• TOPSHOT - A woman holds a child while sitting in the back of a minibus transporting Syrian refugees who have been newly refugees by the Turkish military operation in northeastern Syria upon arriving at the Bardarash camp, near the Kurdish city of Dohuk, in Iraq's autonomous Kurdish region, on October 16, 2019. Some 500 Syrian Kurds have entered neighbouring Iraqi Kurdistan over the past four days fleeing a Turkish invasion now entering its second week, officials said. Iraqi Kurdistan previously hosted more than one million Iraqis who fled fighting with the jihadists of the Islamic State group between 2014 and 2017. / AFP / Safin HAMED
    TOPSHOT - A woman holds a child while sitting in the back of a minibus transporting Syrian refugees who have been newly refugees by the Turkish military operation in northeastern Syria upon arriving at the Bardarash camp, near the Kurdish city of Dohuk, in Iraq's autonomous Kurdish region, on October 16, 2019. Some 500 Syrian Kurds have entered neighbouring Iraqi Kurdistan over the past four days fleeing a Turkish invasion now entering its second week, officials said. Iraqi Kurdistan previously hosted more than one million Iraqis who fled fighting with the jihadists of the Islamic State group between 2014 and 2017. / AFP / Safin HAMED
  • Men help an elderly woman after disembarking from a minibus transporting Syrians who have been recently-turned refugees by the Turkish military operation in northeastern Syria upon arriving at the Bardarash camp, near the Kurdish city of Dohuk, in Iraq's autonomous Kurdish region, on October 16, 2019. Some 500 Syrian Kurds have entered neighbouring Iraqi Kurdistan over the past four days fleeing a Turkish invasion now entering its second week, officials said. Iraqi Kurdistan previously hosted more than one million Iraqis who fled fighting with the jihadists of the Islamic State group between 2014 and 2017. / AFP / Safin HAMED
    Men help an elderly woman after disembarking from a minibus transporting Syrians who have been recently-turned refugees by the Turkish military operation in northeastern Syria upon arriving at the Bardarash camp, near the Kurdish city of Dohuk, in Iraq's autonomous Kurdish region, on October 16, 2019. Some 500 Syrian Kurds have entered neighbouring Iraqi Kurdistan over the past four days fleeing a Turkish invasion now entering its second week, officials said. Iraqi Kurdistan previously hosted more than one million Iraqis who fled fighting with the jihadists of the Islamic State group between 2014 and 2017. / AFP / Safin HAMED
  • epa07925962 Kurdish Syrian refugees fleeing the Turkish military operation in Syria arrive to Bradasrsh Refugee camp, in Duhok, Kurdistan Region of Iraq, 16 October 2019. Some 280 refugee arrived to Duhok. EPA/GAILAN HAJI
    epa07925962 Kurdish Syrian refugees fleeing the Turkish military operation in Syria arrive to Bradasrsh Refugee camp, in Duhok, Kurdistan Region of Iraq, 16 October 2019. Some 280 refugee arrived to Duhok. EPA/GAILAN HAJI
  • epa07925988 Kurdish Syrian refugees fleeing the Turkish military operation in Syria arrive to Bradasrsh Refugee camp, in Duhok, Kurdistan Region of Iraq, 16 October 2019. Some 280 refugee arrived to Duhok. EPA/GAILAN HAJI
    epa07925988 Kurdish Syrian refugees fleeing the Turkish military operation in Syria arrive to Bradasrsh Refugee camp, in Duhok, Kurdistan Region of Iraq, 16 October 2019. Some 280 refugee arrived to Duhok. EPA/GAILAN HAJI
  • epa07925953 Workers prepare tents before Kurdish Syrian refugees fleeing the Turkish military operation in Syria arrive to Bradasrsh Refugee camp, in Duhok, Kurdistan Region of Iraq, 16 October 2019. Some 280 refugee arrived to Duhok. EPA/GAILAN HAJI
    epa07925953 Workers prepare tents before Kurdish Syrian refugees fleeing the Turkish military operation in Syria arrive to Bradasrsh Refugee camp, in Duhok, Kurdistan Region of Iraq, 16 October 2019. Some 280 refugee arrived to Duhok. EPA/GAILAN HAJI
  • People holding children disembark from a minibus transporting Syrians who have been recently-turned refugees by the Turkish military operation in northeastern Syria upon arriving at the Bardarash camp, near the Kurdish city of Dohuk, in Iraq's autonomous Kurdish region, on October 16, 2019. Some 500 Syrian Kurds have entered neighbouring Iraqi Kurdistan over the past four days fleeing a Turkish invasion now entering its second week, officials said. Iraqi Kurdistan previously hosted more than one million Iraqis who fled fighting with the jihadists of the Islamic State group between 2014 and 2017. / AFP / Safin HAMED
    People holding children disembark from a minibus transporting Syrians who have been recently-turned refugees by the Turkish military operation in northeastern Syria upon arriving at the Bardarash camp, near the Kurdish city of Dohuk, in Iraq's autonomous Kurdish region, on October 16, 2019. Some 500 Syrian Kurds have entered neighbouring Iraqi Kurdistan over the past four days fleeing a Turkish invasion now entering its second week, officials said. Iraqi Kurdistan previously hosted more than one million Iraqis who fled fighting with the jihadists of the Islamic State group between 2014 and 2017. / AFP / Safin HAMED
  • TOPSHOT - Kurdish Syrian civilians flee the town of Kobani on the Turkish border on October 16, 2019 as Turkey and its allies continue their assault on Kurdish-held border towns in northeastern Syria. Turkey rebuffed international pressure to curb its military offensive against Kurdish militants in Syria today as US President Donald Trump dispatched his deputy Mike Pence to Ankara to demand a ceasefire. / AFP / Bakr ALKASEM
    TOPSHOT - Kurdish Syrian civilians flee the town of Kobani on the Turkish border on October 16, 2019 as Turkey and its allies continue their assault on Kurdish-held border towns in northeastern Syria. Turkey rebuffed international pressure to curb its military offensive against Kurdish militants in Syria today as US President Donald Trump dispatched his deputy Mike Pence to Ankara to demand a ceasefire. / AFP / Bakr ALKASEM

