Manchester United's English striker Marcus Rashford (C) shoots to score from the penalty spot for the opening goal during the English Premier League football match between Manchester United and Chelsea at Old Trafford in Manchester, north west England, on August 11, 2019. RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or 'live' services. Online in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No video emulation. Social media in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No use in betting publications, games or single club/league/player publications. / AFP / Oli SCARFF / RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or 'live' services. Online in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No video emulation. Social media in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No use in betting publications, games or single club/league/player publications.
Manchester United's English striker Marcus Rashford (C) shoots to score from the penalty spot for the opening goal during the English Premier League football match between Manchester United and Chelsea at Old Trafford in Manchester, north west England, on August 11, 2019. RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or 'live' services. Online in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No video emulation. Social media in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No use in betting publications, games or single club/league/player publications. / AFP / Oli SCARFF / RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or 'live' services. Online in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No video emulation. Social media in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No use in betting publications, games or single club/league/player publications.
Manchester United's English striker Marcus Rashford (C) shoots to score from the penalty spot for the opening goal during the English Premier League football match between Manchester United and Chelsea at Old Trafford in Manchester, north west England, on August 11, 2019. RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or 'live' services. Online in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No video emulation. Social media in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No use in betting publications, games or single club/league/player publications. / AFP / Oli SCARFF / RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or 'live' services. Online in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No video emulation. Social media in-match use limited to 120 images. An additional 40 images may be used in extra time. No use in betting publications, games or single club/league/player publications.
Manchester United's English striker Marcus Rashford (C) shoots to score from the penalty spot for the opening goal during the English Premier League football match between Manchester United and Chelse

Marcus Rashford, Tammy Abraham and rarity of the Premier League home-grown striker in the past 20 years


Ian Oxborrow
  • English
  • Arabic

As Mason Greenwood trotted on to the Old Trafford pitch on Sunday to replace Marcus Rashford with Manchester United 4-0 up against Chelsea, it felt like a new era was beginning for both clubs.

The 17-year-old was making his fifth first-team appearance, while United were lining up with the youngest Premier League starting XI of the week with an average age of 24 years and 227 days.

Chelsea too were taking a youthful route, as Tammy Abraham made his first Premier League start at the comparatively old age of 21, and 20-year-old English midfielder Mason Mount was given his debut.

Rashford, who scored twice, Abraham and Greenwood made up a triumvirate of attacking talent that had been nurtured through the clubs' academies and into the first team - and led to what would make a wonderful, albeit incredibly difficult, quiz question: when was the last time three home-grown British strikers played for their first club in the same Premier League fixture?

Was this just an anomaly, or are we about to see a trend of British strikers making the jump from youth team to Premier League starter? History certainly isn't in their favour.

Remembering James Wilson

Prior to Rashford, who started Sunday's match wide on the left but has played centrally enough to be regarded as a striker, the previous United youngster to make it through the ranks and into the front line was James Wilson.

Now 23 and playing in Scotland for Aberdeen, Wilson burst on to the scene in 2014 with two goals on his Premier League debut against Hull City before his United career fell away. Before him there was Danny Welbeck who came in and spent a significant period in and around the first team.

The success rate for young British strikers making it to the first team at the other big Premier League clubs doesn't make for great reading if you're a budding goal-scorer.

Here's a look at those who made it beyond a handful of substitute appearances:

Arsenal: This one took a lot of research. You have to go back to the late 1980s and early 1990s when Kevin Campbell was a regular (debut 1988), while Scotsman Paul Dickov made his debut in the 1992-93 season and went on to make 22 appearances before leaving for Manchester City in 1996.

Chelsea: Like Arsenal, British strikers who have come through the youth team are almost entirely absent. Dominic Solanke, now of Bournemouth, made 1 Champions League substitute appearance in 2014 for Chelsea and has as many Premier League goals (one) as he has full England caps.

Carlton Cole was the most successful, making 25 league appearances from 2002 before joining West Ham in 2006. Before that you have to go all the way back to Mark Nicholls (not Paul Nicholls from British soap EastEnders), who played 36 league games, scoring three times between 1995 and 2001.

Everton: Victor Anichebe had a half-decent time at Goodison Park after making his debut in 2006, but is Nigerian. James Vaughan was the club's last British striker through the ranks and there were high hopes for his career. He made his debut in 2004 and scored seven Premier League goals for Everton before signing for Norwich in 2011. Wayne Rooney made his Premier League debut a couple of years earlier.

