• UNITED RATINGS. Double save from Foden then Haaland early on. Booked for time-wasting before the penalty, when Haaland sent him the wrong way. Flew across goal to save Haaland’s header on 45. Saved from Grealish on 56 and then Haaland on 70. PA
    Andre Onana 7/10
    UNITED RATINGS. Double save from Foden then Haaland early on. Booked for time-wasting before the penalty, when Haaland sent him the wrong way. Flew across goal to save Haaland’s header on 45. Saved from Grealish on 56 and then Haaland on 70. PA
    UNITED RATINGS. Double save from Foden then Haaland early on. Booked for time-wasting before the penalty, when Haaland sent him the wrong way. Flew across goal to save Haaland’s header on 45. Saved fr
  • Overhit a first minute cross after a bright United start and saw balls slipped past him by Grealish. Defended a free-kick well – and that was about the best moment in a humiliating afternoon. AFP
    Diogo Dalot 4/10
    Overhit a first minute cross after a bright United start and saw balls slipped past him by Grealish. Defended a free-kick well – and that was about the best moment in a humiliating afternoon. AFP
    Overhit a first minute cross after a bright United start and saw balls slipped past him by Grealish. Defended a free-kick well – and that was about the best moment in a humiliating afternoon. AFP
  • Cleared the ball off the line after 7 minutes. Missed a header on 35 as United wobbled. And then it all got worse and worse. AP
    Harry Maguire 4/10
    Cleared the ball off the line after 7 minutes. Missed a header on 35 as United wobbled. And then it all got worse and worse. AP
    Cleared the ball off the line after 7 minutes. Missed a header on 35 as United wobbled. And then it all got worse and worse. AP
  • He wouldn’t have expected to start in the Manchester derby when he signed in the summer. Up against a better team all afternoon. Nowhere for the third. Reuters
    Jonny Evans 4/10
    He wouldn’t have expected to start in the Manchester derby when he signed in the summer. Up against a better team all afternoon. Nowhere for the third. Reuters
    He wouldn’t have expected to start in the Manchester derby when he signed in the summer. Up against a better team all afternoon. Nowhere for the third. Reuters
  • Struggled at left back. A difficult afternoon as dangerous balls were played into his area. PA
    Victor Lindelof 4/10
    Struggled at left back. A difficult afternoon as dangerous balls were played into his area. PA
    Struggled at left back. A difficult afternoon as dangerous balls were played into his area. PA
  • Holding midfielder in place of the injured Casemiro. Booked for an overreaction to an altercation with Foden. Taken off at half time and while he’d only had 19 touches, his team regressed without him. Hasn’t done anything to show he’s good enough to play for a decent United side. Getty
    Sofyan Amrabat 4/10
    Holding midfielder in place of the injured Casemiro. Booked for an overreaction to an altercation with Foden. Taken off at half time and while he’d only had 19 touches, his team regressed without him. Hasn’t done anything to show he’s good enough to play for a decent United side. Getty
    Holding midfielder in place of the injured Casemiro. Booked for an overreaction to an altercation with Foden. Taken off at half time and while he’d only had 19 touches, his team regressed without him.
  • First start in six weeks. Played well when he came on versus Copenhagen midweek. Didn’t play well in the derby. Rodri walked past him to shoot before City’s third goal. Getty
    Christian Eriksen 4/10
    First start in six weeks. Played well when he came on versus Copenhagen midweek. Didn’t play well in the derby. Rodri walked past him to shoot before City’s third goal. Getty
    First start in six weeks. Played well when he came on versus Copenhagen midweek. Didn’t play well in the derby. Rodri walked past him to shoot before City’s third goal. Getty
  • Rolled United's first shot on target at the start of the first half and then struck the second well at the end of the first half. Reuters
    Scott McTominay 5/10
    Rolled United's first shot on target at the start of the first half and then struck the second well at the end of the first half. Reuters
    Rolled United's first shot on target at the start of the first half and then struck the second well at the end of the first half. Reuters
  • Bright start for the first six minutes as, like in the last Old Trafford derby, he played on the right. Hit a shot well on target on 47, but he captained a side who had 38% of possession and who were, as fully expected, totally outclassed. AP
