Coronavirus: Antibody studies show herd immunity experiments are ‘very dangerous’

The WHO said initial studies disproved the idea that many people had unknowingly contracted Covid-19, creating the conditions for herd immunity

• 

  A police officer wears a headgear mounted with thermal temperature monitor during a nationwide lockdown to slow the spread of the coronavirus, in New Delhi, India. Reuters

• 

  Groom Sanjib Mandal, right, and bride Soma Roy wear masks as they perform rituals on their marriage ceremony at a Hindu temple amid the nationwide lockdown against the coronavirus, in Siliguri. AFP

• 

  A relative of a patient stands outside the General Hospital in Mexico City during the Covid-19 pandemic. AFP

• 

  A man wearing a face mask talks with a shopkeeper in a deserted street with rows of closed shops and restaurants near Gion, in Japan's ancient capital Kyoto. The streets of the tourist city are largely deserted as the number of foreign visitors declined more than 93 per cent from previous year, the local media reported in late April. EPA

• 

  Drivers and passengers are screened by healthcare workers from the DeKalb County Board of Health at a free swabbing site at The House of Hope Atlanta church in Decatur, Georgia, US. EPA

• 

  An elderly woman holds a French flag as residents of Saint Mande celebrate the end of containment measures and thank medical and health care personnel amid the ongoing coronavirus pandemic in Saint Mande, near Paris, France. France begins a gradual easing of lockdown measures and restrictions although the Covid-19 epidemic remains active. EPA

• 

  Health personnel from the Villa Nueva National Hospital stand in front of the entrance of the hospital to address a press conference in Villa Nueva, Guatemala. The health personnel treating coronavirus patients threatened to 'enter a permanent session', in which certain areas of service will receive reduced attention, within 48 hours if they do not receive help from the authorities because of the lack of human resources. EPA

• 

  A boy wearing a mask looks at himself in the shop mirrors in Guangzhou, Guangdong province, China. China reported 17 new confirmed Covid-19 cases on May 10 , seven of which were reportedly linked to Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, according to National Health Commission of China. EPA

• 

  A patient affected by the Covid-19 speaks with a family member by a video call at a field hospital set up at a sports gym, in Santo Andre, Sao Paulo state, Brazil. AFP

• 

  People wait on a tramway dock as they follow social-distancing rules, in the French Riviera city of Nice, southern France, on the first day of France's easing of lockdown measures against the coronavirus. AFP

• 

  Workers of the health ministry prepare to test the employees of the Ciudad de Dios market for Covid-19 in Lima. AFP

• 

  People practice social distancing inside an elevator as they head to their work places at World Trade Centre, after the government announced that private and state companies will reopen after almost two months of lockdown to contain the coronavirus, in Colombo, Sri Lanka. Reuters

• 

  A migrant workers' family desperate to reach their home in neighbouring Madhya Pradesh state hitchhike behind a lorry in India's commercial capital Mumbai that will take them to the outskirts of the city. India’s train network, closed in late March, will gradually restart operations on Tuesday as the country eases its lockdown amid a steep rise in the coronavirus infections. AP Photo

Far fewer people have contracted Covid-19 than expected according to antibody studies, meaning herd immunity experiments are not only doomed to fail, they are dangerous, the WHO said on Monday.

Only between 1 per cent and 10 per cent of people globally have shown evidence of infection, according to the early results of some of the 90 serology surveys taking place across the world.

That means the health implications of the virus are much more severe than many believed it to be, said Dr Mike Ryan, executive director of the World Health Organisation's Health Emergencies Programme.

The new figures show any attempt to pursue a strategy that would result in "herd immunity" without a vaccine would be “very dangerous”.

Maria Van Kerkhove, the WHO's technical lead, said the body had not yet been able to evaluate the methodology of many of the ongoing seroprevalence studies, which look for antibodies in the blood that point to past Covid-19 infection.

But the studies' preliminary results showed a “very low proportion” of people had contracted the virus across the world, mainly in the range of 1 per cent to 10 per cent, with a “couple” pointing to a slightly higher prevalence of 15 per cent.

“What these seroepidemiologic studies indicate to us is that there is a large proportion of the population that remains susceptible. And that’s important when you think about what happens in subsequent waves, or what may happen as a potential resurgence,” she said.

“So we have a long way to go with this virus, because the virus has more people that can be infected.”

Dr Ryan said the estimates disproved the theory that once serology study results were available they would show most people had already had the virus and were therefore immune.

“The preliminary results from the seroepidemiology studies are showing the opposite.

“It is showing the proportion of people with significant clinical illness is actually a higher proportion of all those who have been infected, because the number of people infected in the total population is probably much lower than we expected,” he said.

He said that meant “we have a long way to go” with the virus.

“And it means, as the director general has been saying, for months, this is a serious disease. This is public enemy number one.”

The estimates chimed with research conducted by governments in Europe, which suggested that Belgium has the highest percentage of citizens with a degree of possible immunity to the virus, with an estimated 6.4 per cent prevalence.

In the UK, the hardest hit country on the continent in terms of deaths, it is 3.8 per cent. Only 0.7 per cent of the population is thought to have had the disease in Germany.

On the continent only Sweden has refused to lockdown its economy and population to stem the spread of the virus, introducing only lax, and largely voluntary controls.

That led a state epidemiologist to estimate that almost half, or 40 per cent of the population, would be immune by the end of May. But only 2.5 per cent of the population has so far contracted it, according to the research by the Italian Institute for International Political Studies (ISPI).

Dr Ryan said any strategy involving calculations of how to achieve herd immunity was not only irresponsible, but dangerous.

“Humans are not herds. And as such the concept of herd immunity is generally reserved for calculating how many people would need to be vaccinated in a population in order to generate that same effect,” he said.

“I do think this idea that maybe countries which have had lax measures or haven’t done anything will all of a sudden magically reach some herd immunity, and so what if we lose a few old people along the way, this is a really dangerous calculation.”

He said responsible member states value every member of their society and try to do everything possible to protect their health, and that of the economy.

“We need to get our priorities right as we enter the next phase of this fight,” he added.