Liverpool: There are high hopes for youngster Rhian Brewster who starred for the first team in pre-season. Raheem Sterling is a worthy mention but he was signed for a sizeable fee from QPR. Then you have to go all the way back to Neil Mellor, who made a dozen first team appearances from 2002, scoring twice, as he failed to live up to the "new Michael Owen" tag. Before Mellor, there was Owen and Robbie Fowler.

Michael Owen made a big impact at Liverpool after passing through the club's youth ranks. Allsport
Michael Owen made a big impact at Liverpool after passing through the club's youth ranks. Allsport

Manchester City: The current Premier League champions had a spell over a decade ago when the British strikers were rolling off the conveyor belt. There was Ched Evans (16 league games, debut 2007), Daniel Sturridge (21 league games, debut 2006), Ishmael Miller (17 league games, debut 2006) and Bradley Wright-Phillips (32 league games, debut 2004).

Newcastle: They're remembered for some horrendous signings (Xisco, Emmanuel Riviere) rather than home-grown attacking talent in the past couple of decades. Adam Armstrong showed promise, scoring goals out on loan after making his debut in 2014, but left having made just one Premier League start. Nile Ranger played 51 times in the league from 2009, scoring twice, while Nigerian Shola Ameobi is worth a mention after more than a decade in and around the first team. The big success story however was Andy Carroll.

Tottenham: Take Harry Kane out of the list and you aren't left with much. A deep dive into the archives shows a few substitute appearances for Lee Barnard in 2006, one goal in three games for Northern Irishman Paul McVeigh in 1997 and you have to go even further back in the time machine to find Rory Allen scoring twice in the Premier League in 1996 - his only league goals for the club in 20 games.

West Ham: Has a club been through more strikers in the Premier League era? Remember Diego Tristan? Savio? Davor Suker? The last British youth team graduate to make it was Freddie Sears in 2008. He left for Colchester United in 2012 after 46 league games and two goals.

