Live updates: follow the latest news on Russia-Ukraine
Western leaders reacted with scepticism on Tuesday to Russia's announcement that some troops amassed near Ukraine were returning to their bases after finishing military drills.
It was not clear how many troops were pulling back out of an estimated 130,000 stationed near Ukraine's border, and senior western figures called for more proof from Russia that it was easing its military posture. The foreign minister in Kiev issued a warning: “Don't believe what you hear, believe what you see.”
And President Joe Biden said a Russian attack on Ukraine remains “distinctly possible” and that the US has yet to confirm Moscow's claims it has pulled some troops back from the border.
But markets rallied on hopes of a peaceful solution as Ukraine said a flurry of diplomacy in recent weeks had helped to prevent a Russian escalation.
Nato leaders said there were signs of a diplomatic opening after the troop reductions followed signals from Russia that it wanted to keep the delicate talks alive.
However, Russia has previously left heavy equipment behind while withdrawing soldiers and the movement of forces alone “doesn't represent real de-escalation”, said Nato Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg.
The US envoy to the alliance said Russia had a history of false claims that it was lowering tension. “You may remember in late December, there were some similar claims that came out of Moscow that they were de-escalating and in fact, facts on the ground did not support that claim,” said Julianne Smith.
Prime Minister Boris Johnson said the UK's intelligence was "not encouraging" with Russia said to be building field hospitals in Belarus, in what he said was potential preparation for an attack on Ukraine.
The apparent partial withdrawal came as German Chancellor Olaf Scholz held peace talks in the Kremlin on Tuesday in what diplomats are describing as a window of opportunity to prevent war.
Mr Scholz sat down with President Vladimir Putin at the long Kremlin table that has been a feature of recent discussions, after France's Emmanuel Macron was similarly kept at a distance after reportedly refusing a Russian coronavirus test.
The German leader welcomed Russia's call for more discussions after saying he could see "no sensible reason" for Russia to amass troops near Ukraine. He said he hoped more troops would withdraw from the border to follow those sent back to their barracks on Tuesday.
"We are ready, together with our partners in the EU and Nato and with Russia, to discuss concrete steps to improve our common security," he said.
Mr Putin repeated Russia's frustration that Nato would not consider putting curbs on its eastward expansion but said he would engage with discussions on other issues such as missile control.
The US and UK have warned in recent days that Mr Putin could order an invasion of Ukraine at any moment, and satellite images published by US company Maxar Technologies suggested new Russian movements of troops, attack helicopters and fighter jets.
But Russia's Defence Ministry announced early on Tuesday that some units were returning to their garrisons after completing drills that have added to the West's disquiet.
“The units of the southern and western military districts, having completed their tasks, have already begun loading on to rail and road transport,” spokesman Igor Konashenkov said.
Video footage published by a Russian news agency showed some tanks and other armoured vehicles being loaded on to railway flatcars.
It was the second glimmer of hope in two days from the Russian side after it signalled on Monday that it was open to further talks, although experts urged caution in interpreting the significance of the withdrawal.
UK Foreign Secretary Liz Truss, who was on air when news of the partial Russian withdrawal filtered through, said Britain would “need to see a full-scale removal of troops” to believe Moscow's insistence that no invasion is planned.
Henry Boyd, an analyst at the IISS think tank, said Russia had mobilised at a scale it could not have managed until very recently and that concrete signs of a withdrawal would need to be seen.
“I think it's within this context that one should maintain an air of cautious scepticism about Russia's announcement this morning,” he said. “As recently as five years ago, I think the scale of mobilisation would have been impossible for Russia's armed forces to achieve.”
-
Russian tanks return from a shooting range in the Voronezh region. Russia said some of its forces near the Ukraine border would be returning to their bases after completing exercises. EPA -
Russian President Vladimir Putin meets German Chancellor Olaf Scholz in Moscow to discuss the Ukraine crisis. Reuters -
Russian tanks make their way through snow back to their bases. EPA -
Russian armoured vehicles are loaded on to railway platforms after the end of military drills in South Russia on Tuesday. AP -
Chancellor Scholz attends a wreath-laying ceremony at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier in Moscow. EPA -
“The units of the southern and western military districts, having completed their tasks, have already begun loading on to rail and road transport,” Russia's Defence Ministry spokesman Igor Konashenkov said. AP -
Britain's Foreign Secretary Liz Truss arrives at 10 Downing Street to attend a meeting of the UK's Cobra emergency committee. AFP -
Russian military vehicles are loaded on to railway freight carriages in Crimea. EPA -
A Ukrainian soldier fires an anti-tank weapon during an exercise in eastern Ukraine. AP
Other Russian drills were still going on, Mr Konashenkov said, with the navy staging war games and marines planning a live-fire exercise with allied Belarusian troops on Saturday.
But Ukraine claimed a diplomatic victory after what was the first announcement in weeks of a Russian pull-back.
“We and our allies have managed to prevent Russia from any further escalation. It is already the middle of February, and you see that diplomacy is continuing to work,” Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba said.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy declared Wednesday, the day speculated about as the potential start date for a Russian invasion, as a day of unity featuring defiant flag-waving and singing of national hymns.
The Kremlin, in turn, mocked the supposed timetable by saying Mr Putin had enquired about what time the Americans thought an invasion would start.
John Chipman, the head of the IISS, said Russia had enough assets to carry out some operations in Ukraine even if it was not poised to invade the entire country.
