Israeli court’s compromise on Sheikh Jarrah could avoid Palestinian evictions

No conclusion yet in long-running case over right to live in East Jerusalem neighbourhood

Knesset member Ahmad Tibi speaks at a demonstration by Palestinian, Israeli and foreign activists against Israeli occupation and settlement activity. The protest was held outside the Supreme Court in Jerusalem as it convened to rule on the eviction of Palestinian families from their homes in Sheikh Jarrah in the east of the city.

Judges at the Israeli Supreme Court in East Jerusalem discuss the eviction of Palestinian families from their homes in the city’s Sheikh Jarrah district.

Palestinian residents of Sheikh Jarrah attend the discussion at the Israeli Supreme Court in East Jerusalem.

Palestinians attended a discussion at the Israeli Supreme Court in East Jerusalem regarding the removal of Palestinian families from their homes.

Israeli left-wing activists protest against government policy regarding Palestinians in East Jerusalem outside the Supreme Court in Jerusalem.

Israeli left-wing activists protest outside the Supreme Court in Jerusalem against government policy regarding Palestinians in East Jerusalem. The Israeli Supreme Court was discussing the eviction of Palestinian families from their homes in Sheikh Jarrah.

Israel’s Supreme Court on Monday suggested a compromise that would prevent the eviction of dozens of Palestinians from the East Jerusalem neighbourhood of Sheikh Jarrah.

The cases examined by the court involved four Palestinian families made up of about 70 people. Attempts by Jewish settlers to expel them from their homes were among the causes of an 11-day conflict between Israel and Gaza militants in May.

Lower Israeli courts have approved the evictions of the four families. They ruled that their houses were built on land owned by Jews before Israel was established in 1948.

But weighing a last-ditch appeal from the residents, the court came up with a compromise that would give them “protected” status.

The deal would protect them from eviction for many years, but leave the question of legal ownership unanswered, said Ahmad Amara, a consultant to the residents’ legal team.

He said the court gave the sides one week to respond.

The Supreme Court had been scheduled to issue a ruling in May, but it delayed its decision after the attorney general requested more time to consider the cases.

The threatened evictions pose a test for Israel’s new governing coalition, which includes three pro-settlement parties and a small Islamist faction. For the sake of unity, the government has tried to sideline Palestinian issues to avoid internal divisions.

Weeks of unrest – highlighted by heavy-handed Israeli police tactics against residents and demonstrators who supported them – captured international attention before the 11-day conflict in May that killed 260 people in Gaza and 13 in Israel.

A ceasefire took effect on May 21, but the long-running campaign by Jewish settlers to evict dozens of Palestinian families has continued.

The settlers have been waging a decades-long campaign to evict the families from densely populated Palestinian neighbourhoods just outside the walls of the Old City, in one of the most sensitive parts of East Jerusalem.

The settlers say the homes are built on land that was owned by Jews before the 1948 war surrounding Israel’s creation. Israeli law allows Jews to reclaim such property, a right denied to Palestinians who lost land and homes in the same conflict.

Jordan controlled East Jerusalem from 1948 to 1967. The families, who were made refugees during the 1948 war, say that Jordanian authorities offered them their homes in exchange for giving up their refugee status.

Things changed after Israel captured East Jerusalem, along with the West Bank and Gaza, in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war, and annexed it in a move not recognised internationally. The Palestinians want all three territories for their future state and view East Jerusalem as their capital.

In 1972, settler groups told the families that they were trespassing on Jewish-owned land. That was the start of a long legal battle leading to eviction orders against 36 families in Sheikh Jarrah and two other East Jerusalem neighbourhoods.

Israeli rights groups say other families are also vulnerable, estimating that more than 1,000 Palestinians are at risk of being evicted.