____________________

Maguire, Pulisic, Ceballos: Premier League signings on debut

  • Harry Maguire: Looked like he had spent years playing in Manchester United’s back four as they beat Chelsea 4-0. Certainly an upgrade on Phil Jones and Chris Smalling on this showing. Getty Images
    Harry Maguire: Looked like he had spent years playing in Manchester United’s back four as they beat Chelsea 4-0. Certainly an upgrade on Phil Jones and Chris Smalling on this showing. Getty Images
  • Christian Pulisic: Swimming against the tide as United eased to victory. Chelsea’s £58m signing came on after 58 minutes and manager Frank Lampard said: "It was one of those games where I felt it was better to start with Ross [Barkley] and Mason [Mount], who have been very strong in pre-season, and bring Christian on.” He added that Pulisic showed “little moments with his acceleration on the ball”. Reuters
    Christian Pulisic: Swimming against the tide as United eased to victory. Chelsea’s £58m signing came on after 58 minutes and manager Frank Lampard said: "It was one of those games where I felt it was better to start with Ross [Barkley] and Mason [Mount], who have been very strong in pre-season, and bring Christian on.” He added that Pulisic showed “little moments with his acceleration on the ball”. Reuters
  • Daniel James: The perfect introduction for the signing from Swansea as he scored United’s fourth goal just seven minutes after coming on. Getty Images
    Daniel James: The perfect introduction for the signing from Swansea as he scored United’s fourth goal just seven minutes after coming on. Getty Images
  • Aaron Wan-Bissaka: Hugely impressive debut in Manchester United’s 4-0 win. His all-action defending has endeared him to home fans already. AFP
    Aaron Wan-Bissaka: Hugely impressive debut in Manchester United’s 4-0 win. His all-action defending has endeared him to home fans already. AFP
  • David Luiz: Left on the Arsenal bench after joining from Chelsea. PA Wire
    David Luiz: Left on the Arsenal bench after joining from Chelsea. PA Wire
  • Dani Ceballos: The loan signing from Real Madrid started on the Arsenal bench before coming on in the 64th minute and helped see the game out. Action Images via Reuters
    Dani Ceballos: The loan signing from Real Madrid started on the Arsenal bench before coming on in the 64th minute and helped see the game out. Action Images via Reuters
  • Pepe: Like Ceballos, Arsenal’s record signing was held back and only played the last 20 minutes. Getty Images
    Pepe: Like Ceballos, Arsenal’s record signing was held back and only played the last 20 minutes. Getty Images
  • Allan Saint-Maximin: The Frenchman excited Newcastle fans after entering the fray in the 67th minute. AFP
    Allan Saint-Maximin: The Frenchman excited Newcastle fans after entering the fray in the 67th minute. AFP
  • Joelinton: Newcastle’s record buy showed promise against Arsenal and almost scored but ended on the losing side. EPA
    Joelinton: Newcastle’s record buy showed promise against Arsenal and almost scored but ended on the losing side. EPA
  • Ayoze Perez: A quiet start for Leicester’s summer signing from Newcastle in the goal-less draw with Wolves. Was replaced after 76 minutes. AFP
    Ayoze Perez: A quiet start for Leicester’s summer signing from Newcastle in the goal-less draw with Wolves. Was replaced after 76 minutes. AFP
  • Tanguy Ndombele: The £63million midfielder was ‘fantastic’ according to Tottenham manager Mauricio Pochettino, scoring a lovely curling 20-yard strike as his side beat Aston Villa 3-1. Getty Images
    Tanguy Ndombele: The £63million midfielder was ‘fantastic’ according to Tottenham manager Mauricio Pochettino, scoring a lovely curling 20-yard strike as his side beat Aston Villa 3-1. Getty Images
  • Trezeguet: The Egyptian missed a chance to put Aston Villa 2-0 up before they capitulated against Tottenham. Was replaced after 59 minutes. Getty Images
    Trezeguet: The Egyptian missed a chance to put Aston Villa 2-0 up before they capitulated against Tottenham. Was replaced after 59 minutes. Getty Images
  • Wesley: No debut goal for the Villa striker signed from Brugge who was withdrawn after 74 minutes. Reuters
    Wesley: No debut goal for the Villa striker signed from Brugge who was withdrawn after 74 minutes. Reuters
  • Giovani Lo Celso and Ryan Sessegnon: Tottenham’s other new signings were paraded on the pitch but then watched from the stands. PA Wire
    Giovani Lo Celso and Ryan Sessegnon: Tottenham’s other new signings were paraded on the pitch but then watched from the stands. PA Wire
  • Neal Maupay: Dream start for the Brighton striker who came on after 64 minutes and took just 13 minutes to score his first goal since his £20m move from Brentford. Getty Images
    Neal Maupay: Dream start for the Brighton striker who came on after 64 minutes and took just 13 minutes to score his first goal since his £20m move from Brentford. Getty Images
  • Ismaila Sarr and Danny Welbeck: Watford’s new signings were not involved in the matchday squad as their side lost 3-0 at home to Brighton. PA Wire
    Ismaila Sarr and Danny Welbeck: Watford’s new signings were not involved in the matchday squad as their side lost 3-0 at home to Brighton. PA Wire
  • Moise Kean: The arrival from Juventus made little impact for Everton in blustery conditions at Palace after being introduced from the bench after 69 minutes. AFP
    Moise Kean: The arrival from Juventus made little impact for Everton in blustery conditions at Palace after being introduced from the bench after 69 minutes. AFP
  • Jean Philippe Gbamin: The Ivory Coast midfielder joined Everton from Mainz for £25m. He replaced the injured Andre Gomes after 45 minutes of the goal-less draw with Crystal Palace. Reuters
    Jean Philippe Gbamin: The Ivory Coast midfielder joined Everton from Mainz for £25m. He replaced the injured Andre Gomes after 45 minutes of the goal-less draw with Crystal Palace. Reuters
  • Che Adams: Lively start by Southampton’s £15m striker bought from Birmingham City. Taken off after 73 minutes as his side fell away. PA via AP
    Che Adams: Lively start by Southampton’s £15m striker bought from Birmingham City. Taken off after 73 minutes as his side fell away. PA via AP
  • Alex Iwobi: Not involved for Everton after his £35m move from Arsenal. EPA
    Alex Iwobi: Not involved for Everton after his £35m move from Arsenal. EPA
  • Erik Pieters: Two assists for the former Stoke City left back in Burnley’s 3-0 win over Southampton. Action Images via Reuters
    Erik Pieters: Two assists for the former Stoke City left back in Burnley’s 3-0 win over Southampton. Action Images via Reuters
  • Oliver McBurnie: Sheffield United’s £17.5m record signing came off the bench in the second half and was involved in the equaliser but was ultimately upstaged by veteran Billy Sharp who netted his first Premier League goal. Getty Images
    Oliver McBurnie: Sheffield United’s £17.5m record signing came off the bench in the second half and was involved in the equaliser but was ultimately upstaged by veteran Billy Sharp who netted his first Premier League goal. Getty Images
  • Philip Billing: Bournemouth’s £15m signing from Huddersfield impressed and played a part in his side’s goal in the 1-1 draw with Sheffield United. AFP
    Philip Billing: Bournemouth’s £15m signing from Huddersfield impressed and played a part in his side’s goal in the 1-1 draw with Sheffield United. AFP
  • Sebastien Haller: The £45million man held the ball up well as West Ham looked the part early on against Manchester City before being steamrolled 5-0. AP Photo
    Sebastien Haller: The £45million man held the ball up well as West Ham looked the part early on against Manchester City before being steamrolled 5-0. AP Photo
  • Joao Cancelo: An unused substitute as Manchester City eased to victory in their opening match. Action Images via Reuters
    Joao Cancelo: An unused substitute as Manchester City eased to victory in their opening match. Action Images via Reuters
  • Rodri: Fitted in to Manchester City’s midfield seamlessly with effective tackling and passing while those around him did the work in front of goal. Reuters
    Rodri: Fitted in to Manchester City’s midfield seamlessly with effective tackling and passing while those around him did the work in front of goal. Reuters
  • Pablo Fornals: The £24m signing from Villarreal started on the West Ham bench but was brought on at half-time. Four second half goals for Man City was no reflection on him, and he will have easier days in the Premier League. Reuters
    Pablo Fornals: The £24m signing from Villarreal started on the West Ham bench but was brought on at half-time. Four second half goals for Man City was no reflection on him, and he will have easier days in the Premier League. Reuters

