UK's Rwanda plan 'not deterring desperate migrants from crossing Channel'

Charities call for safe way for refugees to get to UK and claim asylum

Migrants are taken into Dover, Kent, on a Border Force vessel, after a small boat incident in the English Channel, on May 2. PA

Refugee charities said the British government’s plan to send migrants to Rwanda has done little to deter people from making the perilous journey to the UK, as Channel crossings resumed at the weekend.

On Sunday, 254 people were detected in small boats crossing from France after an 11-day pause in such trips.

More migrants were taken to Dover on Bank Holiday Monday, including children, with the BBC reporting that more than 100 had been taken to shore by the afternoon.

The official figures for Monday’s crossings from the Ministry of Defence are not expected until Tuesday.

Confirmation of Sunday’s figures from the ministry came after what is believed to have been an 11-day break in activity around the Channel, from April 20 to 30, when no crossings were recorded amid reports of strong winds and choppy seas.

The ministry took over control of migrant operations in April, when the government also announced controversial plans to send some of those making the cross-Channel journey to Rwanda.

The government’s Nationality and Borders Bill — called the anti-refugee Bill by campaigners because it makes knowingly arriving in the UK illegally a criminal offence and includes powers to process asylum seekers overseas — became law on Thursday.

But refugee organisations said the Bill did “nothing to address the reasons people come”, with one charity saying most migrants it spoke to said the plan would not put them off crossing to the UK.

The Rwanda deal will see the East African nation receive asylum seekers deemed by the UK to be inadmissible, having arrived “illegally” under new immigration rules.

Care4Calais said that of the 64 people it surveyed, 87 per cent had heard of the plan and 75 per cent said “it won’t put them off crossing to the UK”.

“They have no choice. They’ve fled danger, made long, dangerous journeys, and France ‘does not give you security’, as one said,” the charity said on Twitter.

It called the Rwanda deal — which Home Secretary Priti Patel has described as a “world-first” agreement — “just another in a long line of deterrence policies announced by this government over the last few years”.

“Refugees have escaped from the worst horrors in this world," Care4Calais said. "When you’re risking your life, what else do you have to lose?

"When someone explains ‘even death wouldn’t stop me’ trying to get to the UK, it’s clear that even the threat of Rwanda won’t change anything."

• 

  British Home Secretary Priti Patel has challenged opponents of her plan to send migrants to Rwanda to come up with a better idea to tackle small-boat crossings in the Channel. PA

• 

  A rescuer carries a child as migrants are brought in to Dover, Kent, after a small-boat incident in the English Channel. PA

• 

  Under the new proposals, asylum seekers who try to enter the UK through the English Channel route from France will be flown to Rwanda in Africa on a one-way ticket. PA

• 

  A migrant found at sea while attempting to cross the English Channel boards a bus to be taken for processing in Dover. AFP

• 

  A border force officer parks a dingy used to carry migrants at Dover Port. Getty Images

• 

  The number of migrants who have reached the UK by crossing the English Channel has topped 6,000 so far this year, official figures showed. Getty Images

• 

  British navy ship 'HMS Tyne' on patrol in the English Channel off the coast of Dover. PA

• 

  A group of people thought to be migrants are brought in to Dover, Kent, on board a Border Force vessel. PA

Such sentiments were echoed by Pierre-Henri Dumont, French National Assembly member for Calais.

“When you leave your country because of flood, because of starvation, because you are not afraid of being hauled and sent back to another country, at least if you have a chance you will try,” Mr Dumont told BBC Radio 4.

He said there was evidence that UK government plans to process asylum applications in Rwanda was encouraging migrants to try the crossing before these measures took effect.

“From what I heard from the migrants, it seems that the news of the new legislation in the UK with Rwanda gives the smugglers the availability of new commercial arguments to the migrants to urge them to cross quickly for them not to be sent away because of this new legislation,” Mr Dumont said.

Enver Solomon, chief executive of the Refugee Council, said the resumption of crossings at the weekend showed that “draconian policies enshrined in the Nationality and Borders Bill and their Rwanda deal are doing little to deter desperate people jumping on boats because they do nothing to address the reasons people come”.

Mr Solomon called on the UK to have a “grown-up conversation with France and the EU about sharing responsibility”.

“We need a fair and humane asylum system, which means well thought-out, long-term solutions that address why people are forced from their homes, and provides them with safe routes to the UK,” he said.

Sunday’s figures mean at least 6,947 people have reached the UK since the start of the year after navigating busy shipping lanes from France in small boats, data compiled by PA show.

That is more than three times the amount recorded by this time last year (2,004) and more than six times the figure for the same period in 2020 (1,006).

Typically there can be periods of several days or weeks without migrant crossings, often depending on weather conditions.

Two longer gaps of 16 and 13 days without crossings were recorded this year, before the Rwanda deal was announced.

The longest period without any crossings so far in 2022 was 16 days, between January 27 and February 11, PA analysis of government figures shows.

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer said there needed to be “an international co-ordinated criminal response” to tackle the “criminal gangs” who he said were driving the migrant crisis.

“I know what can be done if you’ve got teams working together across Europe all the way along those routes, absolutely bearing down on these criminal gangs, and working very closely with the French authorities as well,” he said on the campaign trail in Worthing, West Sussex.

Mr Solomon said that those “coming across the channel are fleeing atrocities like those in Ukraine and Afghanistan”.

Care4Calais said there was is no longer a build-up of Ukrainians in Calais “because they can apply for visas from anywhere”.

Renewing their call for the option of visa applications for all refugees, the charity said: “The answer to many problems in Calais is to let refugees apply for visas to cross the Channel safely.

"Because now, unless you’re Ukrainian, there’s no safe way for a refugee to get to the UK and claim asylum.

"That would put people smugglers out of business and save lives.”