Scientists say easing UK Covid restrictions at Christmas 'throws fuel on the fire'

Five-day social distancing amnesty could lead to 25 days of tough measures

Scientists have warned against relaxing coronavirus restrictions in the UK over Christmas. AFP

British scientists said relaxing coronavirus restrictions over Christmas "throws fuel on the fire” at a time when infections are high.

The warning comes as ministers consider giving families five days of freedom over the festive period.

The move would allow families to come together – bypassing a ban on people from several households meeting indoors.

But health officials said that a single day of freedom could cost five days of restrictions, raising the possibility of 25 days of tough measures in January.

Dr Susan Hopkins, a medical adviser to the government on its Covid-19 response, said she was “very keen” for the UK to have a near-normal Christmas but said that it would come at a price.

She said: “We need to be very careful about the number of contacts we have to reduce transmission before Christmas and get our cases as low as possible.”

Prof Andrew Haywood, who is on the government’s Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies, said widespread mixing at Christmas posed “substantial risks” at the wrong time.

He told BBC's Radio 4 Today programme: "We're putting far too much emphasis on having a near-normal Christmas.

“We know respiratory infections peak in January, so throwing fuel on the fire at Christmas can only contribute to this.”

He said: “We’re on the cusp of being able to protect those elderly people who we love through vaccination and it would be tragic to throw that opportunity away and waste the gains we’ve made during lockdown.”

'Highly inconsistent message'

Prof Haywood also said the government’s communication strategies lacked consistency.

“When policy is undulating between stay at home to save lives, eat out to help out, the tier system, the second lockdown and now a proposal for an amnesty on social distancing, it’s a highly inconsistent message,” he said.

Another top scientist, Prof Gabriel Scally from Bristol University, said there was “no point” in having a near-normal Christmas only to have to “bury friends and relations in January and February”.

People walk past Christmas trees in Covent Garden in central London. AFP

He tweeted: “We have not made nine months of sacrifices to throw it all away at Christmas.”

England is scheduled to emerge from its second coronavirus lockdown on December 2 and is expected to re-enter tier-based restrictions.

Much of the country is expected to fall into Tier 3 – or very high alert – which prevents people meeting indoors.

Defence Secretary Ben Wallace said a decision would be made as close as possible to December 2 but said that he did not want to be “the Grinch who stole Christmas”.

He told ITV's Good Morning Britain: "I would love all of us to be able to have a Christmas, but more than anything I want us to get through this Covid and try and get this country back to normal and I want to protect lives."

Meanwhile, Prof Andrew Pollard, of the Oxford Vaccine Group, said the world was “still at the bottom of the mountain” in the struggle to return to normal life.

His comments came after The Lancet medical journal published encouraging results from the Oxford trial that showed their vaccine triggered a strong immune response in adults in their 60s and 70s.

“Now we’ve got to get the data about the vaccine in front of regulators for them to scrutinise it and approve the first vaccines,” Prof Pollard said.

“Then we’ve got that huge effort to climb up to the top where we’ve got the vast majority of those at risk vaccinated and protected so the most vulnerable are no longer at risk and we can start to get back to normal.”

A pedestrian wearing a protective mask walks past a mural in San Francisco, California. Bloomberg

Shelves in the toilet paper aisle at a Walgreens store sit empty in Buffalo Grove, Illinois. AP Photo

A man wearing a face mask leaves a dog park in the Arts District amid the coronavirus pandemic in Los Angeles, California. AFP

This aerial view shows people waiting in line in their cars at a Covid-19 testing site at Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles. AFP

Vehicles wait to cross the US-Mexico border and enter Ciudad Juarez, amid surging Covid-19 cases in the Mexican border city and the US border city of El Paso, Texas. AFP

A nurse at Stormont Vail Health System pushes a hospital bed through hallways in Topeka, Kansas. AP

A doctor visits Covid-19 patients to check their state of health and evaluate their release from the hotel at the Living Place Hotel on November 18, 2020 in Bologna, Italy. Getty Images

A worker delivers meals to Covid-19 patients who are housed in the Living Place Hotel in Bologna, Italy. Getty Images

A young woman with a crucifix cries as police use a water cannon to disperse protesters demonstrating against the coronavirus lockdown measures imposed by the German government, close to the Reichstag building in Berlin. AFP

A woman, wearing a face mask to prevent the spread of the coronavirus, walks along the European quarter in Brussels. AP Photo

A medical worker takes a blood sample in the Krylatskoye Ice Palace in Moscow, Russia. AP Photo

A Swiss army soldier, right, wearing personal protective equipment helps hospital's physiotherapists to treat a Covid-19 patient in the intermediate care units of Geneva University Hospital. AP

Four youngster riding on one scooter roll down a popular street, in Ankara, Turkey. Turkey is re-introducing a series of restrictions, including partial weekend lockdowns. AP Photo

A man holding a cross and a Bible preaches about Christianity backdropped by the Royal Exchange, back centre, and the Bank of England, at left, during England's second coronavirus lockdown in the City of London. AP Photo

A Christmas tree stands on display in the middle of Leadenhall Market, City of London. AP Photo

Medical workers and patients are seen in the treatment hall of a temporary hospital in Moscow, Russia. AP Photo

People paddle on the shores of the Atlantic ocean in Saint Jean de Luz, south-west France. France's health minister says the country is 'progressively getting back in control' of its resurgent epidemic. AP Photo

Health workers takes care of a patient in Sao Paulo, Brazil. AFP

A man in protective suit stands next to a mobile testing kiosk outside the Ernakulam district administration headquarters in Kochi, Kerala, India. AP Photo

A health official collects a swab sample from a man to test for the coronavirus at a village on the outskirts of Bengaluru in south India. AFP

Pedestrians wearing protective masks wait to cross a road in Shinbashi in Tokyo, Japan. Bloomberg

Workers wearing face masks pour ice on the clams at a section selling imported seafoods at a supermarket in Beijing. AP Photo

A group of remand prisoners stage a protest on the roof of the Welikada Remand Prison complex in Colombo, Sri Lanka. EPA