• MANCHESTER UNITED RATINGS: Andre Onana - 5: Has conceded more than one goal in the last four league games, the first time this has happened in 44 years. It also meant United’s excellent home run of wins came to an end. Only got his fingers to the third, a finish that was going away from him. Fine save from Fati at the end. Reuters
    MANCHESTER UNITED RATINGS: Andre Onana - 5: Has conceded more than one goal in the last four league games, the first time this has happened in 44 years. It also meant United’s excellent home run of wins came to an end. Only got his fingers to the third, a finish that was going away from him. Fine save from Fati at the end. Reuters
  • Diogo Dalot - 6: Third straight league start. Subject of a yellow card tackle by Lampety after three minutes. Top play to set up Rashford on 25. Nicked ball off Mitoma to stop a 48th-minute attack. Another who didn’t do enough to stop the second goal conceded. Reuters
    Diogo Dalot - 6: Third straight league start. Subject of a yellow card tackle by Lampety after three minutes. Top play to set up Rashford on 25. Nicked ball off Mitoma to stop a 48th-minute attack. Another who didn’t do enough to stop the second goal conceded. Reuters
  • Victor Lindelof - 5: Ball ran by him before Brighton took the lead in a big setback after a bright start. Smart ball to Rashford to set up one attack. Did well to keep the ball when Lallana threatened to run at goal on 42. Getty
    Victor Lindelof - 5: Ball ran by him before Brighton took the lead in a big setback after a bright start. Smart ball to Rashford to set up one attack. Did well to keep the ball when Lallana threatened to run at goal on 42. Getty
  • Lisandro Martinez - 5: Backed off and didn’t do enough to stop the cross for the first – a fine Welbeck finish. Static for Brighton’s second goal from Gross and, like Casemiro, a star player who has dipped this season. Getty
    Lisandro Martinez - 5: Backed off and didn’t do enough to stop the cross for the first – a fine Welbeck finish. Static for Brighton’s second goal from Gross and, like Casemiro, a star player who has dipped this season. Getty
  • Sergio Reguilon - 5: Combined well with Rashford on the left at the start, but part of a defence that was continually carved open by Brighton. Getty
    Sergio Reguilon - 5: Combined well with Rashford on the left at the start, but part of a defence that was continually carved open by Brighton. Getty
  • Casemiro - 5. Too casual and didn’t make a recovery run for Welbeck’s goal. Didn’t have the legs you need against Brighton. Disappointing so far this season. What on earth has happened? AP
    Casemiro - 5. Too casual and didn’t make a recovery run for Welbeck’s goal. Didn’t have the legs you need against Brighton. Disappointing so far this season. What on earth has happened? AP
  • Scott McTominay - 5: First start of the season for his club. Didn’t do enough to stop Brighton’s second and struggled to stop them dominating possession. EPA
    Scott McTominay - 5: First start of the season for his club. Didn’t do enough to stop Brighton’s second and struggled to stop them dominating possession. EPA
  • Bruno Fernandes - 5: Began on the right of a midfield, which started well, but got deeper and deeper against the best team to visit Old Trafford so far this season. Booked before the break. AFP
    Bruno Fernandes - 5: Began on the right of a midfield, which started well, but got deeper and deeper against the best team to visit Old Trafford so far this season. Booked before the break. AFP
  • Christian Eriksen - 6. Beautiful pirouette to start a ninth- minute attack as United started on the front foot with high pressing. Tried to set up attacks for United who had 14 shots, but only four on target. Brighton had 10 shots – eight on target. AP
    Christian Eriksen - 6. Beautiful pirouette to start a ninth- minute attack as United started on the front foot with high pressing. Tried to set up attacks for United who had 14 shots, but only four on target. Brighton had 10 shots – eight on target. AP
  • Marcus Rashford - 6: Drove into the box from the left. Took the first shot on target in the game – and the second after 11 minutes. And the third after 25, then the fourth, which hit the post on 33. Another shot went wide on 46. PA
    Marcus Rashford - 6: Drove into the box from the left. Took the first shot on target in the game – and the second after 11 minutes. And the third after 25, then the fourth, which hit the post on 33. Another shot went wide on 46. PA
  • Rasmus Hojlund - 6: Aggressive on his first United start, getting in front of Dunk for early crosses. Thought he’d scored after 40 minutes. VAR didn’t. Linked well with Rashford. Decision to bring him off was booed. Getty
    Rasmus Hojlund - 6: Aggressive on his first United start, getting in front of Dunk for early crosses. Thought he’d scored after 40 minutes. VAR didn’t. Linked well with Rashford. Decision to bring him off was booed. Getty
  • SUBS: Hannibal Mejbri (for Casemiro on 64') - 7: Pulled one back with a shot on the half turn from distance nine minutes later. Booked for a challenge on Ferguson, but a determined cameo. AFP
    SUBS: Hannibal Mejbri (for Casemiro on 64') - 7: Pulled one back with a shot on the half turn from distance nine minutes later. Booked for a challenge on Ferguson, but a determined cameo. AFP
  • Anthony Martial (for Hojlund 64') - 4: Almost no impact. AP
    Anthony Martial (for Hojlund 64') - 4: Almost no impact. AP
  • Alejandro Garnacho (for McTominay 85') - NR: Fans had sung his name. He came on as a last gamble. It was all too late. Getty
    Alejandro Garnacho (for McTominay 85') - NR: Fans had sung his name. He came on as a last gamble. It was all too late. Getty
  • Aaron Wan-Bissaka (for Reguillon on 85') - NR: Went to right back. Getty
    Aaron Wan-Bissaka (for Reguillon on 85') - NR: Went to right back. Getty
