Top diplomat Simon McDonald demolishes Boris Johnson Chris Pincher claims

Downing Street’s defence was first ‘not true and the modification is still not accurate’

Boris Johnson and Simon McDonald in 2016. Photo: Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office

Boris Johnson is facing serious questions over his integrity after the former head of the diplomatic service refuted his evidence over the Chris Pincher affair.

In a letter and BBC interview on Tuesday, Lord Simon McDonald contradicted the British Prime Minister’s version of events over the scandal in which the former deputy chief whip was accused of inappropriate physical contact with two men.

The former Foreign Office permanent secretary accused Downing Street of “telling the truth and crossing your fingers at the same time”.

“What I have seen and read over the last few days, I knew to be wrong and things get to a point where you have to do the right thing,” he said.

Lord McDonald is a respected establishment figure who has undertaken a highly unusual intervention that questions the premier’s probity. He retired after a long career that included appointments as ambassador to Germany and Israel, as well as private secretary to the foreign secretary between 2001 and 2003.

When reports first emerged that Mr Pincher had resigned from his ministerial post on Thursday questions were raised over why Mr Johnson had appointed him as a whip in February despite previous complaints.

Downing Street originally said the prime minister was “not aware of any specific allegations” against Mr Pincher.

Education Minister Will Quince was then sent out to defend this line on Monday, stating he had been given a “categorical assurance” that Mr Johnson was unaware of the complaints.

A few hours later, during a Westminster Lobby briefing, journalists were told the issues were now either resolved or did not progress to a formal complaint.

Chris Pincher, MP, who has resigned as a whip over allegations of drunken inappropriate behaviour. Boris Johnson was briefed "in person" about an investigation into the conduct of Pincher when he was a Foreign Office minister, the former permanent secretary at the Foreign Office has said.

On Tuesday, just minutes before Lord McDonald appeared for an interview on the BBC’s Today radio programme, Deputy Prime Minister Dominic Raab said it was news to him that the prime minister had been briefed in person about Mr Pincher’s issues.

He was responding to the devastating letter Lord McDonald wrote to the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards, that he also tweeted.

“The original No 10 line is not true and the modification is still not accurate,” the peer stated. “Mr Johnson was briefed in person about the initiation and outcome of the investigation."

There was a “formal complaint”. Allegations were “resolved” only in the sense that the investigation was completed; Mr Pincher was not exonerated.”

Lord McDonald, 61, told the BBC a senior Cabinet official specifically told him he had informed Mr Johnson of the complaints.

The career diplomat admitted it was “very unusual” for a retired senior civil servant to directly contradict a prime minister but he did so following the apparent dissembling he had witnessed.

Electric intervention

Lord McDonald, a Cambridge University graduate, has effectively demolished Mr Johnson’s position on the issue in the most devastating public fashion.

The diplomat took early retirement from leading the Foreign Office in 2020 after he clashed with Downing Street by suggesting a political decision relating to Brexit resulted in the government not joining the European Union in bulk buying safety equipment and ventilators during the Covid-19 pandemic. Mr Johnson said it was time for new leadership when the Foreign Office merged with the international aid department that year.

British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has succumbed to a rebellion in his ruling Conservative Party and said he would stand down as leader. Reuters

Several crises, including sleaze allegations against a Conservative MP, had increased the pressure on Mr Johnson. Tim Hammond / No 10 Downing Street

More than 50 members of his government, including health secretary Sajid Javid and chancellor of the exchequer Rishi Sunak, have quit. AP

A new Conservative leader will be selected before a party conference is held in October. AP

A protester outside Parliament in London. Getty

Questions are mounting over how much Mr Johnson knew about accusations of misconduct against MP Christopher Pincher. PA

Nadhim Zahawi leaves No 10 Downing Street after being named as the new Chancellor of the Exchequer. Getty

Mr Johnson survived an attempt by Tory MPs to oust him in a vote of confidence in June. PA

Mr Johnson leaves the Houses of Parliament after the vote. Tory MPs voted by 211 to 148 in the secret ballot in Westminster. EPA

Sir Graham Brady, chairman of the 1922 Committee of Tory backbenchers, announcing the result of the vote. PA

A police officer patrols Downing Street on Monday. The vote of no confidence marked the most serious challenge yet to Mr Johnson's three-year tenure as prime minister. EPA

A protester holds up an anti-Boris Johnson placard outside parliament in London. EPA

Boris Johnson reads the long-awaited report by senior civil servant Sue Gray into the Downing Street party scandal. Photo: Andrew Parsons / No 10 Downing Street

A gathering in the Cabinet Room at No 10 Downing Street on Mr Johnson's birthday. Photo: Cabinet Office

Mr Johnson during a gathering held while lockdown rules were in force across the UK. Photo: Cabinet Office

Another gathering at No 10 Downing Street to mark the departure of a special adviser. Photo: Cabinet Office

Mr Johnson apologises to MPs in the House of Commons in April, having been fined after a police probe for attending a party during coronavirus lockdowns imposed by his own government. AFP

Mr Johnson was no more than 30 seconds into his speech when the first shout of 'resign' was heard from the opposition benches, followed by 'you’re an embarrassment' and 'just go'. Reuters

'I take this opportunity on the first available sitting day to repeat my wholehearted apology to the House,' he said, admitting that 'people had a right to expect better of their prime minister'. AFP

The prime minister, pictured with a birthday cake baked for him by school staff at Bovingdon Primary Academy in Hemel Hempstead, said it ‘didn't occur’ to him that a gathering on June 19, 2020 to mark his 56th birthday broke coronavirus rules. AFP

Former Chancellor Rishi Sunak, left, was also fined for attending lockdown parties held in and around Downing Street. AFP

Mr Johnson is the first sitting prime minister to be censured for breaking the law, sparking calls from all sides of parliament, including some in his own party, to step down. Reuters

A lone protester demonstrates at Downing Street in London. EPA

Before the war broke out in Ukraine, Mr Johnson appeared vulnerable to the Partygate controversy. He has been praised by some for his response to the conflict. AFP

Mr Johnson and his wife Carrie applaud health workers outside No 10 Downing Street in May 2020. Getty

Mr Johnson makes a statement in the House of Commons in January on a report regarding the Downing Street parties during lockdown. Reuters

A journalist highlights sections of the Sue Gray report. AFP

Mr Johnson is understood to have been present at six of at least 12 'partygate' events under investigation. One occurred on the eve of Prince Philip’s funeral, at which Queen Elizabeth II had to grieve away from other mourners because of social distancing protocol. Getty

His exposure of Mr Johnson’s position also comes at a particularly perilous time for the prime minster. On Wednesday next week elections will be held for the 1922 Committee that sets the rules for Conservative Party leadership votes. If a majority of anti-Mr Johnson MPs are voted in they are likely to change the rules to enable a second confidence vote. On this occasion, it is entirely possible Mr Johnson could be removed from power.

Following a long list of scandals, including the Partygate affair, Lord McDonald’s evidence might prove the final straw that broke Mr Johnson’s premiership.