David de Gea 5, Edinson Cavani 8; Dominic Calvert-Lewin 8, Robin Olsen 5 - Manchester United v Everton ratings

United squander two-goal lead as Everton claim a point at Old Trafford

• 

  MANCHESTER UNITED RATINGS: David de Gea 5. Quiet first half bar Richarlison benefitting from a Lindelof mix up. The second half is when it all went wrong. Should have done better for Doucoure’s goal after a weak parry. Could do little about second but quickly lashed a ball over his full-backs near the end rather than trying to help see game out. Could he have come out more for Everton’s third? Getty Images

• 

  Aaron Wan-Bissaka 7. Played Calvert-Lewin onside early on but had a fruitful first half where he found much space to get forward and cross. Passed to Fernandes to score his wonder goal. Hesitation cost him possession in second and the whole defence could have done better on all three goals. Reuters

• 

  Victor Lindelof 6. Early charge forward and keen to carry the ball into the Everton half as United dominated against a team who’d won their previous four away games – though didn’t create too many chances. Made a mess on the turn to allow Richarlison – who he’d previously dominated - a shot after 41 minutes and struggled with pace of Everton’s forwards in a woeful start to second half. EPA

• 

  Harry Maguire 6. Fine against Calvert-Lewin in first half but then weak on Everton’s first goal and found wanting on Everton’s second as his defence failed to clear their lines and gave James Rodriguez space to shoot. Fell to ground and lost possession late on as United hearts went in mouths. PA Images

• 

  Luke Shaw 7. Fine on Calvert-Lewin and, like Wan-Bissaka, could get forward because of Everton’s narrow diamond formation. Brilliant combination with Cavani after 46 minutes before he shot on target. Set up McTominay’s goal. Booked. EPA

• 

  Scott McTominay 7. Strong tackles to break up spirited Everton start. Pushed forward and scored – again at Old Trafford – with a header which looked to be United’s winner … until heartbreak seconds from time. AFP

• 

  Paul Pogba 6. January’s player of the month at the club and started after being rested midweek but went off after 39 minutes injured and clutching his thigh. Unfortunate. AP

• 

  Mason Greenwood 8. Super ball from deep to Shaw in an early attack which went nowhere but exposed Everton’s lack of width. Crossed well and United’s liveliest player in the first half, passing short and long with both feet, crossing and taking players on. AP

• 

  Bruno Fernandes 7. Floored by early Davies tackle and barely touched the ball in the first 25 minutes as Everton’s formation choked him. More involved after the opening goal, then he produced the moment of the match, ignoring a Fred pass, then receiving the ball back from Wan-Bissaka and nonchalantly shooting into the roof of the goal. Spectacular. PA Images

• 

  Marcus Rashford 6. Perfect cross with beautiful technique for Cavani’s opener. Confident going forward and combined well with well balanced attack around him. Had two chances to get the fourth. Needs to be more clinical. Getty Images

• 

  Edinson Cavani 8. Scored in both wins v Everton this season and took 24 minutes to do the same, pausing to time his movement and waiting to head in Rashford’s cross. Intelligent in movement and with simple passes. Shame he wasn’t at the end of some of the chances created. AP

• 

  SUB: Fred 6. On for injured Pogba after 41minutes to resume partnership with McTominay. Weak shot wide almost immediately. Poor over hit cross ended a fine 63rd minute attack. Needed to provide more cover. Getty Images

• 

  SUB: Axel Tuanzebe NA. On for Greenwood in 92nd minute to win a minute in time added on. Booked and gave a foul away which led to late equaliser. It could not have gone worse for the defender. Reuters

• 

  EVERTON RATINGS: Robin Olsen, 5 - A mixed evening for the Swede who thwarted Luke Shaw and Marcus Rashford with smart saves, but was beaten emphatically by Edinson Cavani’s powerful header and a Bruno Fernandes screamer, while the less said about United’s third the better. EPA

• 

  Mason Holgate, 5 - It’s never an easy job defending at Old Trafford and proved to be the case for Holgate who showed some early nerves with a sliced clearance that dropped kindly for Cavani, while Marcus Rashford always had his number on a tough night for full-back. AFP

