Netanyahu defends overhaul of Israel's judicial system after mass anti-government rally

The Prime Minister says Israel will remain a 'robust democracy' as House Speaker Kevin McCarthy prepares visit to the country

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attend the weekly cabinet meeting in the prime minister's office in Jerusalem, 30 April 2023. EPA / ABIR SULTAN / POOL

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu doubled down on controversial plans to overhaul the judicial system on Sunday, pledging the country would remain a “robust democracy” as a top US leader prepared to visit.

“Israel has been thrown off balance,” Mr Netanyahu argued. “The big challenge is to bring it back to a balance that is accepted in most democracies … without going to the side that would indeed remove checks and balances on the power of the majority.”

Mr Netanyahu spoke on Sunday to CNN's Fareed Zakaria a day after protesters stormed the streets of Israel in opposition to the judicial reform plan.

Thousands rallied in Tel Aviv ahead of Israeli legislators' return for a new parliament session, against the reform plan pushed by Mr Netanyahu's historically right-wing, ultranationalist government. It seeks to weaken the Supreme Court and increase the government's role in selecting its judges.

An Israeli army officer was removed from his post on Sunday for attending a political protest in uniform, the first such case during the political crisis.

Meanwhile, Israel's Haaretz reported that seven hundred elite military reservists signed a letter to Mr Netanyahu saying the reserve system will begin “to collapse” if the proposed reforms pass.

The American-educated prime minister made the appeal as the US House Leader Kevin McCarthy landed in Israel with a bipartisan delegation celebrating the 75th anniversary of the country's establishment.

Washington has historically maintained a strong pro-Israel track record, but the judicial reform has caused friction between the stalwart allies.

More than half of all foreign military aid that US President Joe Biden, a personal friend of Mr Netanyahu, requested for the fiscal year of 2022 was earmarked for Israel, according to the Council on Foreign Relations, a think tank.

Under a 2016 agreement, Washington committed to providing about $4 billion to Israel each year, including $500 million for missile defence.

Last month, after Mr Netanyahu threatened the ousting of a defence minister opposed to the measure, the White House said it was “deeply concerned”.

“We are deeply concerned by today’s developments out of Israel, which further underscore the urgent need for compromise,” National Security Council spokesperson Adrienne Watson said in a March statement.

“Democratic values have always been, and must remain, a hallmark of the US-Israel relationship,” she added.

Protesters at a mass 'Independence party' demonstration against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his government's judicial reforms, in Tel Aviv on April 25. Reuters

The Tel Aviv demonstrators chant and wave flags. Getty

Protesters at their 75th Israel Independence Day rally. Getty

A Tel Aviv protester lights a flare as he demonstrates against the Israeli government's proposed judicial overhaul. Getty

Protesters at the mass 'Independence party' in Tel Aviv. Reuters

Protesters at the mass 'Independence party' in Tel Aviv. AP

Protesters at the mass 'Independence party' in Tel Aviv. Reuters

Protesters at the mass 'Independence party' in Tel Aviv. Reuters

Protesters at the mass 'Independence party' in Tel Aviv. Reuters

Protesters at the mass 'Independence party' in Tel Aviv. Reuters

Demonstrators light flares during the anti-judicial reform protests on Israel's 75th anniversary of statehood in Tel Aviv. AFP

Demonstrators chant during a rally in Tel Aviv to protest the Israeli government's judicial overhaul bill, as the country begins celebrations for its 75th anniversary, on April 25, 2023. AFP

Protesters at the mass 'Independence party' in Tel Aviv. Reuters

A demonstrator with a megaphone leads chants at the Tel Aviv protest as the country begins celebrations for its 75th anniversary, on April 25. AFP

Demonstrators raise a large banner demanding 'democracy'. AFP

The 'Independence party' rally in Tel Aviv'. Reuters

A little protester on her dad's shoulders. AFP

Demonstrators raise Israeli flags near a banner depicting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. AFP