  • Facundo Pellistri (for Martinez on 85') - NR: Is he ever going to get sufficient minutes to show what he can really do, or not do? AP
    Facundo Pellistri (for Martinez on 85') - NR: Is he ever going to get sufficient minutes to show what he can really do, or not do? AP
  • BRIGHTON RATINGS: Jason Steele - 7: Great distribution with his feet. Good anticipation to come out of his box and deny Rashford an opportunity from a long ball. Easy save from long-range Fernandes effort and another good stop from a Rashford free kick. No chance for Hannibal's goal. EPA
    BRIGHTON RATINGS: Jason Steele - 7: Great distribution with his feet. Good anticipation to come out of his box and deny Rashford an opportunity from a long ball. Easy save from long-range Fernandes effort and another good stop from a Rashford free kick. No chance for Hannibal's goal. EPA
  • Joel Veltman - 6: Given a tough time by the pace of Rashford at times but made a vital block to deflect the United forward's first-half shot against the woodwork. Generally comfortable with the ball at his feet. Wasted a good chance to play Welbeck in from the edge of the area. Fiercely committed. EPA
    Joel Veltman - 6: Given a tough time by the pace of Rashford at times but made a vital block to deflect the United forward's first-half shot against the woodwork. Generally comfortable with the ball at his feet. Wasted a good chance to play Welbeck in from the edge of the area. Fiercely committed. EPA
  • Jan Paul van Hecke - 8: Strong headed clearance from a United corner on 34 minutes. Twice managed to shepherd Rashford well as he broke into the box early in the second half. Snuffed out an opening for Hojlund. Getty
    Jan Paul van Hecke - 8: Strong headed clearance from a United corner on 34 minutes. Twice managed to shepherd Rashford well as he broke into the box early in the second half. Snuffed out an opening for Hojlund. Getty
  • Lewis Dunk - 8: Solid in the heart of the Brighton defence. Cool under pressure and distributed well. Impressive shift. EPA
    Lewis Dunk - 8: Solid in the heart of the Brighton defence. Cool under pressure and distributed well. Impressive shift. EPA
  • Tariq Lamptey - 7: Neat work on the left flank. Came forward well and involved in some well-worked passing moves out wide. Lovely ball to tee up Joao Pedro for Brighton's third. EPA
    Tariq Lamptey - 7: Neat work on the left flank. Came forward well and involved in some well-worked passing moves out wide. Lovely ball to tee up Joao Pedro for Brighton's third. EPA
  • Pascal Gross - 9: Fresh from his first senior cap for Germany aged 32, he was the midfield kingpin for his team, linking up play and spraying passes before finishing brilliantly for Brighton's second. Reuters
    Pascal Gross - 9: Fresh from his first senior cap for Germany aged 32, he was the midfield kingpin for his team, linking up play and spraying passes before finishing brilliantly for Brighton's second. Reuters
  • Mahmoud Dahoud - 6: Battled well on his first start since the opening game at Luton. PA
    Mahmoud Dahoud - 6: Battled well on his first start since the opening game at Luton. PA
  • Simon Adingra - 6: Put Onana under pressure early in the second half with some sharp pressing. Showed great anticipation to cut out a dangerous cross-field pass. Allowed Reguilon to wriggle past him late in the game. EPA
    Simon Adingra - 6: Put Onana under pressure early in the second half with some sharp pressing. Showed great anticipation to cut out a dangerous cross-field pass. Allowed Reguilon to wriggle past him late in the game. EPA
  • Adam Lallana - 7: Nice dummy to assist Welbeck's opener. Pressed United's backline well. Worked hard defensively. Getty
    Adam Lallana - 7: Nice dummy to assist Welbeck's opener. Pressed United's backline well. Worked hard defensively. Getty
  • Kaoru Mitoma - 7: Harried the United defence well. Quiet game until he helped to set up Gross's goal. Surging run into the box in the 78th minute. EPA
    Kaoru Mitoma - 7: Harried the United defence well. Quiet game until he helped to set up Gross's goal. Surging run into the box in the 78th minute. EPA
  • Danny Welbeck - 8: Sweet left-foot finish for Brighton's opener after he'd played the ball wide for cross into the box. Went close with a crisp strike from outside the box on 32 minutes. Held the ball up well and dropped back to put in a shift helping out his defence when required. AFP
    Danny Welbeck - 8: Sweet left-foot finish for Brighton's opener after he'd played the ball wide for cross into the box. Went close with a crisp strike from outside the box on 32 minutes. Held the ball up well and dropped back to put in a shift helping out his defence when required. AFP
  • SUBS: Joao Pedro (for Welbeck 64') - 8: Stunning side-footed finish from the edge of the box. Wonderful technique. Looked good in everything he did. EPA
    SUBS: Joao Pedro (for Welbeck 64') - 8: Stunning side-footed finish from the edge of the box. Wonderful technique. Looked good in everything he did. EPA
  • Ansu Fati (for Lallana 64') - 7: Set up Evan Ferguson on the edge of the area. Decent strike just inside the box that forced a sharp save from Onana. Another lightning quick run to force a save in added time. Promising debut. EPA
    Ansu Fati (for Lallana 64') - 7: Set up Evan Ferguson on the edge of the area. Decent strike just inside the box that forced a sharp save from Onana. Another lightning quick run to force a save in added time. Promising debut. EPA
  • James Milner (for Lamptey 76') - NR. Good clearing header in the box. EPA
    James Milner (for Lamptey 76') - NR. Good clearing header in the box. EPA
  • Billy Gilmour (for Dahoud 76') - NR. Reuters
    Billy Gilmour (for Dahoud 76') - NR. Reuters
  • Evan Ferguson (for Adingra 83') - NR: Decent effort saved by Onana. EPA
    Evan Ferguson (for Adingra 83') - NR: Decent effort saved by Onana. EPA