____________________

Why are so few British strikers making it in the Premier League?

There's multiple reasons which can be used. Firstly there's the deluge of television money which has necessitated instant success for the bigger clubs. Why wait for an 18 or 19-year-old to get up to speed with top-flight football when you can tempt a ready-made player from Europe or South America with big wages?

Then there's the way the young players are being coached in the academies and the formations being utilised. Notice how managers describe attacking players as being able to "play right across the frontline".

The traditional four-four-two has largely died out and with it the big-man, little man combination upfront.

Instead, we have the 4-2-3-1 with the central striker, such as Rashford, able to play in the wide areas, or the wide players, such as Raheem Sterling, able to play in the central slot or as a deeper lying false nine. Academy sides then mirror the formation and tactics being used by the first team.

With just one place upfront up for grabs, clubs single out the best possible option from around the world rather than within the club's post code as they may have done decades ago.

Then there's the pattern of play which has changed from the more direct English-style to possession based. The foreign players were traditionally more technically accomplished and able to fit in to the style demanded by the increasing number of foreign managers in the Premier League, although the English FA has been working to improve the situation from the grassroots up.

Manchester United's French midfielder Paul Pogba embraces Chelsea's English striker Tammy Abraham. AFP
Manchester United's French midfielder Paul Pogba embraces Chelsea's English striker Tammy Abraham. AFP

Will we see the likes of Chelsea and Man United continue with the young, English attackers?

Not if Jose Mourinho was still in charge at either of his former clubs.

He was critical of new Chelsea manager Frank Lampard for fielding such an inexperienced side at Old Trafford.

“(Marcos) Alonso was on the bench, Kante was on the bench, (Olivier) Giroud was on the bench, and to come to Old Trafford, even if this is not the huge Manchester United that used to scare people, it’s Manchester United," he said while working as a pundit for Sky Sports.

“A little bit of experience would fit well with the team. You look to the performance of Mason Mount, Tammy Abraham and for matches of this dimension you need a little bit more,” he said.

As for United, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has made it clear by selling Romelu Lukaku and not replacing him that he is backing Rashford, Anthony Martial and Greenwood to handle the weight of expectation.

As the for quiz question of when the last time three home-grown British strikers played for their first club in the same Premier League fixture, answers on a postcard please.