Escape from Qamishli: the night that independent Kurdish Syria died in a deal


Gareth Browne
  • English
  • Arabic

It is not uncommon for the internet and phone networks to go down in north-east Syria.

There are Turkish frontlines barely a few hours drive from the border city of Qamishli and the flickering lights of the Turkish town of Nusaybin just over the frontier remind you of Ankara’s loom over Syria’s autonomous Kurdish region.

So when all connections died shortly after filing my report for the day, I simply wandered to a nearby hotel where the internet is usually more reliable.

“In two hours, this street could be under regime control,” another journalist leaving the hotel said as I entered.

It was a sentence that would set in motion a whirlwind 12 hours for Kurdish-controlled Syria and for me personally.

The grinding eight-year Syrian civil war abruptly changed direction and the landscape of the conflict was redrawn in just hours thanks to a deal.

The long-threatened Turkish offensive was in its fifth day and Ankara-backed forces looked set to take control of two key border towns.

But on Sunday evening, the city’s streets were quieter than usual.

The patrols of Kurdish fighters and Asayish plain-clothed officers sporting their Kalashnikovs were greatly reduced, almost non-existent.

For a moment, my phone connected to a Turkish phone tower on the other side of the border and a flurry of messages pinged.

“Mazloum [Head of the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF)] is on a Russian base now drinking tea,” read one.

Barely an hour later, Kurdish officials would announce a deal for the Syrian government to take control of a number of cities and towns and to deploy troops in a bid to beat back the Turkish-led offensive.

Kobane, a place synonymous with the fight against ISIS, was among the towns to be handed over.

It was a deal that saw the Kurds give away much of the territory they have fought for the past six years to take back from ISIS. Beyond their survival, there were few details of what the government in Damascus had given in return.

