The Indian Union Home Minister P. Chidambaram.
The Indian Union Home Minister P. Chidambaram.

India piles up evidence over Mumbai attacks



MUMBAI // The Indian government yesterday handed over a seven-page dossier to Pakistan, its fourth since last year's Mumbai terrorist attack, stepping up pressure on its nuclear rival to act tough against the perpetrators of the attack, who it claims are Pakistani nationals. With the latest dossier, P Chidambaram, India's home minister, said the country had provided more evidence to Pakistan to prosecute Hafiz Saeed, the commander of the Lashkar-i-Taiba (LiT), who India accuses of masterminding the attack.

The new dossier comes just four days after a top Pakistani law official expressed his inability to prosecute Mr Saeed given a lack of evidence against him. "India wants us to prosecute him for his involvement in the Mumbai attacks but how could we do so without concrete evidence? Law demands evidence," Latif Khosa, the attorney general of Pakistan, said last week. With the latest information, India had filled "in the blanks", Mr Chidambaram said.

"There is enough evidence to continue the probe against Saeed," he added. After months of heightened tensions, India and Pakistan broke ground recently when both countries decided to restart the stalled peace talks. In the joint statement issued on July 17 by Manmohan Singh, India's prime minister, and his Pakistani counterpart, Yusuf Raza Gilani, both sides vowed to insulate the process from terrorism, a sticky issue which has often scuttled negotiations in the past.

Both sides have sat through four rounds of talks, achieving modest gains such as trade agreements and some confidence-building measures. The fifth round was underway when the Mumbai attacks happened. After enduring three wars, numerous skirmishes along the border, and decades of a cold war, observers celebrated this new friendliness as a means to peacefully negotiate all major outstanding disputes, including Kashmir.

But, fearful that Mr Singh had compromised India's stance on cross-border terrorism, hardline critics in India's opposition criticised the joint statement in the Indian parliament last week. "He [Mr Singh] has walked into the Pakistani camp," Yashwant Sinha, a member of parliament from the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janta Party, said in a parliament debate last week. There was also some unease about the inclusion of the issue of Baluchistan in the joint statement. Pakistan accuses India of causing trouble in Balochistan province by fanning the insurgency there. Hardline opposition members say that by agreeing to include it in the joint statement, India, which has long played a victim of terrorism, had tacitly admitted it was also a perpetrator.

"When there's war [between India and Pakistan], India wins. When there's dialogue, India loses," said Mulayam Singh, from the Samajwadi Party. Mr Singh denied those charges and said there was no dilution in India's stance on terrorism. He said the talks were still dependent on Pakistan's action against militant organisations. "Unless we want to go to war with Pakistan, dialogue is the only way out," Mr Singh said, but asserted that "we should do so on the basis of 'trust but verify'".

His statement was widely seen as an effort to downplay, possibly retract, the much-celebrated joint statement issued on July 17. "The [Indian government] has become extremely risk-averse after this fiasco," said Darsh Pant, a professor in the department of defence studies at London's King's College. "In trying to be too bold, [Mr Singh] has inadvertently made it difficult for him to take the relationship any further."

In some ways, de-linking terrorism from the talks would have been a practical way for both nuclear rivals to move forward, some observers say. It would also have given Pakistan the maneuvrability to take action against organisations such Jammat-ud-Dawa (JuD), believed to be a front organisation for the LiT, said Hamid Mir, the executive editor of the Pakistan-based Geo TV. Organisations such as JuD are popular in Pakistan, he said. It has the potential to ratchet public pressure and mobilise the masses if Pakistan were to clamp down on them.

"By de-linking the dialogue process from terrorism, no one can point fingers at the Pakistani government for acting against them under Indian pressure," he said. Brahma Chellaney, a professor of strategic studies at the New Delhi-based Centre for Policy Research, disagrees. Since the Mumbai terrorist attack, India has not exercised any outrage over Pakistan's ineptitude in reigning in militant organisations, he said, denouncing Mr Singh's speech in parliament.

"By greeting each major cross-border terror strike in recent years with complete inaction, Singh has speciously suggested to the nation that the only alternative to such abysmal pusillanimity is war," he said. The biggest concern for the opposition is the possibility of another terrorist strike on India as the talks with Pakistan resume. The fear is justified in some ways, but forgoing dialogue between the civilian governments of both countries does not rule out the possibility of further attacks, says Vinod Mehta, the editor of Outlook magazine, an Indian weekly.

"If India waits until Pakistan hangs the last terrorist on its soil, then it is being unrealistic," he said. achopra@thenational.ae

COMPANY PROFILE

Company name: Klipit

Started: 2022

Founders: Venkat Reddy, Mohammed Al Bulooki, Bilal Merchant, Asif Ahmed, Ovais Merchant

Based: Dubai, UAE

Industry: Digital receipts, finance, blockchain

Funding: $4 million

Investors: Privately/self-funded

LIVING IN...

This article is part of a guide on where to live in the UAE. Our reporters will profile some of the country’s most desirable districts, provide an estimate of rental prices and introduce you to some of the residents who call each area home.