    Bruno Fernandes 5/10
    Bright start for the first six minutes as, like in the last Old Trafford derby, he played on the right. Hit a shot well on target on 47, but he captained a side who had 38% of possession and who were, as fully expected, totally outclassed. AP
    Bright start for the first six minutes as, like in the last Old Trafford derby, he played on the right. Hit a shot well on target on 47, but he captained a side who had 38% of possession and who were,
  • Subdued by City’s dominance, he’s having an awful season like his team. Should’ve done better with an Eriksen ball and a rare Walker slip on 69, but he shot wide. Getty
    Marcus Rashford 4/10
    Subdued by City’s dominance, he’s having an awful season like his team. Should’ve done better with an Eriksen ball and a rare Walker slip on 69, but he shot wide. Getty
    Subdued by City’s dominance, he’s having an awful season like his team. Should’ve done better with an Eriksen ball and a rare Walker slip on 69, but he shot wide. Getty
  • Lost Rodri to concede a soft 23rd minute penalty, then ran forward towards goal before being knocked off balance by Stones in the area. Unlike Rodri, he didn’t wave for a foul. Still to score in the league. EPA
    Rasmus Hojlund 5/10
    Lost Rodri to concede a soft 23rd minute penalty, then ran forward towards goal before being knocked off balance by Stones in the area. Unlike Rodri, he didn’t wave for a foul. Still to score in the league. EPA
    Lost Rodri to concede a soft 23rd minute penalty, then ran forward towards goal before being knocked off balance by Stones in the area. Unlike Rodri, he didn’t wave for a foul. Still to score in the l
  • UNITED SUBS. (On for Amrabat, 45') Came on at half-time and played more defensively than usual. PA
    Mason Mount 4/10
    UNITED SUBS. (On for Amrabat, 45') Came on at half-time and played more defensively than usual. PA
    UNITED SUBS. (On for Amrabat, 45') Came on at half-time and played more defensively than usual. PA
  • (On for Hojlund 73'). He usually makes an impact when he comes on. Not today. PA
    Alejandro Garnacho 5/10
    (On for Hojlund 73'). He usually makes an impact when he comes on. Not today. PA
    (On for Hojlund 73'). He usually makes an impact when he comes on. Not today. PA
  • (On for Lindleof 73'). The left back who didn’t start ahead of someone who isn’t a left back. What could he do, the damage was done. Antony (on for Eriksen, 86'): N/A. Martial (on for Rashford, 86'): N/A. Getty
    Sergio Reguilon 5/10
    (On for Lindleof 73'). The left back who didn’t start ahead of someone who isn’t a left back. What could he do, the damage was done. Antony (on for Eriksen, 86'): N/A. Martial (on for Rashford, 86'): N/A. Getty
    (On for Lindleof 73'). The left back who didn’t start ahead of someone who isn’t a left back. What could he do, the damage was done. Antony (on for Eriksen, 86'): N/A. Martial (on for Rashford, 86'):
  • CITY RATINGS. Made a great save to deny McTominay on stroke of half-time and also stayed on his feet long enough to push Hojlund wide when racing through. Came up trumps in big moments despite not having much to do. PA
    Ederson 7/10
    CITY RATINGS. Made a great save to deny McTominay on stroke of half-time and also stayed on his feet long enough to push Hojlund wide when racing through. Came up trumps in big moments despite not having much to do. PA
    CITY RATINGS. Made a great save to deny McTominay on stroke of half-time and also stayed on his feet long enough to push Hojlund wide when racing through. Came up trumps in big moments despite not hav
  • Defended well apart from one lapse up against Rashford early in the second half. Getty
    Kyle Walker 7/10
    Defended well apart from one lapse up against Rashford early in the second half. Getty
    Defended well apart from one lapse up against Rashford early in the second half. Getty
  • Solid, steady game from the Portuguese centre-back. EPA
    Ruben Dias 7/10
    Solid, steady game from the Portuguese centre-back. EPA
    Solid, steady game from the Portuguese centre-back. EPA
  • Kept stepping into midfield to make the extra man and also defended superbly in tracking and doing enough to stop Hojlund as he raced in on goal. Getty
    John Stones 8/10
    Kept stepping into midfield to make the extra man and also defended superbly in tracking and doing enough to stop Hojlund as he raced in on goal. Getty
    Kept stepping into midfield to make the extra man and also defended superbly in tracking and doing enough to stop Hojlund as he raced in on goal. Getty