• 

  Michael Keane, 6 - Started brightly with important interventions to keep Victor Lindelof and Cavani at bay. He was taken out of the game by Rashford’s superb delivery as United went in front, but his clipped ball into the box set up Dominic Calvert-Lewin to make it 3-3. EPA

• 

  Ben Godfrey, 5 - It took a brave header from the young defender to prevent Cavani’s chipped cross from reaching Fernandes, who caught him in the face for his troubles. Like his teammates he struggled to deal with the energy of Rashford and the menace of Cavani. AFP

• 

  Lucas Digne, 6 - Failed to stop Rashford’s cross for the opener and struggled with Mason Greenwood's pace in spells, but his teasing cross from the left was instrumental in the build-up to the equaliser, while he clattered the side of the post late on. Reuters

• 

  Abdoulaye Doucoure, 7 - Kept his side in the game at both ends, first smashing Paul Pogba’s perilous header away to safety with Scott McTominay lurking, before tapping into an empty net after David de Gea could only parry Calvert-Lewin’s strike. Reuters

• 

  Tom Davies, 5 - The 22-year-old became the latest man to rile Fernandes when he clattered into United’s talisman from behind. He started well, but ultimately couldn’t contain a fired up Fernandes who sold him the wrong way before unleashing a beautiful strike for 2-0. EPA

• 

  Andre Gomes, 6 - Like Davies, it was an impressive start from the Portugal international who snuffed out a string of passes intended for his compatriot Fernandes and Cavani in the early exchanges, but that task became increasingly more difficult. Reuters

• 

  James Rodriguez, 6 - Talk about a game of two halves! Once again guilty of fizzling into the background in a carless first half, he started the second superbly and produced a wonderful touch before hammering past De Gea into the bottom corner to level the game. AFP

• 

  Richarlison, 7 - The Brazilian always looked lively and was constantly a threat when Everton were able to switch the play to the left. Frustratingly his teammates didn’t look to pick him out enough, despite a series of bursting runs in the channel. EPA

• 

  Dominic Calvert-Lewin, 8 - You just can’t stop him! The forward dragged his side back into the game when his effort from a tight angle was fumbled straight to Abdoulaye Doucoure by De Gea, and he was on-hand again to stab home a dramatic equaliser for his 17th of the season. AFP

• 

  SUB: Gylfi Sigurdsson, 7 - Brought on to replace James Rodriguez just shy of the hour-mark as Carlo Ancelotti searched for an unlikely winner, only for his side to fall behind a couple of minutes later, although he asked a couple of questions with calculated set-pieces. Reuters

• 

  SUB: Alex Iwobi, NR - Replaced Tom Davies for the final quarter-of-an-hour, but he had little impact and failed to trouble Shaw. EPA

• 

  SUB: Josh King, NR - The former Red Devil replaced Doucoure as the Toffees made one last attempt to unstick their opponents. He imposed himself well and drew the foul that led to a last-gasp leveller. EPA

Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer endured a sour ending to his 100th Premier League game in charge after slack defending again cost his team home points in a 3-3 draw with Everton on Saturday.

United's away league form has been outstanding this season but simple errors unbecoming of title contenders have led to four defeats at Old Trafford, most recently a 2-1 reverse to bottom team Sheffield United.

Manchester United took a 2-0 lead against the Toffees but amateurish defending allowed the visitors to wipe out the deficit and then snatch a draw with the last kick of the game from Dominic Calvert-Lewin after they had fallen behind again.

The result dented second-placed United's hopes of winning their first league title since 2013 as it left them two points behind leaders Manchester City who have two games in hand.

Solskjaer reacted with a touch of defiance as he praised his team's prolific scoring but could not ignore the disappointment of having to settle for a draw which tasted like defeat.

"We deserved to win the game but that is football for you, you have to take your chances and cannot concede with every shot," he told the BBC.

"First half I did not feel we played particularly well but scored two fantastic goals. You go in at the break 2-0 up feeling we have not hit where we could do.

"After 2-2 we played really well then the last kick of the ball kicks us in the teeth and we go home disappointed."