The SDF, without their primary international backer Washington who had pulled troops back to make way for the Turkish assault, were in too frail a position to be laying down demands.

SDF leadership insists the deal was the only alternative to being wiped-out by Turkish forces.

It was, they said, a choice between concession or extinction.

But the deal also brought worry.

The regime has a track record of exacting revenge and settling scores in areas it recaptures.

The National
The National

But more personally, the regime has a terrible reputation with the press and sees foreign journalists entering any areas of Syria without almost impossible to secure accreditation from Damascus as fair game for arrest.

As we throttle out of Qamishli, barely 20 minutes after that initial WhatsApp ping, I’m struck by the feeling that the experiment that was the statelet of Rojava – whatever one thinks of it – is collapsing in front of me in a matter of hours, at the whim of international powers.

Every time the silhouettes of soldiers manning another checkpoint come into view, our driver slows as he squints into the dark. Is the position held by the SDF, the Kurdish YPG fighters or had government troops already got so far north?

In Qamishli, the government has held parts of the city centre city all through the war, but now there were reports of new regime checkpoints popping up across the area.

One of Syria’s most stable and secure areas was suddenly unpredictable. Given the increased dangers for the international press, and those working with it, almost all journalists pulled out.

Kurdish officials continue to insist nothing has changed for the media and nothing has changed for the administration or security of cities. Senior Kurdish official Alder Xelil said on Monday that “Rojava lives on”.

But it remains to be seen whether a regime that takes as naturally to deception as Damascus does can be trusted to honour their deal.

