Geidt 'wanted no part' in Boris Johnson plan to breach ministerial code

UK prime minister considered action risking deliberate breach of his own ministerial code, Lord Geidt said as he quit as ethics adviser

Lord Christopher Geidt, who has stepped down from his position as UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson's adviser on ministers' interests, a day after he appeared in front of a cross-party committee of MPs. PAShow less

Boris Johnson’s ethics adviser resigned because the British prime minister had put in him an “odious” position by asking him to approve a “deliberate” breach of the ministerial code over a trade issue, it was revealed on Thursday.

Lord Christopher Geidt’s resignation could cause a crisis for Mr Johnson, who is already under severe pressure following the partygate scandal.

This is the second resignation of an ethics adviser to Mr Johnson in the last year, raising questions over his continued role as prime minister.

A brief statement on Lord Geidt's resignation was published on Wednesday evening, but the 21-word statement left the reason for his departure a mystery until the exchange of letters with the prime minister was published as the government came under pressure to provide clarity.

Lord Geidt had already been considering his future in the position following questions over the prime minister’s conduct after he was fined by the police for breaking lockdown rules at a Downing Street party.

The ministerial interests adviser said in his resignation letter to the prime minister that he had been only credibly clinging to the role “by a very small margin” due to partygate.

But in the excoriating letter, he pointedly stated that he could not countenance a “deliberate and purposeful” breach of the ministerial code, implying that Mr Johnson had asked him to approve of this breach, potentially over Chinese steel tariffs.

“A deliberate breach, or even an intention to do so, would be to suspend the provisions of the code to suit a political end,” he wrote.

The resignation letter by Lord Christopher Geidt to Boris Johnson after he stepped down from his position as the prime minister's adviser on ministers' interests. PA

“This would make a mockery not only of respect for the code but licences the suspension of its provisions in governing the conduct of Her Majesty’s ministers. I can have no part in this.

“I therefore resign from this appointment with immediate effect.”

In his response, Mr Johnson said his intention has been to “seek your advice on the national interest protecting a crucial national industry”.

This issue was protected in other European countries and Britain would “suffer material harm if we do not continue to apply such tariffs”.

Downing Street has cited “commercial sensitivity” in not naming what the tariff issue might be, which could indicate Britain would have been in breach of World Trade Organisation rules.

But the prime minister’s official spokesman told the media that it was “a critical national industry at risk of material harm if the government does not take action, affecting businesses and livelihoods”.

“You will appreciate it remains a level of commercial sensitivity to a specific issue which both Lord Geidt and the prime minister referred to in their exchange of letters,” he said.

Downing Street insisted the dispute was not linked to the financial interests of Mr Johnson or any minister.

The spokesman confirmed Mr Johnson was “surprised” after being informed of Lord Geidt's resignation on Wednesday afternoon.

Mr Johnson’s letter said the issue concerned “potential future decisions” by the Trade Remedies Authority, which investigates whether new remedies are required to prevent injury to British industries caused by unfair trading practices.

While the government has refused to disclose the issue, there is a suggestion it could be related to tariffs on Chinese steel which the authority had recommended removing.

This led to protests from Britain’s steel industry, and the Department of Trade and Industry overruled the authority.

Lord Geidt also referred to Mr Johnson’s failure to address whether he broke the ministerial code when he made his statement to Parliament on partygate.

“Despite being repeatedly questioned in the House of Commons about your obligations under the ministerial code (after paying a fixed penalty notice), your responses again made no reference to it,” he wrote.

Fleur Anderson, the Labour frontbench MP who raised an Urgent Question in Parliament over the resignation, called it an “embarrassment” that “degraded” Britain’s democracy.

“The prime minister has now driven out of his hand-picked ethics advisers to resign in despair — it's a badge of shame for this government,” she added.

Lord Geidt’s letter of resignation in full

This is Lord Geidt’s letter of resignation to Mr Johnson.

Dear Prime Minister,

I appeared before the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee in Parliament yesterday. I was glad for the opportunity to give an account of the recent changes to the Ministerial Code, to the Terms of Reference of the Independent Adviser and to the support for the Office of the Independent Adviser.

I was asked at length about my recent annual report. I alluded to my frustration, as made clear in my preface, that you had not made any public reference to your own conduct under the Ministerial Code in the period since inquiries were under way. This would be especially important in the event that the Metropolitan Police found against you, which they did, and/or that Sue Gray’s report included criticism of behaviour within the scope of the Ministerial Code, which it did.

