Scottish Health Secretary Humza Yousaf, Finance Secretary Kate Forbes, centre, and former minister Ash Regan have called for greater transparency over voting figures. Getty
Scottish Health Secretary Humza Yousaf, Finance Secretary Kate Forbes, centre, and former minister Ash Regan have called for greater transparency over voting figures. Getty
Scottish Health Secretary Humza Yousaf, Finance Secretary Kate Forbes, centre, and former minister Ash Regan have called for greater transparency over voting figures. Getty
Scottish Health Secretary Humza Yousaf, Finance Secretary Kate Forbes, centre, and former minister Ash Regan have called for greater transparency over voting figures. Getty

SNP civil war a step closer as leadership contenders demand access to membership data


Neil Murphy
  • English
  • Arabic

The Scottish National Party has become engulfed in another major row after three leadership candidates called on the party to release their current membership figures, amid accusations that the number was being kept secret.

The party, which seeks to establish Scotland as an independent nation, is currently staging an election to replace Nicola Sturgeon, who announced her intention to step down as First Minister and party leader earlier this year.

The three candidates vying to succeed her - Humza Yousaf, Kate Forbes and Ash Regan - have all said the party must release details of how many people are eligible to vote in the contest which has not been revealed up until now.

Members who have been tasked with electing are having the choice of voting electronically or on paper.

Reports at the weekend suggested that 78,000 online forms were being sent out, though the party has not commented on the figure. The exact size of the electorate remains unclear.

The candidates have been told that the number of votes, percentage share, and turnout will be published when the result is declared on March 27.

The lack of transparency has threatened to further damage the party which has been hit by infighting between factions.

Ms Regan said she has written to SNP chief executive Peter Murrell, who is Ms Sturgeon's husband, on behalf of Ms Forbes and her own campaigns.

She requested the total number of paid-up SNP members and how many digital and paper ballots have been sent out.

Ms Regan’s letter said: “We have previously reached out to the national secretary, Lorna Finn, with a request for this information.

Nicola Sturgeon through the years - in pictures

  • Nicola Sturgeon has resigned as Scotland's First Minister after more than eight years in the role. Here is a look back at her storied career. AP
    Nicola Sturgeon has resigned as Scotland's First Minister after more than eight years in the role. Here is a look back at her storied career. AP
  • British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak meets with Ms Sturgeon in November 2022. PA
    British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak meets with Ms Sturgeon in November 2022. PA
  • Ms Sturgeon receives applause after her keynote speech at the Scottish National Party Conference in October 2022 in Aberdeen. Getty
    Ms Sturgeon receives applause after her keynote speech at the Scottish National Party Conference in October 2022 in Aberdeen. Getty
  • King Charles III during an audience with Ms Sturgeon at the Palace of Holyroodhouse, Edinburgh, in September 2022. PA
    King Charles III during an audience with Ms Sturgeon at the Palace of Holyroodhouse, Edinburgh, in September 2022. PA
  • She receives her second dose of the Oxford/AstraZeneca Covid-19 vaccine in Glasgow in June 2021. Getty
    She receives her second dose of the Oxford/AstraZeneca Covid-19 vaccine in Glasgow in June 2021. Getty
  • Ms Sturgeon is seen taking a selfie on stage at the Scottish National Party conference in Aberdeen in October 2015. Getty
    Ms Sturgeon is seen taking a selfie on stage at the Scottish National Party conference in Aberdeen in October 2015. Getty
  • With former British prime minister David Cameron at the Scottish Parliament in January 2015. PA
    With former British prime minister David Cameron at the Scottish Parliament in January 2015. PA
  • Ms Sturgeon attends her first audience with Queen Elizabeth II at Buckingham Palace in December 2014. Getty
    Ms Sturgeon attends her first audience with Queen Elizabeth II at Buckingham Palace in December 2014. Getty
  • During her swearing-in as Scotland's First Minister at the Court of Session in Edinburgh in November 2014. Getty
    During her swearing-in as Scotland's First Minister at the Court of Session in Edinburgh in November 2014. Getty
  • Ms Sturgeon is congratulated by her husband Peter Murrell after being formally voted in as Scotland's First Minister in 2014. Getty
    Ms Sturgeon is congratulated by her husband Peter Murrell after being formally voted in as Scotland's First Minister in 2014. Getty
  • Former first minister of Scotland Alex Salmond with Ms Sturgeon following his last key note speech as party leader in November 2014 in Perth. Getty
    Former first minister of Scotland Alex Salmond with Ms Sturgeon following his last key note speech as party leader in November 2014 in Perth. Getty
  • Then Scottish National Party deputy leader Ms Sturgeon meets worshippers at Glasgow Central Mosque during the 'Yes' campaign for the Scottish Referendum in September 2014. Getty
    Then Scottish National Party deputy leader Ms Sturgeon meets worshippers at Glasgow Central Mosque during the 'Yes' campaign for the Scottish Referendum in September 2014. Getty
  • Mr Salmond arrives with Ms Sturgeon to deliver his victory speech in Edinburgh in May 2011, after the SNP secured an unprecedented victory in the Parliament elections. Getty
    Mr Salmond arrives with Ms Sturgeon to deliver his victory speech in Edinburgh in May 2011, after the SNP secured an unprecedented victory in the Parliament elections. Getty
  • After her key note speech at the SNP spring conference in April 2009 in Glasgow. Getty
    After her key note speech at the SNP spring conference in April 2009 in Glasgow. Getty
  • Ms Sturgeon attends the STUC Conference in Glasgow in April 2007. Getty
    Ms Sturgeon attends the STUC Conference in Glasgow in April 2007. Getty
  • Mr Salmond and Ms Sturgeon launch the party's election campaign in Edinburgh in January 2005. Getty
    Mr Salmond and Ms Sturgeon launch the party's election campaign in Edinburgh in January 2005. Getty

“However, we have yet to receive a response, which has prompted us to address this matter through a formal open letter.

“As the chief executive of the SNP, it is your responsibility to ensure that the leadership election process is transparent, fair, and equitable.

“Providing this information is crucial to fostering trust and confidence among the candidates, their campaign teams, and the party members who are participating in the election.”

A spokesman for Ms Forbes said: “It is standard practice for any election to be made aware of voting numbers in advance. This should be no different.”

Neil Gray, who is Mr Yousaf’s campaign manager as well as being a Scottish Government minister, said: “Yesterday, Humza’s campaign team also asked for the figures to be published and sought assurances this would be done as soon as possible.”

Figures from the Electoral Commission show that in December 2021, the SNP had around 104,000 members.

An SNP spokesman said: “Candidates have already been made aware that responsibility for the leadership election does not rest with any member of staff.”

Updated: March 16, 2023, 9:52 AM