Coronavirus: spike in Darfur deaths points to invisible spread

In the sprawling refugee camps of Sudan's Darfur, officials say people are falling sick and dying at astonishing rates. UNAMID via AP

In the sprawling refugee camps of Darfur, the war-scarred western region of Sudan, officials say the elderly are falling sick and dying at astonishing rates.

In North Darfur’s provincial capital of El Fasher, some say they scroll through a dozen death announcements each day ⁠— another old friend, relative, community leader lost with dizzying speed.

Doctors in the region’s few functioning hospitals report an influx of patients with symptoms like a lost sense of taste, breathing troubles and fevers. The official causes of their untimely deaths remain “unknown”.

Humanitarian workers and medical personnel believe the coronavirus is spreading unchecked and untracked through Sudan’s most marginalised territory, where medical facilities are few and far between and where years of conflict have left some 1.6 million people crammed into refugee camps.

Nationwide, Sudan has reported 6,879 coronavirus infections and 433 deaths, according to the Health Ministry. Of those, 193 cases and 54 fatalities have been confirmed across Darfur, a figure experts believe is a vast undercount.

In this March 26, 2020 photo released by the United Nations African Union Mission in Darfur (UNAMID), UNAMID medical section commence a daily body temperature check for all personnel entering the Mission's compounds in El Fasher, as part of precautionary measures put in place to minimize risk of COVID-19 infections to its personnel as well as the host community, in North Darfur, Sudan. In the sprawling refugee camps of Sudan's Darfur, officials say people are falling sick and dying at astonishing rates. Humanitarian workers and medical personnel believe the coronavirus is spreading unchecked and untracked through Sudan’s most marginalized territory. (UNAMID via AP)

Since the beginning of the pandemic, public health officials have sounded the alarm that the coronavirus will take a disastrous toll on the world’s most vulnerable regions, particularly refugee camps, where social distancing, even hand-washing, prove impossible.

“People in the camps are suffocating, they can’t breathe,” said Mohamed Hassan Adam, director of Abushouk displacement camp in North Darfur.

Just a corner of the camp saw 64 unexplained deaths in one month, he said. His four neighbours, all in their sixties, grew feeble and vanished one by one.

“They get exhausted then they die. There is no way to tell what happened,” he said.

Authorities are scrambling to curb the spread of contagion amid a fragile democratic transition after massive protests last year toppled longtime autocrat Omar Al Bashir.

“We are in the eye of the storm,” said Ashraf Issa, spokesman for the UN-African Union peacekeeping force in Darfur, referring to the country’s exponential surge in infections.

Sudan’s health care system is in disarray after years of war and sanctions. Dire shortages of protective equipment and staff nationwide prompted strikes by medical workers as infections rise in their ranks.

A drastic under supply of drugs and hard currency forces the sick to purchase essential medicine out of pocket. A lack of fuel has made it increasingly difficult for doctors and patients to reach hospitals.

“These are the problems that Sudan faces everywhere, but in Darfur it is more severe,” said Dr Babikir El Magboul, director of the Health Ministry’s Emergency and Epidemiology Department. “It’s like a separate continent.”

Many in Darfur’s camps are undernourished and weakened by infectious diseases like malaria and acute watery diarrhoea. At Abushouk camp, each bathroom is shared by dozens of people. Around the territory, markets and mosques — along with a growing number of funerals — continue to draw crowds.

Darfur, with a population of 9 million, has only around 600 health facilities, or one per 15,000 people. With facilities scattered over an area the size of Spain, residents in rural areas must travel long distances to reach one. Doctors say quarantine centres have no more than a few dozen beds, two or three ventilators and cheap gowns and surgical masks for protection equipment.

Before a new testing centre opened this month in Nyala, South Darfur, testing was centralised in one laboratory in the capital, Khartoum, which processes just around 270 samples each day. Health workers in Darfur say that results can take a week to come through.

To fill the gap, some local doctors are working to grasp the virus’ toll.

When El Fasher saw a spike in over 200 “mysterious” fatalities in just two weeks, officials launched an investigation. Dr Taher Ahmed, deputy dean of El Fasher University’s medical college, attributed around 50 fatalities to Covid-19, but said it was still likely an undercount. Doctors in West and Central Darfur provinces also reported an unusual increase in deaths.

Dr Abdullah Adam, a radiology doctor, said he knew of 47 acquaintances who died the past month after showing coronavirus symptoms in villages around Kabkabiya, near El-Fasher. Among them were two of his uncles, he said. One family he knew lost a brother and sister in the same week.

