BP's chief executive search is Big Oil’s best chance to fix industry's gender problem

Only two women lead large international oil companies

Titans of the oil and gas world like Exxon Mobil, Chevron, Shell, and BP have successfully adapted to countless societal changes over the past century – war, nationalisations, even the climate movement.

But a major hurdle remains: Big oil has yet to appoint its first female chief executive – something BP could soon change.

This week, the 114-year old British oil company parted ways with its charismatic chief executive Bernard Looney after investigations found he failed to disclose several workplace relationships. What the board knew and when remains unclear.

BP’s interim leader, Murray Auchincloss, is also in a relationship with a BP employee, though the company says it was fully disclosed when he became chief financial officer.

Appointing a female chief executive would send a clear message that the clubby era of petro-masculinity could finally be coming to an end.

But doing so will require bucking more than a century of precedent: Only two women – Vicki Hollub at Occidental Petroleum and Meg O’Neill at Woodside Energy Group – currently lead large international oil companies.

“It’s a very tough culture,” Jane Stevenson, global leader for chief executive succession at executive search company Korn Ferry, said.

“In some companies, not all, everything is set up for male norms – and it makes it difficult.”

In the US, women represent just 13 per cent of the oil and gas C-suite, the lowest of any professional industry, according to McKinsey & Co.

Worldwide, women occupy just 22 per cent of jobs in oil and gas, making it the third-most gender unbalanced industry, according to a 2021 study by Boston Consulting Group and the World Petroleum Council.

Despite the industry’s embrace of diversity and inclusion policies, that percentage was unchanged from four years earlier.

To explain the disparity, industry executives often point to the dearth of women studying science, technology, engineering and maths.

But this only accounts for part of the problem: While women earned only 22 per cent of degrees in engineering in 2018, they earned 53 per cent of STEM degrees, according to Pew Research.

In the BCG study, the top two career obstacles women cited were not being told of job opportunities and unfair performance evaluations.

A review of the resources industry by the Australian government supported that study: It depicted an industry dominated by a macho culture, one where employees promotions are based on personal recommendations rather than merit.

“I’m tired of hearing, where are the women?” Katie Mehnert, chief executive of Ally Energy, a Houston-based human capital management company, said.

“There’s not a lack of women. There’s a lack of visibility and opportunities for them to progress.”

Women who ascend the ranks in oil and gas tend to do so in finance, legal and human resources roles.

Exxon and Shell currently have female chief financial officers and Chevron will appoint one within the next six months.

But in oil and gas, chief financial officers and general counsel rarely claim the top job. For chief executives, the industry tends to anoint candidates from the technical ranks.

And women occupy only about 10 per cent of technical and operational roles at any level of seniority, according to BCG.

When women do become managers in non-technical roles, they often do not make it to the C-suite.

Quote

There’s not a lack of women. There’s a lack of visibility and opportunities for them to progress

Katie Mehnert, chief executive, Ally Energy

In a 2021 study, the International Energy Agency found a “particularly acute” disparity between women in lower and senior management, with just 5 per cent occupying top posts in the industry.

“All of this suggests that a further glass ceiling exists beyond the glass ceiling to enter senior management in general,” the IEA said.

BCG also found the number of women in business roles dropped 50 per cent between midcareer positions and the higher ranks. And those women don’t tend to drop out of work – they join other industries.

“The reason for the decline may be that skills developed in these areas are more readily transferable to jobs outside the oil and gas industry,” said the BCG authors.

If their employers do not create an inclusive environment, women will leave, the report said.

In Australia, a 2022 government probe into discrimination into the resources industry found that almost half of Chevron's employees in the country reported being bullied.

Last year, a separate Bloomberg investigation found that Exxon suffered substantial attrition during the pandemic due, in part, to a fear-laced culture that rewarded employees who looked and sounded like their managers. Exxon said this characterisation is false.

Fortunately for BP, the company is more gender-balanced than most of its industry peers.

Women make up 39 per cent of employees and 30 per cent of senior leaders, both higher than before the pandemic.

This browser does not support the video element.

By 2030, BP aims to have women to fill at least half of its roughly 400 leadership roles and 40 per cent of the positions at every other level, according to a company representative.

In the wake of Mr Looney’s departure, six of BP’s 11 top-ranked executives are women.

Anja-Isabel Dotzenrath, executive vice president of gas of low carbon energy, and Carol Howle, executive vice president of trading, lead the internal list of chief executive candidates.

Both would represent a departure from BP’s culture of promoting engineers with extensive experience in operational roles in its oil and gas assets.

Appointing a woman to the top job “would send a message that this sector appreciates diversity of thought, background and gender, which are essential in taking on the energy challenges of the future”, Mr Mehnert said.

“BP has an opportunity to be the first.”

Updated: September 17, 2023, 5:00 AM