Your letter in response to my annual report was welcome. It addressed the absence of comment by you about your obligations under that Ministerial Code up until that point. You explained that, by paying a fixed term penalty, you had not breached the Ministerial Code. The letter did not, however, address specifically the criticism in Sue Gray’s report about your adherence to the Nolan Principles (on leadership, in particular). Neither did the letter make mention that, despite being repeatedly questioned in the House of Commons about your obligations under the Ministerial Code (after paying a fixed penalty notice), your responses again made no reference to it.

I reported to the select committee yesterday that I was satisfied that you had responded to my annual report to explain your position. I am disappointed, however, that the account you gave was not fuller, as noted above. Moreover, I regret the reference to “miscommunication” between our offices, with the implication that I was somehow responsible for you not being fully aware of my concerns. These inconsistencies and deficiencies notwithstanding, I believed that it was possible to continue credibly as independent adviser, albeit by a very small margin.

This week, however, I was tasked to offer a view about the government’s intention to consider measures which risk a deliberate and purposeful breach of the Ministerial Code. This request has placed me in an impossible and odious position. My informal response on Monday was that you and any other minister should justify openly your position vis-a-vis the code in such circumstances. However, the idea that a prime minister might to any degree be in the business of deliberately breaching his own code is an affront. A deliberate breach, or even an intention to do so, would be to suspend the provisions of the code to suit a political end. This would make a mockery not only of respect for the code but licence the suspension of its provisions in governing the conduct of Her Majesty’s ministers. I can have no part in this. Because of my obligation as a witness in Parliament, this is the first opportunity I have had to act on the government’s intentions. I therefore resign from this appointment with immediate effect.

Yours Sincerely,

The Rt Hon Lord Geidt

Independent Adviser on Ministers’ Interests

• 

  Boris Johnson has had an eventful time during his life in politics and journalism. Here, 'The National' looks back at his life in pictures. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson attends the coronation ceremony of Britain's King Charles III at Westminster Abbey in May. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson leaves his home to attend a televised evidence session in March in front of the Commons Privileges Committee. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson listening to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy address parliamentarians in Westminster Hall in February. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson and Carrie Johnson arrive at Westminster Abbey for the state funeral of Queen Elizabeth II in September 2022. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson he announces his resignation as prime minister outside 10 Downing Street in July 2022. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson at a press conference in response to the publication of the Sue Gray report into Partygate at Downing Street in May 2022. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson reads the long-awaited report by senior civil servant Sue Gray into the Downing Street party scandal, in his Downing Street office in May 2022. Photo: Downing Street

• 

  Mr Johnson and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in central Kyiv in April 2022. The British prime minister paid an unannounced visit to Kyiv in a show of solidarity with Ukraine. AFP

• 

  Mr Johnson watches an early morning police raid on a home in Liverpool as part of an operation to thwart drug dealing, in December, 2021. Getty Images

• 

  The prime minister battles with his umbrella while with Prince Charles at The National Memorial Arboretum in July 2021, in Stafford, England. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson and his wife before the Uefa European Championship final between Italy and England at Wembley Stadium, London, in July last year. Getty Images

• 

  The British prime minister with US President Joe Biden, European Council President Charles Michel, former Japanese prime minister Yoshihide Suga and Italian Prime Minister Mario Draghi during the G7 Summit in Cornwall, in June 2021. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson with his wife Carrie in the garden of 10 Downing Street after their wedding at Westminster Cathedral, in May last year. Getty Images

• 

  Boris Johnson visits Hartlepool after Conservative Party candidate Jill Mortimer won a parliamentary by-election in May, 2021. Getty Images

• 

  The prime minister after receiving the first dose of the AstraZeneca vaccine at St Thomas' Hospital in London in March, 2021. Getty Images

• 

  Boris Johnson after signing a Brexit trade deal with the EU in December 2020. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson examines a vial of the AstraZeneca Covid-19 candidate vaccine, at a pharmaceutical manufacturing facility in Wrexham, Wales, in November 2020. Getty

• 

  Mr Johnson demonstrating the two-metre distancing rule during his visit to St Joseph's Catholic Primary School in Upminster, East London, in August 2020. PA

• 

  In this photo, published alongside the Sue Gray report into the Partygate affair, Mr Johnson is seen at a gathering in the Cabinet Room in 10 Downing Street on his birthday in June, 2020. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson and former chancellor Rishi Sunak use hand sanitiser during a visit to the Pizza Pilgrims restaurant in June 2020, in east London, to see how they are getting their business ready to reopen as coronavirus lockdown restrictions were lifted in England. PA

