• Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskaer cuts a forlorn figure during the 6-1 thrashing at home to Spurs. Reuters
    Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskaer cuts a forlorn figure during the 6-1 thrashing at home to Spurs. Reuters
  • Son Heung-min celebrates scoring Tottenham's fourth goal. Reuters
    Son Heung-min celebrates scoring Tottenham's fourth goal. Reuters
  • Manchester United captain Harry Maguire. Getty
    Manchester United captain Harry Maguire. Getty
  • Spurs defender Davinson Sanchez fouls Anthony Martial and gives away a second-minute penalty at Old Trafford. Reuters
    Spurs defender Davinson Sanchez fouls Anthony Martial and gives away a second-minute penalty at Old Trafford. Reuters
  • Manchester United's Bruno Fernandes scores from the spot. PA
    Manchester United's Bruno Fernandes scores from the spot. PA
  • United's Bruno Fernandes celebrates his goal. AP
    United's Bruno Fernandes celebrates his goal. AP
  • Spurs' Harry Kane battles for possession with Paul Pogba of United. Reuters
    Spurs' Harry Kane battles for possession with Paul Pogba of United. Reuters
  • Referee Anthony Taylor shows a red card to United's Anthony Martial, third from right. AP
    Referee Anthony Taylor shows a red card to United's Anthony Martial, third from right. AP
  • United's Marcus Rashford is tackled by Serge Aurier of Spurs. PA
    United's Marcus Rashford is tackled by Serge Aurier of Spurs. PA
  • Tottenham's Son Heung-min, center, scores his side's second goal. AP
    Tottenham's Son Heung-min, center, scores his side's second goal. AP
  • Spurs striker Harry Kane celebrates scoring his team's third goal. AFP
    Spurs striker Harry Kane celebrates scoring his team's third goal. AFP
  • Spurs defender Serge Aurier makes it 5-1. AFP
    Spurs defender Serge Aurier makes it 5-1. AFP
  • Spurs manager Jose Mourinho, left, and his United counterpart Ole Gunnar Solskaer. Reuters
    Spurs manager Jose Mourinho, left, and his United counterpart Ole Gunnar Solskaer. Reuters
  • Serge Aurier celebrates scoring Spurs' fifth goal. AFP
    Serge Aurier celebrates scoring Spurs' fifth goal. AFP
  • Son Heung-min goes down after being fouled by United defender Eric Bailly. Getty
    Son Heung-min goes down after being fouled by United defender Eric Bailly. Getty
  • United's Paul Pogba after giving away the penalty that led to Spurs sixth goal. PA
    United's Paul Pogba after giving away the penalty that led to Spurs sixth goal. PA
  • Harry Kane makes it 6-1 to Spurs from the penalty spot. Reuters
    Harry Kane makes it 6-1 to Spurs from the penalty spot. Reuters
  • Harry Kane celebrates scoring Spurs' sixth goal. Reuters
    Harry Kane celebrates scoring Spurs' sixth goal. Reuters
  • United's Donny van de Beek under pressure from Moussa Sissoko, right, and Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg, left. Reuters
    United's Donny van de Beek under pressure from Moussa Sissoko, right, and Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg, left. Reuters

Muddled thinking and clouded strategy: Manchester United are just trying the same thing over and over again


  • English
  • Arabic

One manager in place for 26 years; five through a revolving door in the seven years since.

And the first hint of another change sooner rather than later.

Manchester United are no longer the benchmark of success in English football, they are a shambles, a mishmash of muddled thinking and clouded strategy.

Whether or not there is substance in the former Tottenham Hotspur manager Mauricio Pochettino being sounded out as a possible replacement for Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, it is an indication of how disorientated United have become.

Trying the same thing over and over, but expecting different results.

After Alex Ferguson’s inauspicious start at Old Trafford – and remember he had to fashion success from a supremely under-achieving organisation – talk of him being replaced had no place at the club or on the terraces. He was an institution running an institution, amassing 38 trophies.

David Moyes, Ryan Giggs, Louis van Gaal, Jose Mourinho and now Solskjaer have followed, and while there has been the occasional success none of them, in football parlance, has been fit to lace Ferguson’s boots.

Last weekend, a club which prides itself on being one of the biggest in world football, was humiliated in a 6-1 home Premier League defeat by Mourinho’s Tottenham.

While one result should never be the trigger to replace a manager, the fact it is even being discussed is a reflection of the turmoil inside Old Trafford. And once again the spotlight shines on who is to blame.

Executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward, sat watching alone in the stand, left the Tottenham defeat with plenty to contemplate.

It came the day before the transfer window shut and, despite their struggles, United’s headline new recruit was Edinson Cavani, a 33-year-old striker. For free.

Solskjaer was initially the injection of energy and optimism that United needed. He promised a return to the "United way", bringing through young players and committing to returning to the days of a whirlwind attacking force.

To get to the next level, the Norwegian first wanted to bring in striker Erling Haaland in January, one of Europe’s rising stars. Instead, Haaland joined Borussia Dortmund.

This window, Solskjaer wanted Jadon Sancho from Dortmund, a player with electric pace and thrilling potential. Negotiations, the realm of Woodward, broke down, and Sancho stayed put.

Manchester United's executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward watches from the Old Trafford stands as Tottenham cruise to victory. PA
Manchester United's executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward watches from the Old Trafford stands as Tottenham cruise to victory. PA

Since Woodward replaced David Gill in May 2013, he has overseen 15 transfer windows, with 37 major signings.

That he wields so much influence, yet sees the managers come and go, all of them shouldering the blame for another season of being outclassed by city, English and European rivals, should be a reflection of Woodward’s time at the helm, as much as the parted coaches.

United aren't the first club to struggle to get the players they want but after the glory years of Ferguson and Gill, when players would be honoured to get a call, rather than look the other way, it is a stark contrast.

Woodward leaves another transfer deadline behind, with the fans again asking questions of the vice chairman. And Solskjaer, more than likely, carrying the can.

EA Sports FC 26

Publisher: EA Sports

Consoles: PC, PlayStation 4/5, Xbox Series X/S

Rating: 3/5

How to help

Call the hotline on 0502955999 or send "thenational" to the following numbers:

2289 - Dh10

2252 - Dh50

6025 - Dh20

6027 - Dh100

6026 - Dh200