• Palestinians launch fireworks at Israeli police at Al Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem. AP
    Palestinians launch fireworks at Israeli police at Al Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem. AP
  • Israel police have words with a Palestinian worshipper. AP
    Israel police have words with a Palestinian worshipper. AP
  • Officers try to disperse Palestinians in the Al Aqsa Mosque compound. AP
    Officers try to disperse Palestinians in the Al Aqsa Mosque compound. AP
  • Paramedics carry an injured Palestinian. AP
    Paramedics carry an injured Palestinian. AP
  • Israeli border police on patrol at the Lion's Gate in Jerusalem's Old City, as Palestinians wait to be allowed to enter the Al Aqsa Mosque compound. AFP
    Israeli border police on patrol at the Lion's Gate in Jerusalem's Old City, as Palestinians wait to be allowed to enter the Al Aqsa Mosque compound. AFP
  • Israel's Foreign Ministry tweeted video purportedly showing masked Palestinians throwing objects inside the mosque. AFP
    Israel's Foreign Ministry tweeted video purportedly showing masked Palestinians throwing objects inside the mosque. AFP
  • An injured man is stretchered to safety. The foreign ministry denied reports on social media that police had entered the mosque building itself during the violence. Reuters
    An injured man is stretchered to safety. The foreign ministry denied reports on social media that police had entered the mosque building itself during the violence. Reuters

Palestinian orphans mourn mother Israeli soldiers 'shot by mistake'


  • English
  • Arabic

When Ghada Sabatien set out to visit her uncle in a village near Bethlehem, she was not expecting to be caught up in the surge of violence between Israelis and Palestinians.

But the unarmed 45-year-old, who was partially sighted and understood little Hebrew, bled to death in the street after “mistakenly” being shot by an Israeli soldier.

She leaves behind six orphans.

The West Bank village of Husan is usually a quiet backwater, despite being close to a major crossing into Israel.

The shops have signs in Arabic and Hebrew, and Israeli settlers regularly stop there to buy groceries, with few tensions.

Houria Sabatien with three of her grandchildren who were orphaned when their mother, Ghada Sabatien, 45, was shot dead by an Israeli soldier. AFP
Houria Sabatien with three of her grandchildren who were orphaned when their mother, Ghada Sabatien, 45, was shot dead by an Israeli soldier. AFP

At the entrance to the village, Israeli soldiers are stationed on a concrete island that serves as a checkpoint.

On April 10, Sabatien set out to visit her uncle, wearing a hijab and long gown.

On the way back, the walk took her past the makeshift checkpoint.

As she approached, a soldier fired warning shots and shouted.

Sabatien had “eye problems”, her family said, and that she did not speak Hebrew because she had spent years abroad.

In footage taken by a Palestinian TV crew that happened to be filming near by, she appeared to panic.

But she kept walking. The soldier opened fire at her legs, and she fell to the ground.

It took several minutes for an ambulance to arrive. By the time she reached a hospital in the nearby town of Beit Jala, she had lost catastrophic amounts of blood. She died in the hospital.

Sabatien was not wearing an explosive vest or carrying any kind of weapon.

Her family have been in shock and anger ever since she was killed.

“My sister went there and asked a soldier in Hebrew: 'Did she do anything wrong?'” Sabatien's mother, Houria Sabatien, 69, told AFP.

Ghada Sabatien’s son Omar with a picture of his mother at their home in the village of Husan near Bethlehem in the occupied West Bank. AFP
Ghada Sabatien’s son Omar with a picture of his mother at their home in the village of Husan near Bethlehem in the occupied West Bank. AFP

“He answered: 'No'. 'So why did you shoot at her?' she asked. The soldier said: 'Sorry'.”

Around her sat her grandchildren, four of Sabatien's orphans: Omar, Jamila, Mohammed and Moustafa, their eyes glued to the floor.

“They've become orphans. And me, I'm old, I'm afraid for them when they go out, I'm afraid for them because of the army,” Houria said.

“I would like to feed them and show them life. But I'm afraid for their future.”

Moustafa, 15, is struggling to comprehend the tragedy.

“When I lost my mother, it was as if life no longer had any meaning. She was the one who woke us up in the morning, she was the one who welcomed us back from school, she was the one who took care of us,” he said.

“She was everything, she cannot be replaced.”

He reminisced about his mother's delicious maqloubeh, a Palestinian dish of rice and meat, and how she would help with his mathematics homework.

“She made me understand straight away,” he said.

Born into a family of scientists, Sabatien graduated with a degree in mathematics at Bethlehem University and spent 15 years in Jordan, where she was a teacher.

When her husband died four years ago, she returned to Husan with the children.

She prepared meals, helped with homework, read the Quran, visited extended family members, and occasionally gave private lessons.

“She was an independent, peaceful, educated woman who was not interested in politics at all,” her brother, Rafat, said.

He said he had received an apology from the Israeli army for their “mistake “.

AFP approached the army for comment on the killing.

It said she had run “suspiciously” towards the checkpoint and that soldiers had fired at her legs.

“The suspect received initial medical treatment by IDF soldiers at the scene,” it said. “The circumstances of the case are being reviewed.”

The tragedy sparked anger, among Palestinians and overseas.

In a rare move, Washington's envoy to the Palestinians, George Noll, called the family to express his condolences.

The Husan area suffered a surge in night-time protests. One young man, Qusay Hamamra, was killed by Israeli forces after throwing a Molotov cocktail at them.

But Houria said she would teach Ghada's children a different path.

“If we want to fight against Israel, we must do it through education, culture … we cannot stay in hatred,” she said.

“If I love Ghada, I must teach this to her children.”

Updated: April 21, 2022, 6:36 AM