Regulators and industry bodies forge carbon trading framework at Cop28 summit

Singapore and Papua New Guinea sign implementation agreement on carbon credits co-operation

Guohua Power Station, a coal-fired power plant, in Dingzhou, China. Carbon credits have been discussed at Cop28. AP

While talks about fossil fuels and climate finance dominate the Cop28 climate change summit, regulators and industry bodies are setting out a framework for carbon credit trading.

Carbon credits, also known as carbon offsets, are permits that allow companies to emit a certain amount of carbon dioxide or other greenhouse gases. The proceeds from the sale of the credits are used to finance climate action projects that would not otherwise be feasible.

The discussions have been held as the industry faces criticism over lack of transparency and poor quality of projects, with some critics saying that carbon offsets give some sectors the licence to pollute.

“The project-based carbon markets have grown very quickly. They were [growing] between 30 per cent and 40 per cent a year for a handful of years until 2022,” Peter Mannion, partner at McKinsey's sustainability practice, told The National.

“We've seen a slight kind of pause in that growth and maybe even a slight decline over this year, and that's been driven by a number of concerns related to integrity in both the supply side … and the demand side."

The number of credits used by companies fell 6 per cent in the first half of the year, the first dip in at least seven years, BloombergNEF data shows.

An outcome of the Cop26 summit in Glasgow in 2021 was the establishment of Article 6, which regulates carbon markets under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change.

In theory, it allows the government or private companies in one country to pay for emissions reductions in another and receive the credit for their own Paris Agreement goals.

However, there is still no agreement among countries on the technical details for trading carbon credits.

“The goal there being that money might be able to flow from countries with a high cost to base to countries with lower cost, and also support some really important projects like … clean cooking, reforestation, or nature restoration,” Mr Mannion said.

• 

  Sara Omi is the first lawyer from the Embera people who live in Panamá. Photo: TINTA

• 

  Sara Omi with her communit,y the indigenous Embera People who live in Panama. Photo: Coordination of Territorial Women Leaders of the Mesoamerican Alliance of Peoples and Forests (CMLT -AMPB), Panama

• 

  The Embera people live in Panama's forests in round-shaped homes on wooden stilts with thatched roofs. Photo: TINTA

• 

  Sturdy wagara leaves are used in the traditional thatched roofs and wooden homes. Photo: TINTA

• 

  Protection of traditional ways of life is critical to their survival. Photo: TINTA

• 

  Sara Omi in her traditional dress with designs and body paint from the jagua fruit used by her community to decorate themselves before they go hunting or for spiritual ceremonies. Photo: TINTA

• 

  Women in traditional communties have fought to take on leadership positions to have a voice in village affairs. Photo: TINTA

• 

  Indigenous people say ancestral knowledge about preserving the forests, preventing erosion, protecting the soil that they have learnt can be shared to combat climate change. Photo: TINTA

• 

  Rising temperatures are among the reasons for the deforestation of rainforests in Brazil. Photo: Cristiane Juliao

Singapore and Papua New Guinea on Friday signed an implementation agreement on carbon credits co-operation, which sets out a legally binding framework and processes for the generation and international transfer of carbon credits.

High-integrity carbon markets can contribute to “much-needed” climate action globally, Grace Fu, Singapore’s Minister for Sustainability and the Environment, said in a statement.

“As an alternative energy disadvantaged country, effective international co-operation, such as through carbon markets, will also help us to achieve our climate ambitions,” Ms Fu said.

Singapore, the world's largest bunkering hub and a key business centre, aims to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050.

Last week, Bank of America, Morgan Stanley and Standard Chartered were among the companies that backed the US State Department’s Energy Transition Accelerator scheme.

Chile, the Dominican Republic, Nigeria and the Philippines have expressed interest in participating in the programme, which plans to create a framework for countries and power sectors. The scheme could mobilise “anywhere from $72 billion to $207 billion” in transition finance by 2035.

The voluntary carbon-offset market is expected to grow to $250 billion by 2050, from $2 billion in 2020, Morgan Stanley said.

Carbon markets have improved a lot in terms of transparency, but there is room for further improvement, a Cop28 participant from the International Union of Forest Research Organisations, told The National.

“Recent research suggests that … all of the efforts are lost on the way because of transparency issues, and because the resources are not fairly distributed, and sometimes, they don't even reach the communities or the [forest] stewards,” said Nelson Grima, deputy co-ordinator of science-policy programme at IUFRO.