Like a hole in the head

Drilling a hole in the skull is being touted as a possible treatment for dementia.

epa01624800 Human skull with front trepanation on display at the Egyptian Museum in Barcelona, Spain, 05 February 2009, as part of a deformed skeletons exhibition. The show includes 136 skeletons and human remains with different types of diseases and malformations. The exhibition, opened today, runs through 30 June 2009.  EPA/ALBERTO ESTEVEZ
Powered by automated translation

In the early 1960s, a young Russian neurophysiologist called Yuri Moskalenko travelled from the Soviet Union to the UK on an exchange programme with the Royal Society, Britain's prestigious academy of science. During his stay, he co-authored a paper published in the journal Nature. "Variation in blood volume and oxygen availability in the human brain" may not sound subversive, but it was the start of a radical idea.

Decades later, having worked in Soviet Russia and become president of the Sechenov Institute of Evolutionary Physiology and Biochemistry at the Russian Academy of Sciences in St Petersburg, Dr Moskalenko is back in the UK. Now collaborating with researchers at the Beckley Foundation in Oxford, England, his work is bearing fruit. And strange fruit it is. With funding from the foundation, he is exploring the idea that people with Alzheimer's disease could be treated by drilling a hole in their skull. In fact, he is so convinced of the benefits of trepanation that he claims it may help anyone from their mid 40s onwards to slow or even reverse the process of age-related cognitive decline. Can he be serious?

For thousands of years, trepanation has been performed for quasi-medical reasons such as releasing evil spirits that were believed to cause schizophrenia or migraine. Today it is used to prevent brain injury by relieving intracranial pressure, particularly after accidents involving head trauma. In the popular imagination, though, it is considered crude, if not downright barbaric. Yet such is the desperation for effective treatments for dementia that drilling a hole in the skull is not even the strangest game in town.

The problem is huge and growing. Alzheimer's, the most common form of dementia, affects 700,000 people in the UK and nearly five million in the US. As people live longer, the numbers seem certain to grow. Yet we have few ideas about what causes dementia and even fewer about how to treat it. Most patients get a mixture of drugs and occupational therapy, which at best stalls the apparent progression of their illness by masking its symptoms.

The causes of dementia are many and poorly understood, but there is growing evidence that one factor is the flow of blood within the brain. As we age, cerebral blood flow decreases, and the earlier this happens the more likely someone is to develop early onset dementia. It remains unclear, however, whether declining cerebral blood flow is the cause, or an incidental effect of a more fundamental change. Dr Moskalenko's research indicates that cerebral blood flow is more closely correlated with age than with levels of dementia, so he decided to delve more deeply.

As well as delivering oxygen to the brain, cerebral blood flow has another vital role: the circulation and production of cerebrospinal fluid. This clear liquid surrounds the brain, carrying the nutrients that feed it and removing the waste it produces, including the tau and beta-amyloid proteins that have been implicated in the formation of plaques found in the brains of people with Alzheimer's. As we age, the proteins in the brain harden, preventing this system from working as it should. As a result, the flow of both blood and cerebrospinal fluid is reduced, impairing the delivery of oxygen and nutrients as well as the removal of waste. Dr Moskalenko's research suggests that this normally begins between the ages of 40 and 50. Moreover, in a study of 42 elderly people with dementia, he found that the severity of their cognitive disorder was strongly correlated with cranial compliance: those with the severest dementia had the lowest compliance.

This view gets qualified agreement from Conrad Johanson, a clinical neuroscientist at Brown University in Providence, Rhode Island. Although the link between low compliance and dementia has yet to be comprehensively shown, he says, "there's a gestalt that it's broadly true". So where does trepanation come into all this? A hole made in the bony cavity would act as a pressure-release valve, and this would alter the flow of fluids around the brain. This is exactly what Dr Moskalenko observed.

Dr Moskalenko studied 15 people who had undergone the procedure following head injuries. He found that their cranial compliance was around 20 per cent higher than the average for their age. Based on this, he calculates that a four-square-centimetre hole increases cerebral blood flow by between eight and 10 per cent, which is equivalent to 0.8 millilitres more blood per heartbeat. This, he says, shows that trepanation could be an effective treatment for Alzheimer's, and he even goes so far as to suggest that it might provide a "significant" improvement in the mental functions of anyone from their mid-40s, when cranial compliance starts to decline.

Surprisingly, his most vociferous critics do not challenge his support for trepanation. Instead they question his ideas about how it works. Gerald Silverberg at the Stanford School of Medicine in California points out that drilling a hole in the skull may temporarily drain the cranial cavity of cerebrospinal fluid together with any toxins that may have accumulated in it, effectively flushing out the system. So will dementia patients and their families ever accept trepanation as a treatment for the condition? Dr Johanson, who sees trepanation as no more alarming than a spinal tap, admits that it is always going to be a hard sell. "People think it's witchcraft when you drill a hole in the skull and patients are improving."

Harriet Millward, deputy chief executive of the UK-based charity Alzheimer's Research Trust, is keeping an open mind. "The procedure has been understudied so far and, until further research has been undertaken, the possibility of beneficial effects remains open," she says. David Smith, a neuropharmacologist and head of the Oxford Project to Investigate Memory and Ageing, is even more receptive. "I think the observations look pretty robust," he says. In the absence of drug treatments for dementia, "these rather drastic surgical ones are worth considering", he says.