“Should Russia decide to attack, there's probably enough combat mass now present to conduct a more limited ground operation, perhaps to seize Ukraine's eastern regions or to conduct stand-off strikes,” he said at the launch of the institute's annual Military Balance report.
Mr Johnson and Mr Biden said in a call on Tuesday that there was a “crucial window for diplomacy” in which Russia could be persuaded to step back from Ukraine.
Hopes were raised after Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov told Mr Putin that talks with the West should continue despite differences over the future of Nato.
-
A bomb shelter underneath Kiev's Central Train Station. The underground shelter can offer protection to the workers on shift and about 2,000 civilians. AP -
An aerial image of attack helicopters on the runway at Zyabrovka airfield in Belarus. AP -
A Ukrainian servicewoman disinfects the wounds of a dog injured by razor wire at a frontline position outside Popasna, the Luhansk region, in eastern Ukraine. AP -
An interior view shows a kindergarten, which according to Ukraine's military officials was damaged by shelling, in Stanytsia Luhanska in the Luhansk region, Ukraine. Reuters -
Ukrainian pensioner Lidiya Silina, 87, at her house right next to the border with Belarus. Ms Silina would take the rubbish out on the Belarusian side of the border opposite the twisty stream. Then the troubles started and the Russian tanks came. AFP -
A Ukrainian serviceman at a frontline position outside Popasna in eastern Ukraine. AP -
A child copies the position of Ukrainian servicemen standing at attention during the national anthem in Sievierodonetsk, eastern Ukraine. AP -
Ukrainian soldiers pose for a picture as the country observes a Day of Unity in Odessa. AP -
Lorries queue at the Goptivka border crossing between Ukraine and Russia, near the Eastern Ukrainian city of Kharkiv, amid growing tension. EPA -
Ukrainian border guards patrol along the border with Russia, near Kharkiv. EPA -
Four Royal Air Force Typhoon jets in Cyprus. The UK sent the additional jets to boost air patrols over eastern Europe. PA -
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy, second from right, is briefed on preparations at the site of a military drill outside the city of Rivne. AFP -
Nato defence ministers in Brussels, Belgium. The military alliance says Russia is still sending troops to the border with Ukraine, contradicting Moscow’s claims of a drawdown. Reuters -
Ukraine's Senkivka checkpoint near the border with Belarus and Russia. Reuters -
The Motherland Monument in Kiev, Ukraine. The country is on high alert for the possibility of an invasion by its neighbour Russia. AP -
Valentyna Konstantynovska, 79, holds a weapon during basic combat training for civilians in Mariupol, eastern Ukraine. AP -
A satellite image shows a housing area and equipment for troops in Rechitsa, Belarus, where Russian forces are holding joint military exercises. Reuters -
US soldiers prepare to leave Fort Bragg, North Carolina, for Europe, where they are being sent as the crisis between Russia and Ukraine escalates. AFP -
Ukrainian soldiers at the site where a rocket landed close to their positions during the night on a front line near Popasna, eastern Ukraine. AP -
Ukrainian servicemen survey an area that was shelled overnight on Tuesday close to their positions on a front line outside Popasna, eastern Ukraine. AP -
A Ukrainian teenager helps a church minister reinforce basements in a centre for children in the Ukrainian village of Chervone. AFP -
A Ukrainian teenager digs trenches for soldiers serving on their country's eastern front and facing off with Russian-backed separatists, near Chervone. AFP -
A Ukrainian border guard at a crossing to Belarus in Vilcha. Getty -
A child tries to remove ammunition from a clip during basic combat training for civilians organised by the National Guard in eastern Ukraine. AP -
Rumia, 59, a member of Ukraine's Territorial Defence Force, trains near the capital Kiev. AP -
Smoke rises over the Gozhsky training ground during Russia-Belarus military drills in Belarus. AP -
Ukrainians march to show solidarity and patriotic spirit in Kiev. Getty -
A Ukrainian National Guard member shows civilians in the Donetsk region, eastern Ukraine, how to adopt a firing position. AP -
A military helicopter fires missiles during the Russia-Belarus military drills in Belarus. AP -
A pedestrian passes through the only open crossing point between territory held by pro-Russian separatists and Ukrainian government controlled territory in Stanytsia Luhanska, eastern Ukraine. AP -
US soldiers on parade during the visit of Nato Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg to the Mihail Kogalniceanu airbase, near Constanta, eastern Romania. AP
Meanwhile in Britain, Ms Truss sought to keep up the pressure on Russia by saying sanctions in the event of war would target Kremlin-linked oligarchs who have long used London as a base.
She said Russia should expect a “ratchet of sanctions”, including asset freezes and visa bans for Kremlin associates, offering detail on the package of measures repeatedly threatened by western powers.
“There will be nowhere to hide for those oligarchs close to Putin, for companies that back the Russian state, and it will see a degradation of the Russian economy,” she told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.
The EU's foreign policy chief, Josep Borrell, told the same programme that the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline would “not become operational” if war were to break out in Ukraine.
While the US and Britain have joined Ukraine in opposing the pipeline, Germany has resisted calls for a firm commitment that gas will not flow through the pipeline.
Mr Borrell said the EU was ready to keep discussing security concerns with Russia after previous rounds of talks ended with no clear breakthrough.
Suhail Al Mazrouei, UAE Minister of Energy and Infrastructure, told US network CNBC that he hoped negotiations between Russia and its European neighbours would prevail.
“What we hear is that there is no intention for an invasion and that, I think, is comforting,” he said. “Hopefully we will see a de-escalation.”