• 

  Mr Johnson and his fiancee Carrie Symonds applaud key workers outside 10 Downing Street in May 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson in the Cabinet Room observing a minute's silence in April 2020 in a tribute to the health staff and key workers who died during the coronavirus outbreak. PA

• 

  Boris Johnson appears on monitors for a meeting in March 2020. The prime minister chaired morning meetings on the coronavirus remotely from Number 11 Downing Street, while self-isolating after testing positive for the virus. Reuters

• 

  Members of a family listen as BMr ris Johnson makes a televised address to the nation from 10 Downing Street in March 2020, where he outlined the latest instructions to stay at home to help contain the Covid-19 outbreak. AFP

• 

  Mr Johnson speaks to British troops stationed in Estonia during a one-day visit to the Baltic country in December 2019. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson and Carrie Symonds enter Downing Street as the Conservatives celebrate a sweeping election victory in December 2019. Getty

• 

  Boris Johnson is greeted by staff at 10 Downing Street after meeting Queen Elizabeth II and accepting her invitation to form a new government in December 2012. PA

• 

  Former US president Donald Trump and Mr Johnson arrive for a bilateral meeting during the G7 summit in August 2019 in Biarritz, France. Getty

• 

  The queen welcomes Mr Johnson as the newly elected leader of the Conservative Party, during an audience in July 2019. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson, then Britain's foreign secretary, stands in front of St Basil's Cathedral during a visit to Moscow's Red Square in December 2017. Getty

• 

  Mr Johnson collides with a child during a Street Rugby tournament in Tokyo in 2015, held to mark Japan hosting the 2019 Rugby World Cup

• 

  As mayor of London Mr Johnson competes in a tug-of-war in October 2015. Getty Images

• 

  The Olympic Flag is passed from Mr Johnson to IOC President Jacques Rogge during the closing ceremony of the London 2012 Olympic Games. Getty Images

• 

  Mayor of London Boris Johnson with Prime Minister David Cameron during the lighting of the Paralympic Cauldron in Trafalgar Square, in August 2012. PA

• 

  Boris Johnson gets stuck on a zip-line during a BT London Live event in Victoria Park in August 2012. Getty

• 

  Mr Johnson and Lord Sebastian Coe cheer as a giant set of Olympic rings is displayed from Tower Bridge in June 2012, Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson gestures attends a Harry Potter studio tour of Diagon Alley, at the Warner Brother Studios, London, in December 2011. AP Photo

• 

  Mr Johnson at the launch of London's first cycle hire scheme in July 2010. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson with artists' impressions of the design for London's new Routemaster bus in May 2010. Getty Images

• 

  The candidates to be mayor of London; Labour's Ken Livingstone, Conservative Boris Johnson and Liberal Democrat Brian Paddick, being questioned on BBC's 'Newsnight' programme in April 2008. Getty Images

• 

  Boris Johnson on the North Pier in Blackpool during the Conservative Party conference there in October 2005. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson at his desk in 2000 while he was a journalist for 'The Telegraph'. Getty Images

• 

  Mr Johnson when he was president of the Oxford Union society speaking to the Greek minister for culture Melina Mercouri when she addressed the union. Reuters

• 

  Boris Johnson in September 1979, at Eton School. Shutterstock

Boris Johnson’s letter in response to Lord Geidt in full

Here is Mr Johnson’s letter responding to the resignation of Lord Geidt as his ministerial interests adviser in full:

Dear Lord Geidt,

I was sorry to receive your letter of resignation yesterday. I want to thank you for your service. When we spoke on Monday, you said that you were content to remain until the end of the year. So your letter came as a surprise.

You say that you were put in an impossible position regarding my seeking your advice on potential future decisions related to the Trade Remedies Authority. My intention was to seek your advice on the national interest in protecting a crucial industry, which is protected in other European countries and would suffer material harm if we do not continue to apply such tariffs. This has in the past had cross party support. It would be in line with our domestic law but might be seen to conflict with our obligations under the [World Trade Organisation]. In seeking your advice before any decision was taken, I was looking to ensure that we acted properly with due regard to the Ministerial code.

You have carried out your duties admirably under very difficult circumstances. We have discussed the burdens placed on you by this increasingly public role, and the pressures that would be felt by anyone in your position. On behalf of the government, I would like to renew my thanks for all your work.

Yours sincerely,

Boris Johnson