Coronavirus around the world

A patient positive to Covid-19 rests in the quarantine area at the Somine Dolo Hospital in Mopti, Mali. AFP

Doctors check the temperature of a Covid19 patient, in Comas, northern outskirts of Lima, Peru. AFP

Municipal firefighters transfer a patient with symptoms related to coronavirus, at the Covid-19 unit of San Juan de Dios hospital in Guatemala City. AFP

Yoshiro Mori, President of the Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games Organising Committee, attends an Executive Board Meeting in Tokyo, Japan. Kyodo via Reuters

Test takers have their body temperatures checked before entering the venue of an exam for public servants in the port city of Busan, south of Seoul, South Korea. EPA

Cemetery workers stand near relatives who attended to the burial of a man, who died of the coronavirus disease, at the Cementerio Jardin cemetery in Soyapango, El Salvador. Reuters

Funeral workers move the coffin of a woman, who died of the coronavirus disease, at the Municipal cemetery in Nezahualcoyotl, State of Mexico, Mexico. Reuters

Pole vaulter Karsten Dilla of Germany competes during a "Flight Night" event at a drive-in cinema due to the coronavirus pandemic orders in Duesseldorf, Germany. AP Photo

A worker cleans the ceiling of a deserted mosque before reopened after nearly three months of lockdown amid the coronavirus pandemic in Colombo, Sri Lanka. EPA

Lord Mayor of Gorlitz Octavian Ursu, center right, and Mayor of Zgorzelec, Poland, Rafal Gronicz, center left, together open the border fence on the Gorlitz Old Town Bridge in Gorlitz, Germany. dpa via AP

Peter Bosciglio cuts Joe Krywionek's hair at Peter's Barber shop as the provincial phase 2 reopening from the coronavirus disease restrictions begins outside of the Toronto area, in Cobourg, Ontario, Canada. Reuters

Karen Suchy, of Baldwin, cries next to her niece Reese Temme as she catches a glimpse of her mother, Betty Milinski, for the first time in person in three months during a parade to celebrate the start of outdoor visits due to the coronavirus, at Norbert Personal Care Home in the Overbrook area, in Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette via AP

A Buddhist nun cleans wax figures of venerable monks displayed in a Buddhist temple outside Bangkok in Thailand. AFP

Airport police officers wearing protective masks check the documents of travellers at an entrance to Kuala Lumpur International Airport in Sepang, Selangor, Malaysia. Bloomberg

Migrant workers from Bihar state, wearing masks as a precaution against the coronavirus, watch local youth play football as they wait for buses to catch home bound train in Kochi, southern Kerala state, India. AP Photo

A labourer wearing protective face mask fills air in a tyre at a workshop along a road, as the outbreak of the coronavirus disease continues, in Karachi, Pakistan. Reuters

The Gravity Vault Manager, Nick Bowden vacuums in preparation for possible re-opening in Hoboken, New Jersey, US. AFP

Caregivers serve soup in disposable dishes to avoid contamination at Sao Francisco de Assis shelter for the elderly in Sao Joao do Meriti, near Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Reuters

A woman passes by a graffiti depicting Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro and a figure representing the novel coronavirus pulling a rope against health workers with the question "Which side of the rope are you on?" in Sao Paulo, Brazil. AFP

Some camps in the north saw 10 to 15 people a day dying the past week, compared to the normal rate of 5 to 10 a month, said Adam Regal, spokesman for a local organisation that runs some camps.

“We’re losing a whole generation,” said Gamal Abdulkarim Abdullah, director of Zam Zam camp. He said he documented 70 dead the past week.

“The sharp mortality increase in Darfur is mostly linked to Covid-19, although not purely,” said Dr El Magboul. Amid the pandemic, people with other illnesses are struggling to find treatment. Yousef Saleh, the 70-year-old leader of El Fasher’s Great Mosque, died earlier this month because he couldn’t receive his usual diabetes care.

Darfur’s violent past has bred distrust that further corrodes government health efforts.

Conflict flared in the territory when African minority rebels launched a revolt in 2003 over oppression by Al Bashir’s Arab-dominated government. A Bashir waged a brutal counterinsurgency campaign, including mass rapes and killings. The trauma remains even after Al Bashir’s fall.

Camp residents think the coronavirus is a conspiracy to “keep people in their homes where the old regime can come and kill them,” said Dr Abdullah Adam, Zam Zam’s director.

Hassan Adam of Abushouk scoffed when asked whether people call the government hotline to report suspected cases. “The government barely knows we exist,” he said.

It hasn’t helped that local authorities have clamped down on reporting. After two female journalists published an article about the high mortality rate in El Fasher and lack of protective equipment for doctors, they were promptly harassed and threatened with arrest by a military officer, according to the Darfur Journalist Association.

Many saw the incident as an ominous sign.

“When people are in the dark, they don’t take things seriously,” said Dr Abdullah Adam. “I fear the worst is yet to come.”