also seek to restore gloss to his own tainted reputation.

Jose Mourinho has been appointed the new manager of Manchester United. Matt Dunham / AP Photo
Powered by automated translation

In accepting the challenge of attempting to drag Manchester United out of the doldrums, Jose Mourinho will also seek to restore gloss to his own tainted reputation.

Mourinho, 53, is a serial winner, having notably won eight league titles and two Uefa Champions Leagues, but Chelsea’s spectacular collapse over the first half of the recently concluded season resurrected old doubts about his ability to deliver long-term success.

The season also provided recurring reminders of Mourinho’s propensity for controversy and the appointment of the self-styled “Special One” is thought to have been approved despite misgivings about the potential for bad publicity at boardroom level at United.

Discussing Mourinho’s notorious eye-poke on the late Barcelona manager Tito Vilanova during his time at Real Madrid, Bobby Charlton, a United great and club director, once said: “A United manager wouldn’t do that.”

Louis van Gaal, Mourinho’s dismissed predecessor, ultimately paid the price for failing to secure Uefa Champions League qualification, but it was the pedestrian nature of the team’s football that provided a lightning rod for criticism during his two-year tenure.

The European game’s arch pragmatist, Mourinho is not renowned for dashing football and his poor record of promoting young players — one area where Van Gaal enjoyed some success — has been held against him throughout his career.

More from Jose Mourinho’s move to Manchester United:

• Podcast: Jon Turner and Steve Luckings weigh up the pros and cons of Mourinho becoming United manager

• Richard Jolly: Desperate not to be left behind, United had no choice but to replace Van Gaal with Mourinho

Juan Mata's future: First Chelsea, now Man United: Why Mata is once again in danger of the Mourinho axe

United’s two greatest managers, Matt Busby and Alex Ferguson, built their success on youth and the club’s fans are unlikely to react kindly if players like 18-year-old striker Marcus Rashford or teenage full-backs Timothy Fosu-Mensah and Cameron Borthwick-Jackson abruptly disappear from view.

The controversy stoked by Mourinho at Stamford Bridge, meanwhile, has not yet abated, with United’s new manager potentially in line to appear before an employment tribunal next month over his contentious sidelining of Chelsea medic Eva Carneiro.

Of even greater concern to the United hierarchy will be the knowledge that Mourinho’s second stint at Chelsea generated unsustainable levels of friction in the changing room, with technical director Michael Emenalo citing “palpable discord” between manager and players as the chief reason for his December dismissal.

Speaking earlier this season, former AC Milan and England manager Fabio Capello said: “Mourinho burns out his players after a year and a half, at most two years.”

But with United finishing seventh, fourth and fifth in the three seasons since Ferguson retired in 2013, desperation to return the club to title contention appears to have trumped concerns about Mourinho’s ability to establish lasting foundations.

We are delighted to announce Jose Mourinho is our new manager! Full statement: #WelcomeJose

“Jose is quite simply the best manager in the game today,” United’s executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward said on Friday. “He has won trophies and inspired players in countries across Europe and, of course, he knows the Premier League very well, having won three titles here.

“His track record of success is ideal to take the club forward.”

And former United defender Phil Neville said United’s fans will quickly forgive Mourinho’s caustic tendencies if he brings success back to the club.

“He likes to create this siege mentality and that’s what Sir Alex [Ferguson] did for 26 years,” Neville told BBC Radio 5 Live. “Sir Alex did like to create a cause for the fight, with the media and with other managers. If Mourinho does that at United, the fans will take him to their hearts.”

Mourinho had relabelled himself “The Happy One” upon his return to Chelsea, but in his final months at the club he seemed to wear an almost permanent scowl.

Landing the United job, which he has long coveted, is sure to bring a smile back to his face, but frosty departures at first Real Madrid and then Chelsea mean he will not stride through the door with the same swagger that characterised his initial arrival in England from Porto in 2004.

In addition to the challenges facing him at United, his return to management serves up some tantalising clashes with rivals old and new.

At Manchester City he will cross swords again with Pep Guardiola, the former Barcelona coach, with whom he engaged in a titanic and frequently ill-tempered tussle for supremacy in Spain during his time in Madrid.

Long-time Arsenal foe Arsene Wenger also lies in wait, along with fiery Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp, Tottenham Hotspur’s highly-rated coach Mauricio Pochettino and Antonio Conte, his long-term successor at Chelsea.

His first domestic engagement, meanwhile, will be the Community Shield against the Leicester City of Claudio Ranieri, derided as a failure by Mourinho during their time as rival managers with Roma and Inter Milan, but who now possesses the Premier League title.

Follow us on Twitter @NatSportUAE

Like us on Facebook at