  • Careless with the ball in the first half but soon settled into his first Manchester derby. Nullified the threat of Fernandes. Reuters
    Josko Gvardiol 7/10
    Careless with the ball in the first half but soon settled into his first Manchester derby. Nullified the threat of Fernandes. Reuters
    Careless with the ball in the first half but soon settled into his first Manchester derby. Nullified the threat of Fernandes. Reuters
  • His usual tidy self in possession and defensively astute. Created chance with excellent early cross and won his side a penalty. Getty
    Rodri 8/10
    His usual tidy self in possession and defensively astute. Created chance with excellent early cross and won his side a penalty. Getty
    His usual tidy self in possession and defensively astute. Created chance with excellent early cross and won his side a penalty. Getty
  • Man of the match display. Caused United all sorts of problems when drifting into the inside left channel. At his creative best. EPA
    Bernardo Silva 9/10
    Man of the match display. Caused United all sorts of problems when drifting into the inside left channel. At his creative best. EPA
    Man of the match display. Caused United all sorts of problems when drifting into the inside left channel. At his creative best. EPA
  • Bit of a mixed bag with some wayward passing and poor decisions but added incisiveness and scored the third. AFP
    Phil Foden 7/10
    Bit of a mixed bag with some wayward passing and poor decisions but added incisiveness and scored the third. AFP
    Bit of a mixed bag with some wayward passing and poor decisions but added incisiveness and scored the third. AFP
  • Livewire in and around the box. Linked well with teammates, lots of little give and goes caused United problems. Reuters
    Julian Alvarez 7/10
    Livewire in and around the box. Linked well with teammates, lots of little give and goes caused United problems. Reuters
    Livewire in and around the box. Linked well with teammates, lots of little give and goes caused United problems. Reuters
  • Impressive on the left. Involved in second goal and tested Onana on a couple of occasions. AFP
    Jack Grealish 8/10
    Impressive on the left. Involved in second goal and tested Onana on a couple of occasions. AFP
    Impressive on the left. Involved in second goal and tested Onana on a couple of occasions. AFP
  • Two goals and assist. Could easily have had his hat-trick given the chances created. Provided a focal point and that finishing touch. There will be many more goals with service like he received here. AFP
    Erling Haaland 8/10
    Two goals and assist. Could easily have had his hat-trick given the chances created. Provided a focal point and that finishing touch. There will be many more goals with service like he received here. AFP
    Two goals and assist. Could easily have had his hat-trick given the chances created. Provided a focal point and that finishing touch. There will be many more goals with service like he received here.
  • CITY SUBS. (On for Alvarez, 87'): N/A
    Jeremy Doku N/A
    CITY SUBS. (On for Alvarez, 87'): N/A
    CITY SUBS. (On for Alvarez, 87'): N/A
  • (On for Grealish, 87'): N/A
    Mateo Kovacic N/A
    (On for Grealish, 87'): N/A
    (On for Grealish, 87'): N/A

Manchester United v Manchester City ratings: Onana 7, Rashford 4; Silva 9, Haaland 8


  • English
  • Arabic

Erling Haaland scored two goals as Manchester City cruised past struggling Manchester United with a 3-0 win at Old Trafford on Sunday to move within two points of top spot in the Premier League.

Haaland slotted home from the penalty spot after Rasmus Hojlund had pulled back Rodri in the box and then headed in a second just after half-time. He later turned provider to set up Phil Foden for City's third.

The visitors began the game outside the top four after some mixed results in the past month.

But Pep Guardiola's team remain strong favourites for an unprecedented fourth consecutive English top-flight title and showed they are a class apart from their local rivals as they moved up to third.

A fifth defeat in their opening 10 league games this season leaves United down in eighth, 11 points off the top.

"Always it is special for us to win here at Old Trafford," said Guardiola.

"It looks easy but it is not. (We have) a lot of respect for United. We were at our best, especially in the second half."

United boss Erik ten Hag said: "It hurts a lot. I think especially because first half the game plan went perfectly. It is only the penalty that changes the game."

To view player ratings from the game scroll or swipe through the gallery at the top of the page.

Updated: October 30, 2023, 5:57 AM