Judge dismisses Ashley Judd's harassment claim against Harvey Weinstein

However, US district judge Philip Gutierrez says Judd can move forward with her defamation case against the disgraced producer

FILE - In this March 2, 2014 file photo, Harvey Weinstein arrives at the Oscars in Los Angeles. Weinstein is taking a leave of absence from his own company after The New York Times released a report alleging decades of sexual harassment against women, including employees and actress Ashley Judd. (Photo by Jordan Strauss/Invision/AP, File)
Beta V.1.0 - Powered by automated translation

A Los Angeles court on Wednesday dismissed actress Ashley Judd's sexual harassment lawsuit against disgraced Hollywood producer Harvey Weinstein - but said she can move forward with allegations he defamed her and damaged her career.

US district judge Philip Gutierrez said the law covering sexual harassment within a professional relationship did not apply to sexual advances Weinstein, 66, allegedly made toward Judd in 1997 during a meeting about potential film roles.

However, he did rule that Judd, 50, can proceed with her defamation claim against the producer, who has been accused of sexual abuse by hundreds of women and is facing criminal charges in New York.

One of the first women to accuse him, Judd claims that she rejected unwanted advances from Weinstein, who then tried to wreck her career.

She says Weinstein defamed her by telling Lord of the Rings director Peter Jackson that she was a "nightmare" to work with in 1998, which cost her a role in the award-winning franchise.

Gutierrez said in September that the law upon which Judd's claim was based "has never before been applied to an employer's sexual harassment of a prospective employee, and the court is not convinced that the statute was intended to cover such harassment."

Weinstein's lawyers in July insisted Judd had struck a "deal" with Weinstein allowing him to touch her if she "won an Academy Award in one of his films".

But Judd alleged that she proposed the pact to elude Weinstein after he invited her to his Beverly Hills hotel room.

Judd filed her lawsuit after Jackson confirmed in an interview in New Zealand media that Weinstein had discredited actresses, including Judd, while he was pitching early plans for his movies to the Weinstein-led studio Miramax. Jackson went on to say Weinstein had in the 1990s sought to discredit several actresses who later went on to accuse him of sexual misconduct.


Read more:

Harvey Weinstein: The Hollywood stars at the centre of the allegations

'We got you' - Harvey Weinstein accusers relieved, elated at rape charges

Timeline: 5 key dates in the Harvey Weinstein scandal