Discrediting of Murdoch has devolved to tabloid tactics


  • English
  • Arabic

Those not closely acquainted with the workings of the UK's House of Commons Select Committee on Culture, Media and Sport (most people, I assume) should read the following before assessing the latest dilemma facing News Corp's Rupert Murdoch.

Last week the committee issued a report claiming that Mr Murdoch was "not a fit person" to run a global media organisation. Headlines around the world implied that the country's main legislative assembly had condemned the man.

Select committees have powers to scrutinise, not to enact policy. Their findings are based on the insights of cross-party members of parliament and those, such as Mr Murdoch, who engage in committee proceedings (as a foreign national, he was not compelled to). The media committee does not have the heft of others, such as the Public Accounts Committee, which cover the work of government and issues of taxpayer value.

Before it got its teeth into the Murdoch phone hacking business, the media committee was considered a bit of a backwater, good for getting free tickets to Covent Garden or Wimbledon. But its profile has been greatly enhanced because it became the focal point of a wider battle between Government and the opposition Labour Party, between the political class and the Fourth Estate, between businesses seeking to extend or protect their turf and even between celebrities and tabloid editors.

This narrative runs across the related but separate inquiry taking place under Lord Justice Leveson, where similar themes - alleged collusion between politicians and media executives and media standards and regulation - are under consideration.

Thus we have questions of political influence being brought to bear on a takeover bid for BSkyB being introduced, alongside evidence by the actor Hugh Grant - who complained about undue media attention.

Nowhere have wider political motives been more obvious than in the process leading up to the Media and Sport committee's conclusions on Mr Murdoch. Tom Watson, the opposition MP whose inquisitorial style earned him the title of Mr Murdoch's "tormentor in chief", has now been accused by fellow members of shoehorning the "not fit" passage into the report at the last minute.

The findings were not unanimous, dissenters claim, further hinting that the report was intended to help the opposition Labour candidate secure the then-imminent London mayoral election.

Mr Watson has become a media darling as a result of the committee's deliberations and managed to take enough time off the business of haranguing Mr Murdoch to produce a book - also haranguing Mr Murdoch.

Mr Watson was a Gordon Brown loyalist when Mr Murdoch's newspapers switched support from the then-Labour government headed by Mr Brown to the Conservatives.

Irrespective of possible motivations, it was indecorous for a parliamentary institution to insert such an intemperate and ill-conceived phrase into a report that otherwise might have done some good. The committee, whose business was to probe into media ethics, itself resorted to tabloid excess.

After the "not fit" headline had done its damage, Louise Mensch, a Conservative member of the committee, said Mr Murdoch "is self- evidently fit to run a major company and is one of the most legendary newspapermen of all time".

She is right on both counts. The industry benefited greatly from Mr Murdoch's decision to acquire British newspapers, in the process breaking the back of the unions and transforming the economics of the trade in favour of growth, fresh launches and the survival of titles that otherwise would have closed years ago.

The CCMS report and the Leveson inquiry have ventured into territory beyond phone hacking and paying the police for tips. They have created an impression that it is wrong for a businessman such as Mr Murdoch to lobby government and others in order to further his company's ambitions and increase shareholder value.

But this is what good businessmen do. If elected officials or public servants fall for it, they are the ones who are "not fit". Evidence to the Leveson inquiry later this week, from former Murdoch executives on ties with government, is expected to shed further light on this.

Moon Music

Artist: Coldplay

Label: Parlophone/Atlantic

Number of tracks: 10

Rating: 3/5

Islamophobia definition

A widely accepted definition was made by the All Party Parliamentary Group on British Muslims in 2019: “Islamophobia is rooted in racism and is a type of racism that targets expressions of Muslimness or perceived Muslimness.” It further defines it as “inciting hatred or violence against Muslims”.

What vitamins do we know are beneficial for living in the UAE

Vitamin D: Highly relevant in the UAE due to limited sun exposure; supports bone health, immunity and mood.Vitamin B12: Important for nerve health and energy production, especially for vegetarians, vegans and individuals with absorption issues.Iron: Useful only when deficiency or anaemia is confirmed; helps reduce fatigue and support immunity.Omega-3 (EPA/DHA): Supports heart health and reduces inflammation, especially for those who consume little fish.

MOUNTAINHEAD REVIEW

Starring: Ramy Youssef, Steve Carell, Jason Schwartzman

Director: Jesse Armstrong

Rating: 3.5/5

The specs

Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl turbo

Power: 261hp at 5,500rpm

Torque: 405Nm at 1,750-3,500rpm

Transmission: 9-speed auto

Fuel consumption: 6.9L/100km

On sale: Now

Price: From Dh117,059

Mubalada World Tennis Championship 2018 schedule

Thursday December 27

Men's quarter-finals

Kevin Anderson v Hyeon Chung 4pm

Dominic Thiem v Karen Khachanov 6pm

Women's exhibition

Serena Williams v Venus Williams 8pm

Friday December 28

5th place play-off 3pm

Men's semi-finals

Rafael Nadal v Anderson/Chung 5pm

Novak Djokovic v Thiem/Khachanov 7pm

Saturday December 29

3rd place play-off 5pm

Men's final 7pm