UK Athletics faces manslaughter inquiry over death of Emirati Paralympian

Abdullah Hayayei died in 2017 when a throwing cage collapsed during practice for world championships

The British organisers of the 2017 World Para Athletics Championships in London are under investigation for corporate manslaughter over the death of the UAE discus thrower Abdullah Hayayei, The National can reveal.

Hayayei, 36, died in July 2017 when he was struck on the head by a metal pole when a throwing cage collapsed during a practice session at a newly prepared training ground in east London. He died 20 minutes after the incident despite the best efforts of spectators to lift the cage while paramedics treated him.

The investigation is the latest blow to the crisis-hit British governing body UK Athletics, which has suffered a series of controversies over its finances, safeguarding and its links to a notorious coach suspended for doping offences.

It can be revealed today that in May, police told UK Athletics and two connected bodies set up to deliver the games that they were being investigated for manslaughter and other potential health and safety offences.

If charged and found guilty of corporate manslaughter, the organisations could face an unlimited fine under a law that came into force in 2008, experts say.

 

The law was introduced amid frustrations that corporations had not been held to account for major tragedies, including rail and maritime accidents, because of the high burden of proof required.

UK Athletics said: “UKA have co-operated with all agencies since the incident in 2017 and continue to do so, but have no further comment to make at this time.”

Six men were questioned from 2017 to 2018 by police on suspicion of manslaughter by "gross negligence" over Hayayei's death, The National revealed in January last year.

Only two of those men – a man in his sixties and one in his seventies – remain under investigation, police said. Their roles have not been disclosed by the investigation but are likely to have focused on the cage and whether it was put up properly.

The family of Mr Hayayei, a father of five, said they were unaware of the developments. A family spokesperson said: “We have not heard any updates on the proceedings of the case. We have no comment for the time being.”

His elder sister, Mariam, had previously said the family were determined to get answers.

“Not one of us has managed to forget what happened to Abdullah and we never will do,” she said. “His death affected us all and the people who were responsible for his death should receive the maximum punishment.”

Hayayei had turned to sport after being injured in 2001 when a metal rod fell on his head during an army training accident.

He went on to compete in the 2015 World Championships in Qatar and the 2016 Paralympics in Brazil, and was set to compete in the shot-put, discus and javelin in London.

Instead, competitors held a moment of silence in his memory at the opening ceremony.

The incident was at Newham Leisure Centre, east London, which was taken over by the organisers of the championships three days earlier. All the equipment had been brought by the organisers. Wheelchair athletes are normally secured to a circle within the cage to allow them to throw safely.

FUJEIRAH, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES, 19 JUNE 2017. The funeral of Emirati Athlete Abdullah Hayayei in Qidfa that died from an accident in London while training. Abdullah's remains leave the Zaid Bin Khatieb Mosque on it's way to the burial site. (Photo: Antonie Robertson/The National) Journalist: Ruba Haza. Section: National.

The investigations into UK Athletics, London 2017 Ltd and London Championships Ltd mark a significant escalation in the investigation.

Corporate manslaughter is only investigated for the most serious corporate failings and requires a “gross breach” of the duty of care.

“An organisation is not liable if the failings were exclusively at a junior level. The failings of senior management must have formed a substantial element in the breach,” the prosecution guidelines say.

The companies, who were all registered at the UK Athletics’ Birmingham headquarters, have responded to written questions, according to police.

No directors face personal penalty if a company is found to have committed corporate manslaughter – a crime which has proved hard to prosecute.

Experts said about 25 prosecutions had taken place since the law was introduced in 2008 and mostly for small companies.

“Corporate manslaughter prosecutions are few and far between,” said Jonathan Grimes, a health and safety legal expert at London-based Kingsley Napley solicitors. “Although investigations are opened, only a small number of organisations are ultimately prosecuted for corporate manslaughter.

DOHA, QATAR - OCTOBER 31:  Abdullah Hayayei of UAE competes in the men's discus F34 final during the Evening Session on Day Ten of the IPC Athletics World Championships at Suhaim Bin Hamad Stadium on October 31, 2015 in Doha, Qatar.  (Photo by Warren Little/Getty Images)

“That’s partly because it’s difficult to prosecute because you have to demonstrate that it was the way in which an organisation was managed by its senior management that was a significant element in the breach that caused the death.

“That means you have to demonstrate a systemic failure that comes from the top, which can be hard, particularly in larger organisations.”

The chief executive, Joanna Coates, only took on the job in March after a series of scandals at the organisation.

It faced intense criticism over its links with Alberto Salazar, a coach who was banned for four years for doping offences.

British sports leadership also earlier this year announced a review of its strategy, leadership, governance, operation and culture because of major concerns about its operations and finances.

After taking over the top job, Ms Coates told Athletics Weekly: "I think people have lost their trust in athletics because of all the negative stories they've read over the last few years."

EDITOR'S PICKS
NEWSLETTERS