  • Members of Turkish-backed Free Syrian Army, a militant group active in parts of northwest Syria, load their goods after shopping from a market to their vehicle in Akcakale, Turkey. The military action is part of a campaign to extend Turkish control of more of northern Syria, a large swath of which is currently held by Syrian Kurds, whom Turkey regards as a threat. U.S. President Donald Trump granted tacit American approval to this campaign, withdrawing his country's troops from several Syrian outposts near the Turkish border. Getty Images
    Members of Turkish-backed Free Syrian Army, a militant group active in parts of northwest Syria, load their goods after shopping from a market to their vehicle in Akcakale, Turkey. The military action is part of a campaign to extend Turkish control of more of northern Syria, a large swath of which is currently held by Syrian Kurds, whom Turkey regards as a threat. U.S. President Donald Trump granted tacit American approval to this campaign, withdrawing his country's troops from several Syrian outposts near the Turkish border. Getty Images
  • Members of Turkish-backed Free Syrian Army, a militant group active in parts of northwest Syria, load their goods after shopping from a market to their vehicle Akcakale, Turkey. Getty Images
    Members of Turkish-backed Free Syrian Army, a militant group active in parts of northwest Syria, load their goods after shopping from a market to their vehicle Akcakale, Turkey. Getty Images
  • Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan (L) greets his supporters before he addresses members of the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) at their group meeting at the parliament in Ankara. EPA
    Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan (L) greets his supporters before he addresses members of the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) at their group meeting at the parliament in Ankara. EPA
  • Syrian displaced families, who fled violence after the Turkish offensive against Syria, sit in a bus on their way to camps on the outskirts of Dohuk, Iraq. REUTERS
    Syrian displaced families, who fled violence after the Turkish offensive against Syria, sit in a bus on their way to camps on the outskirts of Dohuk, Iraq. REUTERS
  • Buses carry Syrian displaced families, who fled violence after the Turkish offensive against Syria, to displacement camps on the outskirts of Dohuk, Iraq. REUTERS
    Buses carry Syrian displaced families, who fled violence after the Turkish offensive against Syria, to displacement camps on the outskirts of Dohuk, Iraq. REUTERS
  • Smoke billows out after Turkish shelling on the Syrian town of Ras al Ain, as seen from the Turkish border town of Ceylanpinar, in Sanliurfa province, Turkey. REUTERS
    Smoke billows out after Turkish shelling on the Syrian town of Ras al Ain, as seen from the Turkish border town of Ceylanpinar, in Sanliurfa province, Turkey. REUTERS
  • Workers set a tent in preparation to receive a few hundred Syrian refugees who have been newly displaced by the Turkish military operation in northeastern Syria, at the Bardarash camp, north of Mosul, Iraq. The camp used to host Iraqis displaced from Mosul during the fight against the Islamic State group and was closed two years ago. The U.N. says more around 160,000 Syrians have been displaced since the Turkish operation started last week, most of them internally in Syria. AP Photo
    Workers set a tent in preparation to receive a few hundred Syrian refugees who have been newly displaced by the Turkish military operation in northeastern Syria, at the Bardarash camp, north of Mosul, Iraq. The camp used to host Iraqis displaced from Mosul during the fight against the Islamic State group and was closed two years ago. The U.N. says more around 160,000 Syrians have been displaced since the Turkish operation started last week, most of them internally in Syria. AP Photo
  • Syrian locals, carrying Syrian flags, cheer for the Syrian army in the city of Manbej and its surroundings in Aleppo provinces northeastern countryside, Syria. According to media reports, the soldiers were welcomed by the locals, who have gathered in the city center, carrying Syrian flags and cheering for the army which came to encounter the Turkish aggression. EPA
    Syrian locals, carrying Syrian flags, cheer for the Syrian army in the city of Manbej and its surroundings in Aleppo provinces northeastern countryside, Syria. According to media reports, the soldiers were welcomed by the locals, who have gathered in the city center, carrying Syrian flags and cheering for the army which came to encounter the Turkish aggression. EPA
  • Syrian locals, carrying Syrian flags, cheer for the Syrian army in the city of Manbej and its surroundings in Aleppo provinces northeastern countryside, Syria. According to media reports, the soldiers were welcomed by the locals, who have gathered in the city center, carrying Syrian flags and cheering for the army which came to encounter the Turkish aggression. EPA
    Syrian locals, carrying Syrian flags, cheer for the Syrian army in the city of Manbej and its surroundings in Aleppo provinces northeastern countryside, Syria. According to media reports, the soldiers were welcomed by the locals, who have gathered in the city center, carrying Syrian flags and cheering for the army which came to encounter the Turkish aggression. EPA
  • A Syrian soldier and a local man cheer after the Syrian Arab Army completed its deployment in the city of Manbej and its surroundings in Aleppo provinces northeastern countryside, Syria. According to media reports, the soldiers were welcomed by the locals, who have gathered in the city center, carrying Syrian flags and cheering for the army which came to encounter the Turkish aggression. EPA
    A Syrian soldier and a local man cheer after the Syrian Arab Army completed its deployment in the city of Manbej and its surroundings in Aleppo provinces northeastern countryside, Syria. According to media reports, the soldiers were welcomed by the locals, who have gathered in the city center, carrying Syrian flags and cheering for the army which came to encounter the Turkish aggression. EPA
  • Syrian government soldiers hold up portraits of President Bashar al-Assad while flashing the victory gesture at a position on the outskirts of the northern city of Manbij in the north of Aleppo province as government forces deploy there. AFP
    Syrian government soldiers hold up portraits of President Bashar al-Assad while flashing the victory gesture at a position on the outskirts of the northern city of Manbij in the north of Aleppo province as government forces deploy there. AFP
  • Syrian government forces walk past media crew vehicles at a position on the outskirts of the northern city of Manbij in the north of Aleppo province, as government forces deploy there. AFP
    Syrian government forces walk past media crew vehicles at a position on the outskirts of the northern city of Manbij in the north of Aleppo province, as government forces deploy there. AFP
