Wealthy expat couple's divorce should be heard in Abu Dhabi court, British judge rules

Senior legal figure says the new non-Sharia civil court would be best placed to handle the case

• 

  Officials open the Family Court at Abu Dhabi Judicial Department in 2021. Photo: ADJD

• 

  British couple Craig Lindsay and Sarah Goodman marry in a civil ceremony in February 2022. Victor Besa / The National

• 

  Itamar Bareket, from Tel Aviv, places the ring on to his wife-to-be Nogah's finger at the civil court in Abu Dhabi. Khushnum Bhandari / The National

• 

  The couple chose Abu Dhabi because civil marriages are not allowed in Israel. Khushnum Bhandari / The National

• 

  The court also handles divorces and other family matters such as inheritance. Victor Besa / The National

• 

  The process involves paperwork and a ceremony with an official. Victor Besa / The National

• 

  At least dozens of couples have been married at Abu Dhabi Judicial Department and many more plan to do so. Victor Besa / The National

A British judge has said an expatriate couple seeking a divorce should have their case heard in Abu Dhabi and not London, in what is thought to be the first judgment of its kind.

Judge Edward Hess rejected a petition by the woman's lawyer to have the separation of assets decided in the UK's Central Family Court.

Instead, he told lawyers in the case that they would be better served by the Abu Dhabi Civil Family Court, in the country where they have lived for 14 years.

He refused an argument by the woman's lawyer, Gerald Wilson, that the new Abu Dhabi court remains “embryonic” and that any decision by the court would be “determined according to Sharia norms”, arguing that it had only one Emirati judge.

It's the first international recognition of the non-Muslim family court of Abu Dhabi

Byron James,
Expatriate Law, UAE office

According to court documents, Mr Hess said he disagreed with that assessment.

"It seems to me that the new court has been set up with a view to giving assurance to non-Muslims living in the UAE that, if they do become divorced, they will be dealt with in a way which is commensurate with norms of non-Muslim countries," he added.

“I have no reason not to assume that any judge of the new court, whatever his faith, would deal with any case according to the statutory principles which have been summarised above.”

Local courts across the Emirates use a civil and criminal law that is based on Sharia. Among its rulings on divorce is one that says the man and woman keep both of their own assets.

The decision was made at the Central Family Court in September but has only just come to light.

The woman, aged 42 — who was not named in court documents, nor was her husband, aged 47 — issued divorce proceedings in the UK last year.

_______________________________

First Israeli civil marriage in Abu Dhabi court: in pictures

• 

  Nogah and Itamar Bareket, the first Israeli couple to have a civil marriage in Abu Dhabi. All photos: Khushnum Bhandari / The National

• 

  Officials say that five secular Israeli couples, who are not permitted to have non-religious weddings in Israel, have registered to be married in the Emirati capital.

• 

  Nogah's ring. The couple plan to move to the Emirates in the near future.

• 

  An Emirati court official smiles as the process is complete.

• 

  More than 3,000 couples have married in Abu Dhabi's judicial court in the past year.

_______________________________

This was challenged by the husband, a solicitor for a UAE-based firm who said that divorce proceedings should continue in the Emirates, where they have lived since 2008.

He asked for the case to be deferred to the family court at the Abu Dhabi Judicial Department instead of the UK.

The establishment of the new Abu Dhabi court meant that for the first time, divorce proceedings would not be tried under Sharia.

According to documents, the couple are very wealthy, with the husband earning £850,000 (Dh3.8 million) a year, as a partner in a UAE-based law firm.

The couple have assets worth £4.5 million.

Documents state the wife looks after their children and has personal assets worth only £15,305.

Byron James, a partner at Expatriate Law's UAE office, said the case was a significant moment for the capital's new non-Muslim court system.

“This is the first time that the English family court has come to consider whether or not the Abu Dhabi non-Muslim family court should be considered 'forum conveniens' over the English courts," he told The National.

Forumconveniens is where one court takes precedence over another.

"The judge had to decide whether proceedings should take place in England or in Abu Dhabi, and decided that it should proceed in the Abu Dhabi non-Muslim family courts," he said.

"His reasoning was that the Abu Dhabi government has gone to the trouble of putting together a law for expats and whilst it's very new, and whilst there's lots that one could say about unknowns of how the discretionary aspects of the law might be applied, his view was that the new law should be given a chance to prove itself.

"That's really important because it's the first international recognition, as far as I'm aware, and endorsement of the non-Muslim family court of Abu Dhabi.

"And to have a country like England, saying, we will defer to this other country, for our own citizens to get divorced in is a real mark of respect.

"It's an incredible validation for a court that just opened."

It also means that people do not need to fight over jurisdiction as much as they used to, he said.

"It means that whether it proceeds in the non-Muslim courts of the UAE or whether it proceeds in their home country, they are going to have an outcome that feels more culturally appropriate."