Surviving hostage relates mistreatment at trial of ISIS 'Beatle'

Italian aid worker spent 14 months in captivity and experienced brutality at the hands of ISIS members

El Shafee Elsheikh, one of two alleged Islamic State militants known as the 'Beatles' facing trial on U.S. criminal charges for their alleged involvement in beheadings of American hostages in Syria, is shown on a screen during a virtual hearing in U.S. District Court in Alexandria, Virginia, U.S., October 7, 2020 in this courtroom sketch. Bill Hennessy via REUTERS   ATTENTION EDITORS - THIS IMAGE HAS BEEN SUPPLIED BY A THIRD PARTY. NO RESALES. NO ARCHIVES
Powered by automated translation

Federico Motka’s abductors greeted him in English after he and his colleagues were kidnapped near a refugee camp on the Turkish border, telling him: “Welcome to Syria, you mutt.”

For the Italian aid worker, it was the beginning of 14 months of brutality at the hands of ISIS.

Mr Motka gave evidence about the ordeal on Thursday at the terrorism trial of El Shafee Elsheikh, a British citizen charged with taking a leading role in an ISIS kidnapping scheme that took more than 20 westerners hostage between 2012 and 2015.

Four Americans — journalists James Foley and Steven Sotloff and aid workers Peter Kassig and Kayla Mueller — were among them. Foley, Sotloff and Kassig were decapitated.

Mueller was forced into slavery and raped repeatedly by ISIS leader Abu Bakr Al Baghdadi before she, too, was killed.

Mr Motka is the first surviving hostage to give evidence at Mr Elsheikh’s trial in Alexandria, Virginia.

Born in Trieste, Italy, Mr Motka said he spent much of his childhood in the Middle East and went to boarding school in England.

He was an aid worker surveying the needs of refugee camps in March 2013 when he and a colleague, Briton David Haines, were captured and taken hostage.

Mr Motka said that for the first month of captivity, he was only occasionally mistreated, but that mistreatment frequently came at the hands of three captors whom hostages called “the Beatles” because of their British accents.

They learnt to speak surreptitiously about their captors, who wore masks and took pains to conceal their identities, since they never knew what would set them off. A dispute over bathroom hygiene prompted a particularly intense beating, he said.

The British accents and phraseology are an important part of the case, though, as prosecutors seek to prove that Mr Elsheikh is indeed one of the Beatles who tortured hostages, even though the Beatles took great pains to conceal their faces.

Mr Motka gave evidence that there were at least three Britons in the group of captors and the hostages nicknamed them “John”, “George” and “Ringo”.

Prosecutors have said in court that Mr Elsheikh is the one who was nicknamed Ringo.

One way Mr Motka distinguished the three was their preferences for inflicting punishment.

“George was more into boxing,” Mr Motka said. “John, he kicked a lot. Ringo used to talk how he liked wrestling. He would put people in headlocks.”

He described one instance when Ringo put James Foley in a headlock so tight that he passed out.

Mr Motka also recounted a time in the summer of 2013 when the hostages were held in a facility they nicknamed “the box".

The Beatles excitedly put Mr Motka and his cellmate David Haines in a room with Foley and British hostage John Cantlie for what they called a “Royal Rumble".

“They were super excited about it,” Mr Motka said of the Beatles about the tag-team style fight they imposed on the foursome. “We were so weak and shattered we could barely lift our arms.”

The group was told that the losers would be waterboarded. Two of the four passed out during the hour-long battle, Mr Motka said. The Beatles deemed him the loser but never waterboarded him, inflicting a beating instead.

As they were transferred to different facilities, Mr Motka said the hostages were sometimes separated from the Beatles for weeks at a time. Those periods were welcome, relatively speaking, because the Beatles were unique in their cruelty, he said.

When they were transferred again to a place they nicknamed “the dungeon” and saw that the Beatles were there, “we crapped our pants”, Mr Motka said.

“We had just started to relax a little” as the mistreatment had eased in their absence.

“The box”, where the Beatles were a regular presence, was one of the worst stretches of captivity.

Mr Motka said he and other hostages there endured a lengthy “regime of punishment” that included regular beatings and forced stress positions.

“George”, another man called Abu Mohamed and a third nicknamed “the punisher” regularly tortured them, Mr Motka said.

“They played lots of games with us,” Mr Motka said, maintaining composure as he clearly struggled with the emotions of describing his captivity.

“They gave us dog names. We needed to come and immediately respond” to the dog name to avoid a beating.

Mr Motka was not released until May 25, 2014. His 14 months in captivity were the longest of any hostage in the group.

Defence lawyers, though, have highlighted the difficulties that hostages have in formally identifying each of their captors, who routinely wore masks that covered all but their eyes.

In opening statements, prosecutors referenced only three British citizens — Mr Elsheikh, his long-time friend Alexenda Kotey and Mohammed Emwazi, who frequently carried out the role of executioner and was known as “Jihadi John”.

Emwazi was killed in a drone strike and Kotey was captured alongside Mr Elsheikh and also brought to Virginia to face trial. Kotey pleaded guilty last year in a plea bargain that calls for a life sentence.

Jurors also heard evidence on Thursday from Danish hostage negotiator Jens Serup, who spoke on prolonged efforts to secure the release of Daniel Rye Ottosen in exchange for €2 million ($2.2m).

The jury saw photos of huge bruises on Mr Ottosen’s arm and back after he was finally released.

Mr Serup said that the captors told Mr Ottosen the beating was a “farewell present not to forget them".

Updated: March 31, 2022, 9:49 PM