Mosques in India's Maharashtra to lower volume of speakers after Hindu leader protests

More than 900 have responded to local politician's complaints about noise of the call to prayer

Worshippers offer morning prayers to start Eid Fitr at the Gol Masjid mosque in Mumbai.  AFP

Sitting in an office lined with books overlooking a giant prayer hall, Mohammed Ashfaq Kazi, the main preacher at the largest mosque in Mumbai, checked a decibel meter attached to the loudspeakers before he gave the call to prayer.

“The volume of our azaan has become a political issue, but I don't want it to take a communal turn,” said Mr Kazi, one of the most influential Islamic scholars in the sprawling metropolis on India's western coast.

As he spoke, he pointed to loudspeakers attached to the minarets of the ornate, sand-coloured Juma Masjid in Mumbai's old trading quarters.

Mr Kazi and three other senior clerics from Maharashtra where Mumbai is located said more than 900 mosques in the west of the state had agreed to turn the volume down on calls to prayer. This followed complaints from a local Hindu politician.

Security has been stepped up outside Mumbai mosques after Maharashtra Navnirman Sena party chief Raj Thackeray said that he and his followers would play hymns to Hindu god Hanuman on loudspeakers if mosques continue to use loudspeakers for the call to prayer. AP

Raj Thackeray, leader of a regional Hindu party Maharashtra Navnirman Sena, demanded in April that mosques and others places of worship keep within permitted noise limits. If they did not, he said his followers would chant Hindu prayers outside mosques in protest.

Mr Thackeray, whose party has only one seat in the state's 288-member assembly, said he was merely insisting that court rulings on noise levels be enforced.

“If religion is a private matter, then why are Muslims allowed to use loudspeakers all 365 days [of the year[?” Mr Thackeray told reporters in Mumbai, India's financial hub and the capital of Maharashtra.

“My dear Hindu brothers, sisters and mothers come together; be one in bringing down these loudspeakers,” he said.

Leaders of India's 200 million Muslims see the move, which coincided with the holy festival of Eid, as another attempt by hardline Hindus to undermine their rights to free worship and religious expression. They believe the move comes with the tacit agreement of the ruling Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party.

In recent weeks, a senior BJP leader began pushing for swapping marriage and inheritance laws based on religion with a uniform civil code.

The BJP did not respond to a request for comment on Mr Thackeray's initiative. It denies targeting minorities, and said it wants progressive change that benefits all Indians.

At the Juma Masjid, Mr Kazi said he complied with Mr Thackeray's demands to reduce the risk of violence between Muslims and Hindus.

Bloody clashes have erupted sporadically across India since independence, most recently in 2020 when dozens of people, mostly Muslims, were killed in Delhi following protests against a citizenship law that Muslims said discriminated against them.

While hardline Hindu leaders were seeking to undermine Islam, Mr Kazi said: “We [Muslims] have to maintain calm and serenity.”

Raj Thackeray, whose Maharashtra Navnirman Sena party has only one seat in the state's 288-member assembly, said he was merely insisting that court rulings on noise levels be enforced. AP

The state took Mr Thackeray's initiative seriously.

Senior police officials met religious leaders including Mr Kazi earlier this month to ensure microphones were turned down. They feared clashes in Maharashtra, home to more than 10 million Muslims and 70m Hindus.

On Saturday, police filed a criminal case against two men in Mumbai for using loudspeakers to recite the early morning azaan and warned workers of Mr Thackeray's party against gathering around mosques.

“Under no circumstances will we allow anyone to create communal tension in the state and the court's order must be respected,” said V N Patil, a senior Mumbai police official.

A senior official for Mr Thackeray's party said the initiative was not designed to single out Muslims, but aimed to reduce “noise pollution” created by all places of worship.

“Our party does not appease the minority community,” said Kirtikumar Shinde. He added that police had issued warnings to 20,000 party workers this month.

The issue of calls to prayer extends beyond Maharashtra. BJP politicians in three states asked local police to remove or limit the use of loudspeakers in places of worship.

Brajesh Pathak, the deputy chief minister of country's most populous state, Uttar Pradesh, said more than 60,000 unauthorised loudspeakers had been removed from mosques and temples.

Updated: May 09, 2022, 6:43 AM
EDITOR'S PICKS