How one flight from the Middle East to Ireland led to 59 Covid cases

Study reveals how 13 passengers passed virus on to dozens more

A general view of Dublin airport's new Terminal 2 in Dublin, Ireland, on November 19, 2010. AFP PHOTO/Peter Muhly (Photo by PETER MUHLY / AFP)
Powered by automated translation

A single flight from the Middle East to Ireland was responsible for 59 coronavirus cases, a study has found.

Researchers from scientific journal Eurosurveillance, which published the study, said the findings demonstrate how the virus is seeded in countries through air travel.

The Irish outbreak was traced back to one 7.5-hour flight that took off from the Middle East this summer.

The flight ran at 17 per cent capacity, with only 49 of the 283 seats occupied.

Researchers said 13 passengers tested positive for the coronavirus, with two passengers developing symptoms within two days of the flight.

A further 46 people, who were not on the flight, caught the disease after coming into contact with the passengers or their relatives, the study said.

Within 10 days, only people who were not on the flight – but were linked to a passenger – contracted the virus.

The infected passengers had travelled in small groups with varying waiting times at the airport.

One group spent up to 12 hours in a transit lounge while on stopover, while another two groups waited only two hours, in the departure area.

The passengers who caught the virus were aged between 1 and 65.

Where the infected passengers were sitting on the plane. Numbers on the seats indicate flight groups 1 to 4. Eurosurveillance
Where the infected passengers were sitting on the plane. Numbers on the seats indicate flight groups 1 to 4. Eurosurveillance

A mask was worn during the flight by nine of the positive cases, not worn by one – a child – and unknown for three, the researchers said.

One of the passengers involved passed the virus to three members of their household, one of whom passed it on to 25 others while staying in “shared accommodation”.

The researchers said the original source case was unknown.

They said the study shows the potential for the virus to be transmitted in a plane and “imported” to countries.

The chains of coronavirus transmission from infected plane passengers to the wider community. Numbers indicate flight groups 1 to 4, HH = household. Eurosurveillance
The chains of coronavirus transmission from infected plane passengers to the wider community. Numbers indicate flight groups 1 to 4, HH = household. Eurosurveillance
An epicurve showing when passengers and their close contacts contracted coronavirus. Eurosurveillience 
An epicurve showing when passengers and their close contacts contracted coronavirus. Eurosurveillience 

“Air travel has accelerated the global pandemic, contributing to the spread of coronavirus disease throughout the world,” they wrote

Earlier this month, the International Air Transport Association said catching the coronavirus on a plane carried the equivalent risk of "getting struck by lightning".

The industry seized on a US defence department study that found masks greatly minimised exposure to the virus on a plane.

WHO official slams coronavirus contact tracing

WHO official slams coronavirus contact tracing

That study found an average of 0.003 per cent of air particles around a passenger’s head were found to be infectious when a mask is worn.

An Australian study published on October 2 found passengers in window seats in the middle of economy class had the greatest risk of contracting the virus.