Firoz Khan and Reshma Pathan pictured in Oman. The couple were among the 17 passengers that died when their bus to Dubai crashed into an overhead height restriction barrier on June 6, 2019. Their son Zidan Firoz Pathan survived. Courtesy Zidan Firoz Pathan
Firoz Khan and Reshma Pathan pictured in Oman. The couple were among the 17 passengers that died when their bus to Dubai crashed into an overhead height restriction barrier on June 6, 2019. Their son Zidan Firoz Pathan survived. Courtesy Zidan Firoz Pathan
Firoz Khan and Reshma Pathan pictured in Oman. The couple were among the 17 passengers that died when their bus to Dubai crashed into an overhead height restriction barrier on June 6, 2019. Their son Zidan Firoz Pathan survived. Courtesy Zidan Firoz Pathan
Firoz Khan and Reshma Pathan pictured in Oman. The couple were among the 17 passengers that died when their bus to Dubai crashed into an overhead height restriction barrier on June 6, 2019. Their son

Survivors and families of bus crash dead say they feel 'left in the dark'


  • English
  • Arabic

Survivors and families of the 17 passengers that died in a bus crash in Dubai last month are appealing to authorities for answers, saying they have been kept in the dark about legal proceedings.

On Tuesday, the driver of the Omani tourist bus admitted to a charge of wrongful death, saying the sun hampered his vision and caused him to crash into an overhead height restriction barrier, killing more than half the passengers on-board.

Those who survived the crash have urged the case be resolved quickly to avoid prolonging their trauma.

Relatives of those who died said that, while the driver had been appointed a lawyer to defend him, they have received no communication from authorities since the fatal accident.

Zidan Firoz Pathan was seated across the aisle from his parents, Firoz Khan and Reshma Pathan, in the bus to Al Rashidiya on June 6. He saw them both die that day.

“We were just planning a holiday in Dubai. Who thought I would lose them both,” said Pathan, 20, who now lives in Mumbai with his grandparents.

“We need justice for our families. It hurts a lot that the man responsible for my parents’ death and the death of so many people has someone to represent him but there is no one to speak for the innocent people who died.”

Police last week said the bus driver, 53, was travelling at twice the speed limit and failed to see warning signs that included road bumps and a height restriction chain.

The force of the crash tore the left side of the bus almost all the way through, killing most sat on that side.

A photograph of Zidan Firoz Pathan taken by his mother Reshma Pathan minutes before a bus crash two years ago. Courtesy Zidan Firoz Pathan
A photograph of Zidan Firoz Pathan taken by his mother Reshma Pathan minutes before a bus crash two years ago. Courtesy Zidan Firoz Pathan

Many of the 31 bus passengers, like Mr Pathan, were tourists or residents from India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Ireland, Germany and the Philippines travelling to Dubai for the Eid break.

“We are not from Dubai or the UAE so it is difficult to understand what documents are required, who we should approach,” said Mr Pathan.

“We need help from the government of Dubai and Oman, the Indian consulate and the bus company.”

The last joyful memory Mr Pathan has is of sharing pizza with his parents about 30 minutes before the crash.

“I was lying across two seats — that is why I survived,” he said.

“Then the glass powder from the smashed windscreen was all over my face and I saw my father on the floor of the bus with his head bleeding.

“My mother was conscious for a few minutes and there was no blood on her face so I thought she was fine when I pulled her out of the bus. But the ambulance guys took her pulse and said she too was no more.”

He said the horrific scene is replayed in nightmares, making it difficult to sleep most nights.

Over the next month, Mr Pathan must travel to Muscat to clear out his father’s rented home and complete paperwork with the petroleum company Khan worked with for more than 13 years.

As in the case of much of the passengers who died, Khan was the family’s sole earning member.

“I look at their photos to remind myself how we were before the accident,” said Mr Pathan, who is studying mechanical engineering in Mumbai.

“People say I’m lucky to be alive but so many have died. There is no one to give us any answers.”

Other families have also joined in to ask for assistance.

"The Oman government and company are helping the driver but it is because of his actions that our families are suffering," said Darpan Moolchandani, who lost his sister Roshni, an aspiring model, in the accident.

“We need help from the Dubai and Oman government and the Indian embassy to guide us. We are not locals of Dubai so we don’t know what documents are needed.”

Officials and lawyers said the case was complicated because the accident occurred in Dubai but the bus company and driver were Omani.

Of the 17 passengers who died in the accident, 12 were Indian.

