Abu Dhabi, UAETuesday 27 October 2020

US ELECTIONS

Trump hedging on handing over power highlights legal battles on election

Hundreds of court cases are still ongoing in swing states as lawyers seek to block or back electoral policies with just weeks to go

US President Donald Trump arrives for an event honoring Bay of Pigs veterans in the East Room of the White House in Washington, DC on September 23, 2020. / AFP / MANDEL NGAN
US President Donald Trump arrives for an event honoring Bay of Pigs veterans in the East Room of the White House in Washington, DC on September 23, 2020. / AFP / MANDEL NGAN

US President Donald Trump has declined to commit to a peaceful transfer of power if he loses the November 3 election to Democratic rival Joe Biden, opening up what some experts fear could be a constitutional crisis that would tear apart the foundation of American democracy.

"We're going to have to see what happens," Mr Trump, a Republican, told reporters at the White House when asked if he would commit to handing over the reins to Mr Biden if he loses.

The president has sought repeatedly to cast doubt, pre-emptively, on the legitimacy of the election because of his concerns about mail-in voting, which Democrats have encouraged during the coronavirus pandemic.

"The ballots are a disaster," Mr Trump said on Wednesday.

The comments highlight a race that has already generated an unprecedented wave of election-related litigation, as both sides seek to shape the rules governing how votes are tallied in key states.

With 39 days left on Thursday, the court clashes have spread to every competitive state over seemingly mundane issues such as witness signatures, US mail postmarks and the use of drop boxes for ballots amid the pandemic.

TOPSHOT - Andrew Oros looks at messages of thanks and gratitude taped on a mural memorial to late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in downtown Washington, DC on September 23, 2020. Ginsburg, whose death has opened a crucial Supreme Court seat that Republican President Donald Trump has promised to quickly and controversially fill against the wishes of Democrats, will lie in repose beginning September 23, 2020 at the US high court. Trump will announce his pick to replace Ginsburg Saturday, with Senate Republicans promising a swift vote on the nominee. / AFP / ANDREW CABALLERO-REYNOLDS
Andrew Oros looks at messages of thanks and gratitude taped on a mural memorial to late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in downtown Washington DC. AFP

Mr Trump's unfounded attacks on voting by mail and delivery delays amid cost-cutting measures at the US Postal Service have only intensified the urgency of the litigation.

A Reuters analysis of state and federal court records found more than 200 election-related cases pending as of Tuesday. Overall, at least 250 election lawsuits spurred by the coronavirus have been filed, according to Justin Levitt, a Loyola Law School professor who has been tracking the litigation.

The pandemic has turned what were once minor hurdles, such as witness signature requirements, into potentially major obstacles, while exacerbating existing concerns.

"In the past, long lines would be disenfranchising or deterring, but in this case, they can be deadly," said Myrna Perez, who directs the voting rights and elections programme at New York University's Brennan Centre for Justice.

Democrats generally have sought to ease restrictions on mail ballots, which are surging as voters want to avoid the risk of visiting polling sites.

"The Biden campaign has assembled the biggest voter protection programme in history to ensure our election runs smoothly and to combat any attempt by Donald Trump to interfere in the democratic process," said Mike Gwin, a spokesman for the Democratic candidate.

WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 23: Members of the public pay respects to Associate Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg as her flag-draped casket rests on the Lincoln catafalque on the west front of the U.S. Supreme Court September 23, 2020 in Washington, DC. A pioneering lawyer and according the Chief Justice John Roberts 'a jurist of historic stature,' Ginsburg died September 18 at the age of 87 after a long battle against cancer. Alex Wong/Getty Images/AFP == FOR NEWSPAPERS, INTERNET, TELCOS & TELEVISION USE ONLY ==
Members of the public pay respects to Associate Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg as her flag-draped casket rests on the Lincoln catafalque on the west front of the US Supreme Court. Getty Images via AFP

Republicans say they are trying to prevent illegal voting, although experts say voter fraud is exceedingly rare.

"Democrats are working to shred election integrity measures one state at a time, and there's no question they'll continue their shenanigans from now to November and beyond," said Matthew Morgan, general counsel for the Trump campaign.

A flurry of court decisions this month have delivered several Democratic wins, although many remain subject to appeal. In the key states of Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and North Carolina, officials will count ballots that arrive after November 3, as long as they were sent by Election Day.

Several pending cases, including in competitive Texas, Pennsylvania and Michigan, could have a major impact on those states' elections.

TOPSHOT - Democratic Presidential Candidate Joe Biden speaks with the press before departing Charlotte, North Carolina, on September 23, 2020. / AFP / JIM WATSON
Democratic Presidential Candidate Joe Biden speaks with the press before departing Charlotte, North Carolina. AFP

In Pennsylvania, for instance, Republicans will ask the US Supreme Court to step in after the state's highest court rejected their bid to limit drop boxes and disqualify late-arriving ballots. The Trump campaign is pursuing a separate federal lawsuit over some of the same issues.

In Texas, state Attorney General Ken Paxton, a Republican, has sued officials in Harris County to stop them from sending absentee ballot applications to all voters. The county, which includes Houston, is the state's most populous, with nearly 5 million residents.

Republicans prevailed in several earlier cases.

In Florida, a federal appeals court blocked hundreds of thousands of former convicts from voting in November. In Texas, where only those 65 years and older can vote by mail without having to provide a valid reason such as disability, a series of court rulings have stymied Democratic efforts to extend that right to all residents.

The influx of cases may also be a preview of what is to come after November 3, when new fights could arise over which ballots should be counted.

Both campaigns have assembled armies of lawyers in preparation.

The Biden campaign has lined up hundreds of attorneys and has brought in top lawyers like former US Solicitors General Donald Verrilli and Walter Dellinger and former Attorney General Eric Holder as advisers.

Marc Elias, the Democratic attorney who has co-ordinated many election lawsuits this year on behalf of left-leaning groups, is heading a team focused on state-by-state voter protection.

Mr Trump's campaign, for its part, has filed multiple challenges to states like Nevada and New Jersey that plan to mail a ballot to every voter.

Some Democrats are concerned that if Republicans succeed in getting a successor to the late liberal Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on the Supreme Court before the election, it will ensure Mr Trump wins any dispute that ends up at the high court.

The Supreme Court's decision in 2000 to stop the Florida recount handed the presidency to Republican George W Bush, the only time the high court has decided the outcome of a US presidential election.

Mr Trump has seemingly laid the groundwork for a post-election fight, repeatedly asserting without evidence that voting by mail will yield a "rigged" result.

On Wednesday, the president said explicitly that he wanted to have Ginsburg's successor in place because he expects the election to end up at the Supreme Court.

Mr Levitt said he still trusted that judges would reject challenges not backed by evidence.

"Filing a case costs a few hundred dollars and a lawyer, and can often be useful for messaging," he said. "But courts of law demand evidence that the court of public opinion doesn't." – Reporting by Reuters

Updated: September 24, 2020 04:53 PM

THE DAILY NEWSLETTER
Sign up to our daily email