MATCH INFO

Europa League semi-final, second leg
Atletico Madrid (1) v Arsenal (1)

Where: Wanda Metropolitano
When: Thursday, May 3
Live: On BeIN Sports HD

MATCH INFO

Uefa Champions League semi-final, first leg

Barcelona v Liverpool, Wednesday, 11pm (UAE).

Second leg

Liverpool v Barcelona, Tuesday, May 7, 11pm

Games on BeIN Sports

Mountain Classification Tour de France after Stage 8 on Saturday:

  • 1. Lilian Calmejane (France / Direct Energie) 11
  • 2. Fabio Aru (Italy / Astana) 10
  • 3. Daniel Martin (Ireland / Quick-Step) 8
  • 4. Robert Gesink (Netherlands / LottoNL) 8
  • 5. Warren Barguil (France / Sunweb) 7
  • 6. Chris Froome (Britain / Team Sky) 6
  • 7. Guillaume Martin (France / Wanty) 6
  • 8. Jan Bakelants (Belgium / AG2R) 5
  • 9. Serge Pauwels (Belgium / Dimension Data) 5
  • 10. Richie Porte (Australia / BMC Racing) 4
Where can I submit a sample?

Volunteers can now submit DNA samples at a number of centres across Abu Dhabi. The programme is open to all ages.

Collection centres in Abu Dhabi include:

  • Abu Dhabi National Exhibition Centre (ADNEC)
  • Biogenix Labs in Masdar City
  • Al Towayya in Al Ain
  • NMC Royal Hospital in Khalifa City
  • Bareen International Hospital
  • NMC Specialty Hospital, Al Ain
  • NMC Royal Medical Centre - Abu Dhabi
  • NMC Royal Women’s Hospital.
COMPANY PROFILE

Name: Haltia.ai
Started: 2023
Co-founders: Arto Bendiken and Talal Thabet
Based: Dubai, UAE
Industry: AI
Number of employees: 41
Funding: About $1.7 million
Investors: Self, family and friends

Herc's Adventures

Developer: Big Ape Productions
Publisher: LucasArts
Console: PlayStation 1 & 5, Sega Saturn
Rating: 4/5

The National Archives, Abu Dhabi

Founded over 50 years ago, the National Archives collects valuable historical material relating to the UAE, and is the oldest and richest archive relating to the Arabian Gulf.

Much of the material can be viewed on line at the Arabian Gulf Digital Archive - https://www.agda.ae/en

Company Profile

Company name: Cargoz
Date started: January 2022
Founders: Premlal Pullisserry and Lijo Antony
Based: Dubai
Number of staff: 30
Investment stage: Seed

Expo details

Expo 2020 Dubai will be the first World Expo to be held in the Middle East, Africa and South Asia

The world fair will run for six months from October 20, 2020 to April 10, 2021.

It is expected to attract 25 million visits

Some 70 per cent visitors are projected to come from outside the UAE, the largest proportion of international visitors in the 167-year history of World Expos.

More than 30,000 volunteers are required for Expo 2020

The site covers a total of 4.38 sqkm, including a 2 sqkm gated area

It is located adjacent to Al Maktoum International Airport in Dubai South

The burning issue

The internal combustion engine is facing a watershed moment – major manufacturer Volvo is to stop producing petroleum-powered vehicles by 2021 and countries in Europe, including the UK, have vowed to ban their sale before 2040. The National takes a look at the story of one of the most successful technologies of the last 100 years and how it has impacted life in the UAE.

Part three: an affection for classic cars lives on

Read part two: how climate change drove the race for an alternative 

Read part one: how cars came to the UAE

UAE medallists at Asian Games 2023

Gold
Magomedomar Magomedomarov – Judo – Men’s +100kg
Khaled Al Shehi – Jiu-jitsu – Men’s -62kg
Faisal Al Ketbi – Jiu-jitsu – Men’s -85kg
Asma Al Hosani – Jiu-jitsu – Women’s -52kg
Shamma Al Kalbani – Jiu-jitsu – Women’s -63kg
Silver
Omar Al Marzooqi – Equestrian – Individual showjumping
Bishrelt Khorloodoi – Judo – Women’s -52kg
Khalid Al Blooshi – Jiu-jitsu – Men’s -62kg
Mohamed Al Suwaidi – Jiu-jitsu – Men’s -69kg
Balqees Abdulla – Jiu-jitsu – Women’s -48kg
Bronze
Hawraa Alajmi – Karate – Women’s kumite -50kg
Ahmed Al Mansoori – Cycling – Men’s omnium
Abdullah Al Marri – Equestrian – Individual showjumping
Team UAE – Equestrian – Team showjumping
Dzhafar Kostoev – Judo – Men’s -100kg
Narmandakh Bayanmunkh – Judo – Men’s -66kg
Grigorian Aram – Judo – Men’s -90kg
Mahdi Al Awlaqi – Jiu-jitsu – Men’s -77kg
Saeed Al Kubaisi – Jiu-jitsu – Men’s -85kg
Shamsa Al Ameri – Jiu-jitsu – Women’s -57kg


The UAE Today

The latest news and analysis from the Emirates

      By signing up, I agree to The National's privacy policy
      The UAE Today