Mr Vipul, the Indian Consul General in Dubai, said consular officers would check with the UAE foreign office to find out which procedures need to be followed.

He said they were also trying to find a lawyer to represent the survivors and families for free.

“It is not a straightforward case but we will be following up,” Mr Vipul said.

“We can be the facilitators to help the families. There will be lawyers within the community who will be willing to take this case pro bono.”

Mwasalat, the government-owned public transport company that operated the bus to Dubai from Muscat, said information about compensation would be released once the investigation was completed.

Abdul Jabar Qahraman was meeting supporters in his campaign office in the southern Afghan province of Helmand when a bomb hidden under a sofa exploded on Wednesday.

The blast in the provincial capital Lashkar Gah killed the Afghan election candidate and at least another three people, Interior Minister Wais Ahmad Barmak told reporters. Another three were wounded, while three suspects were detained, he said.

The Taliban – which controls much of Helmand and has vowed to disrupt the October 20 parliamentary elections – claimed responsibility for the attack.

Mr Qahraman was at least the 10th candidate killed so far during the campaign season, and the second from Lashkar Gah this month. Another candidate, Saleh Mohammad Asikzai, was among eight people killed in a suicide attack last week. Most of the slain candidates were murdered in targeted assassinations, including Avtar Singh Khalsa, the first Afghan Sikh to run for the lower house of the parliament.

The same week the Taliban warned candidates to withdraw from the elections. On Wednesday the group issued fresh warnings, calling on educational workers to stop schools from being used as polling centres.

EA Sports FC 26

Publisher: EA Sports

Consoles: PC, PlayStation 4/5, Xbox Series X/S

Rating: 3/5

Our family matters legal consultant

Name: Dr Hassan Mohsen Elhais

Position: legal consultant with Al Rowaad Advocates and Legal Consultants.

Match info

Liverpool 3
Hoedt (10' og), Matip (21'), Salah (45 3')

Southampton 0

BRIEF SCORES:

Toss: Nepal, chose to field

UAE 153-6: Shaiman (59), Usman (30); Regmi 2-23

Nepal 132-7: Jora 53 not out; Zahoor 2-17

Result: UAE won by 21 runs

Series: UAE lead 1-0

How to apply for a drone permit
  • Individuals must register on UAE Drone app or website using their UAE Pass
  • Add all their personal details, including name, nationality, passport number, Emiratis ID, email and phone number
  • Upload the training certificate from a centre accredited by the GCAA
  • Submit their request
What are the regulations?
  • Fly it within visual line of sight
  • Never over populated areas
  • Ensure maximum flying height of 400 feet (122 metres) above ground level is not crossed
  • Users must avoid flying over restricted areas listed on the UAE Drone app
  • Only fly the drone during the day, and never at night
  • Should have a live feed of the drone flight
  • Drones must weigh 5 kg or less
Sarfira

Director: Sudha Kongara Prasad

Starring: Akshay Kumar, Radhika Madan, Paresh Rawal 

Rating: 2/5

Can NRIs vote in the election?

Indians residing overseas cannot cast their ballot abroad

Non-resident Indians or NRIs can vote only by going to a polling booth in their home constituency

There are about 3.1 million NRIs living overseas

Indians have urged political parties to extend the right to vote to citizens residing overseas

A committee of the Election Commission of India approved of proxy voting for non-resident Indians

Proxy voting means that a person can authorise someone residing in the same polling booth area to cast a vote on his behalf.

This option is currently available for the armed forces, police and government officials posted outside India

A bill was passed in the lower house of India’s parliament or the Lok Sabha to extend proxy voting to non-resident Indians

However, this did not come before the upper house or Rajya Sabha and has lapsed

The issue of NRI voting draws a huge amount of interest in India and overseas

Over the past few months, Indians have received messages on mobile phones and on social media claiming that NRIs can cast their votes online

The Election Commission of India then clarified that NRIs could not vote online

The Election Commission lodged a complaint with the Delhi Police asking it to clamp down on the people spreading misinformation

Benefits of first-time home buyers' scheme
  • Priority access to new homes from participating developers
  • Discounts on sales price of off-plan units
  • Flexible payment plans from developers
  • Mortgages with better interest rates, faster approval times and reduced fees
  • DLD registration fee can be paid through banks or credit cards at zero interest rates
'The Last Days of Ptolemy Grey'

Rating: 3/5

Directors: Ramin Bahrani, Debbie Allen, Hanelle Culpepper, Guillermo Navarro

Writers: Walter Mosley

Stars: Samuel L Jackson, Dominique Fishback, Walton Goggins