Christie’s has said it plans to withdraw a Tyrannosaurus rex skeleton that was expected to fetch up to $25 million at an auction at the end of this month in Hong Kong.
The decision comes after questions were raised over the number of replica bones included in the skeleton, and how it was marketed, The New York Times reported. One lawyer questioned whether the specimen might include pieces created from a cast of the Natural History Museum Abu Dhabi's Stan.
Christie's spokesman Edward Lewine said the auction house thought the specimen would benefit from "further study".
In a statement released 10 days prior to the scheduled sale, Lewine said: “After consultation with the consignor of the Tyrannosaurus rex scheduled for sale on 30 November in Hong Kong, Christie’s has decided to withdraw the lot.
“The consignor has now decided to loan the specimen to a museum for public display.”
The T-rex, nicknamed Shen, was initially described as a "world-class specimen", of "museum standard", and the first skeleton of its species to come to auction in Asia — with "54 per cent represented by bone density".
However, in recent weeks, a lawyer from a US fossil company, the Black Hills Institute of Geological Research, contacted Christie's to point out similarities between Shen and Stan — another T-rex skeleton Christies sold for $31.8 million in 2020, and is now set to go on display at Natural History Museum Abu Dhabi.
Black Hills Institute still retains the intellectual property rights over Stan, which allows it to sell painted polyurethane casts of the skeleton, priced at $120,000 each. Black Hills president, Peter Larson, pointed out that there were similarities between the two dinosaur skulls, including holes in the lower jaw that were unique to Stan.
Almost all dinosaur skeletons are incomplete, and reconstructed using casts of other specimens' bones. While Stan has 190 original bones, Shen was believed to have about 79.
Larson told The New York Times that he thought the owner of Shen may have supplemented original bones using a cast of Stan.
“They’re using Stan to sell a dinosaur that’s not Stan,” Larson said. “It’s very misleading.”
Scroll through images of the Natural History Museum Abu Dhabi's growing collection below
-
An exhibition at Manarat Al Saadiyat is offering a glimpse into the collection of the coming Natural History Museum Abu Dhabi. All Photos: Victor Besa / The National -
The skull of an Arabian sand gazelle on display as part of an exhibition at Manarat Al Saadiyat, showcasing the collection of the museum, due to be completed at the end of 2025. -
The exhibition space opens up and you are suddenly facing the bone-crushing, flesh-tearing teeth of Stan, the world's most famous T-Rex. -
Stan also has one of the best-preserved T-Rex skulls ever found. -
Dr Mark Jonathan Beech, Head of Archaeology: Al Dhafra & Abu Dhabi, in the Historic Environment Department at the Department of Culture and Tourism - Abu Dhabi (DCT). -
Stan's skull is too heavy to fix to the rest of the upright fossil, so it has been displayed separated, with a replica head mounted to the model for display. -
The seven-billion-year-old Murchison Meteorite. -
The four-tusked stegotetrabelodon elephant roamed Abu Dhabi seven million years ago. -
The Stegotetrabelodon elephant femur. -
Stan was discovered in South Dakota in 1987 by amateur palaeontologist Stan Sacrison, after whom the fossil was named, and who saw the dinosaur's pelvis on the side of a cliff when he was inspecting plants. -
Abu Dhabi has an estimated 3,000 dugongs, the second-highest population in the world after Australia. -
Stegotetrabelodon skull. -
A rendering of the new Natural History Museum in Abu Dhabi. Photo: Department of Culture and Tourism - Abu Dhabi -
A rendering of the new Natural History Museum in Abu Dhabi. Photo: Department of Culture and Tourism - Abu Dhabi -
A rendering of the new Natural History Museum in Abu Dhabi. Photo: Department of Culture and Tourism - Abu Dhabi