  • Turkish soldiers waiting to enter Syria walk past a truck transporting armoured personnel carriers at the border with Syria in Karkamis, Gaziantep province, southeastern Turkey. Turkey defied growing condemnation from its NATO allies to press ahead with its invasion of northern Syria on Tuesday, shelling suspected Kurdish positions near the border amid reports that Syrian Kurds had retaken a key town. AP Photo
    Turkish soldiers waiting to enter Syria walk past a truck transporting armoured personnel carriers at the border with Syria in Karkamis, Gaziantep province, southeastern Turkey. Turkey defied growing condemnation from its NATO allies to press ahead with its invasion of northern Syria on Tuesday, shelling suspected Kurdish positions near the border amid reports that Syrian Kurds had retaken a key town. AP Photo
  • People stand near vehicles in the city of Manbij, Syria. REUTERS
    People stand near vehicles in the city of Manbij, Syria. REUTERS
  • Trucks loaded with humanitarian aid are seen heading to Syria for displaced families who fled violence, at the Iraqi-Syrian border crossing in Fish-Khabur, Iraq. REUTERS
    Trucks loaded with humanitarian aid are seen heading to Syria for displaced families who fled violence, at the Iraqi-Syrian border crossing in Fish-Khabur, Iraq. REUTERS
  • A syrian displaced woman is seen with her child, who fled violence after the Turkish offensive against Syria, at the Domiz refugee camp on the outskirts of Dohuk, Iraq. REUTERS
    A syrian displaced woman is seen with her child, who fled violence after the Turkish offensive against Syria, at the Domiz refugee camp on the outskirts of Dohuk, Iraq. REUTERS
  • Syrian displaced children who fled violence after the Turkish offensive against Syria, arrived at the Domiz refugee camp on the outskirts of Dohuk, Iraq. REUTERS
    Syrian displaced children who fled violence after the Turkish offensive against Syria, arrived at the Domiz refugee camp on the outskirts of Dohuk, Iraq. REUTERS
  • People stand in a queue to receive bread from Turkey-backed Syrian rebel fighters in the border town of Tal Abyad, Syria. REUTERS
    People stand in a queue to receive bread from Turkey-backed Syrian rebel fighters in the border town of Tal Abyad, Syria. REUTERS
  • A man holds stacks of bread that was provided by Turkey-backed Syrian rebel fighters in the border town of Tal Abyad, Syria. REUTERS
    A man holds stacks of bread that was provided by Turkey-backed Syrian rebel fighters in the border town of Tal Abyad, Syria. REUTERS
  • This picture taken from the Turkish side of the border at Ceylanpinar district in Sanliurfa shows smoke rising from the Syrian town of Ras al-Ain on the first week of Turkey's military operation against Kurdish forces. The United States is not aware of any "major" escape of Islamic State extremists since Turkey launched its assault on Syrian Kurdish fighters holding the prisoners, an official said Tuesday. AFP
    This picture taken from the Turkish side of the border at Ceylanpinar district in Sanliurfa shows smoke rising from the Syrian town of Ras al-Ain on the first week of Turkey's military operation against Kurdish forces. The United States is not aware of any "major" escape of Islamic State extremists since Turkey launched its assault on Syrian Kurdish fighters holding the prisoners, an official said Tuesday. AFP
  • This picture taken shows a missile fired by Turkish forces towards the Syrian town of Ras al-Ain, from the Turkish side of the border at Ceylanpinar district in Sanliurfa on the first week of Turkey's military operation against Kurdish forces. The United States is not aware of any "major" escape of Islamic State extremists since Turkey launched its assault on Syrian Kurdish fighters holding the prisoners, an official said Tuesday. AFP
    This picture taken shows a missile fired by Turkish forces towards the Syrian town of Ras al-Ain, from the Turkish side of the border at Ceylanpinar district in Sanliurfa on the first week of Turkey's military operation against Kurdish forces. The United States is not aware of any "major" escape of Islamic State extremists since Turkey launched its assault on Syrian Kurdish fighters holding the prisoners, an official said Tuesday. AFP
  • Boys ride on bicycles in the border town of Tal Abyad, Syria. REUTERS
    Boys ride on bicycles in the border town of Tal Abyad, Syria. REUTERS
  • Syrian government forces arrive in the town of Tal Tamr, not far from the flashpoint Kurdish Syrian town of Ras al-Ain on the border with Turkey, which has been a key target of Turkish forces and their proxies since they launched their military assault. Syrian regime troops arrived after Damascus deployed troops to the country's north to contain a days-long Turkish offensive. AFP
    Syrian government forces arrive in the town of Tal Tamr, not far from the flashpoint Kurdish Syrian town of Ras al-Ain on the border with Turkey, which has been a key target of Turkish forces and their proxies since they launched their military assault. Syrian regime troops arrived after Damascus deployed troops to the country's north to contain a days-long Turkish offensive. AFP
  • Syrian government forces arrive in the town of Tal Tamr, not far from the flashpoint Kurdish Syrian town of Ras al-Ain on the border with Turkey, which has been a key target of Turkish forces and their proxies since they launched their military assault. Syrian regime troops arrived after Damascus deployed troops to the country's north to contain a days-long Turkish offensive. AFP
    Syrian government forces arrive in the town of Tal Tamr, not far from the flashpoint Kurdish Syrian town of Ras al-Ain on the border with Turkey, which has been a key target of Turkish forces and their proxies since they launched their military assault. Syrian regime troops arrived after Damascus deployed troops to the country's north to contain a days-long Turkish offensive. AFP
  • In this photo Turkey's forces advance towards Manbij, Syria. U.S. military spokesman says U.S. forces have left Kurdish-held town of Manbij, part of withdrawal from northeast Syria. AP
    In this photo Turkey's forces advance towards Manbij, Syria. U.S. military spokesman says U.S. forces have left Kurdish-held town of Manbij, part of withdrawal from northeast Syria. AP
  • Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, center, is surrounded by journalists and pro-government academicians in his plane en route back from Baku, Azerbaijan. The White House announced Tuesday that Vice President Mike Pence will travel to Ankara, Turkey on behalf of President Donald Trump and meet with Erdogan. AP
    Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, center, is surrounded by journalists and pro-government academicians in his plane en route back from Baku, Azerbaijan. The White House announced Tuesday that Vice President Mike Pence will travel to Ankara, Turkey on behalf of President Donald Trump and meet with Erdogan. AP