Manchester United v Brighton ratings: Onana 5, Mejbri 7; Gross 9, Welbeck 8


Andy Mitten
  • English
  • Arabic

Manchester United saw their long unbeaten run at Old Trafford come to a juddering halt as they lost 3-1 against Brighton on Saturday.

United manager Erik ten Hag must have hoped he could get his side's season back on track on the pitch after a fortnight beset by off-field controversies.

With Jadon Sancho banned from training with the first-team squad in the aftermath of his social media spat with his manager and Brazil winger Antony given a leave of absence over alleged assault allegations, the Dutchman must have been looking forward to concentrating on the task of winning football matches.

But goals from former United man Danny Welbeck, Pascal Gross, and Joao Pedro meant they followed up their last-gasp defeat at Arsenal before the international break with another loss – their third already this season.

Substitute Hannibal Mejbri's strike for United was scant consolation for a side now heading into full-blown crisis territory.

In his first start for United, Rasmus Hojlund thought he had scored, only for VAR to chalk the goal off after Marcus Rashford had allowed it to go out of play before crossing to the Danish striker.

After the game, Ten Hag said: "We are disappointed and I think it's normal, especially when you have seen the game.

"Such small margins. In the first half, we created a lot of chances but we didn't score and they scored in their first attack.

"We fought back and then we got the goal, or at least we thought we got a goal and then it's disallowed.

"We have to improve, there are things for the team and the individuals, who now have to step up."

To read Andy Mitten's ratings from the game, check out the gallery above. To move to the next photo, click on the arrows or swipe if using a mobile device.

Updated: September 17, 2023, 3:20 AM