But more pressing on Sunday night was the question of what happens to Semelka border crossing with Iraq’s Kurdistan Regional Government.

The border point has been the way through for journalists reporting the fall of ISIS and its aftermath.

But it’s also been a lifeline to independence with officials travelling overseas, families coming back and forth and trade moving across away from the auspices of either Damascus or Turkey.

With suggestions that government forces may be heading to take this exit point as well, a move that would have left us trapped in the country, Sunday night turned into a race to Semelka.

Yet whilst the foreign press corps were able to flee, it was not the case for many local journalists and fixers.

Many of them have avoided the government’s draconian and deadly conscription policies but that might change with Damascus’ return. My fixer said he most feared being forced to fight in the army.

It’s still premature to judge whether the Rojava experiment is dead. But if it lives on, it will do in a dramatically different fashion under the patronage of Russia and Damascus.

The Kurdish autonomous region in this corner of Syria has bought a semblance of stability, and breathing space for a relatively normal, if flawed, statelet to function.

At the same time, it was inherently perceived as an existential threat by Ankara, a fact many of its with which many of its key apologists repeatedly failed to engage.

I recall sitting in a UK Foreign Affairs Select Committee grilling of then foreign ministry official for the Middle East Alistair Burt last year. An otherwise competent minister, well-versed in his brief bumbled around direct questioning on the SDF’s links to the PKK – a guerrilla group that has waged an insurgency against the Turkish state for decades.

His response was an indicator of the wider flaws in the international approach to Rojava and the failure to address the central tension between an internationally backed force loathed by a Nato ally.

The SDF leadership has opted to put its faith in Bashar Al Assad, and his backers in Moscow. But it was a decision made in desperation, and, as many who had fled fighting in Ras Al Ain told me on Saturday, there was still hope the US will come to the rescue. Despite all that has happened, there was still faith in Washington.

The entire international press corps left north-east Syria in a matter of hours on Sunday, but the Rojava experiment looks like it will limp on, cameras or not. That said, whatever remains of the project from here, it is set to be very, very different.