British Muslims 'might have something to teach the rest of us' in curbing coronavirus

Covid-19 spread limited in some districts where UK Muslims make up large part of population

Lights from a residential tower block in Tower Hamlets as seen on April 03, 2020 in London, England. People have been forced to stay at home due to social distancing measures that have been put in place to slow the spread of the coronavirus, Covid-19 pandemicShow less

An investigation into the prevalence of coronavirus among minority groups in the UK has revealed relatively fewer cases in areas where Muslim communities make up a high proportion of the population.

Lower levels of Covid-19 in certain parts of Britain were called “striking” in a report by research group Webber Phillips.

Its analysis of the progress of the disease sought to establish socio-economic explanations for variations in the data for the pandemic so far.

The authors suggested that low figures in places such Tower Hamlets in London and Blackburn in Lancashire could be linked to population make-up and daily practices in some communities.

It suggested that ablutions before prayers may have helped to curbed the spread of the disease in some places.

"If one key to stopping transmission of the virus is hand washing, might a faith community, many of whose members ritually wash before five times a day prayers, have something to teach the rest of us?" the group's director, Trevor Phillips, wrote in The Times.

Mr Phillips has faced accusations of making inflammatory statements against Muslims.

He has denied the criticism, claiming to highlight issues that should concern society as a whole.

The controversies have been magnified by Mr Phillips's former role as head of Britain’s watchdog on community relations, the Equality and Human Rights Commission.

In March he was suspended from the Labour Party for comments about the outlook for Britain’s Muslim community.

The Webber Phillips investigation found that 13 of 17 Covid-19 hotspots in England and Wales had non-white populations above the national average.

The British government has launched an official review into the heavy toll the virus has taken on people from black, Asian and minority backgrounds.

As a percentage of the population, the communities represent 13 per cent of England and Wales but 44 per cent of health service staff.

Of the 81 medical staff who have died, 50 are from minority backgrounds.

Larger rates are also reported in the wider death figures.

Local authorities such Brent and Harrow in London, both with above 50 per cent non-white populations, appeared in the top four of local reporting districts.

A man wearing a protective mask walks past a mural depicting a nurse in Shoreditch, amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak, in London, Britain. REUTERS

A woman observes two robots that carry home orders, in Medellin, Colombia,. EPA

A man is tested for coronavirus disease (COVID-19) at a Los Angeles fire department testing station for the homeless on Skid Row, in Los Angeles, California, U.S. REUTERS

A man sits next to a fountain at the Sun Yat Sen Memorial Park in Hong Kong on April 21, 2020. Hong Kong has reduced growth of confirmed COVID-19 cases to single digits in recent days, but city authorities say they are not taking any risks. Chief executive Carrie Lam said social distancing measures and some business restrictions would continue for another two weeks until at least May 7. AFP

A health worker shows quick tests for COVID-19 with negative results at a drive-through in the parking lot of the Mane Garrincha Stadium in Brasilia, Brazil. The Brazilian government started a mass testing program to improve control of the new coronavirus disease and plan how social isolation will be lifted. AFP

A teacher cleans and disinfects chairs and tables at the the Phoenix Gymnasium secondary school in Dortmund, western Germany. Students preparing for the Abitur high school graduation with exams taking place in May are allowed to turn back to school from April 23, 2020. AFP

People stand on designated spots to maintain social distancing at a market in Manila. AFP

Members of the Myanmar Red Cross carry a dead body of a driver from a boat in Sittwe, Rakhine State killed while delivering test kits for COVID-19 coronavirus. A Myanmar government health worker was injured and his driver killed when their United Nations-marked vehicle was ambushed as they were carrying COVID-19 test samples in conflict-ridden Rakhine state. AFP

Customers wearing face masks as a precautionary measure against the COVID-19 coronavirus sit in a cafe, which has masking tape on every other table to enforce social distancing, in Hong Kong. AFP

A woman wearing a protective face mask rides a scooter across a nearly empty 3rd Avenue in midtown Manhattan during the outbreak of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in New York City, New York, U.S. REUTERS

An employee wearing a face mask sits next to a GE Carescape R860 ventilator in an assembly and testing area at a GE Healthcare manufacturing facility during the global coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak in Madison, Wisconsin, U.S. REUTERS

Workers wearing protective equipment are seen on the grounds of the Central Jamia Mosque Ghamkol Sharif, a temporary morgue set up at a Mosque as the spread of the Coronavirus disease (Covid-19) continues, Birmingham, Britain. REUTERS

But bucking the trend among areas with large minority groups were predominantly Muslim local authorities.

“Most striking is the absence from this list of virtually all the English local authorities where the dominant minority group is Pakistani or Bangladeshi Muslim: Tower Hamlets, Luton, Slough, Redbridge, Waltham Forest and Blackburn,” the report said.

It gave as an example Tower Hamlets, the area with the highest proportion of Pakistani or Bangladeshi Muslims in the country.

It had significantly lower Covid-19 cases than neighbouring Southwark, which has a large African population.

The Webber Phillips report said that the sharp difference between Muslim and other minority groups meant vulnerability is “far more likely to be environmental or behavioural”.

The report admits that for more concrete conclusions to be reached, more research is needed.

Mr Phillips also said other behavioural practices among Pakistani and Bangladeshi communities might have led to the lower rates of infection.

Jabeer Butt of the Race Equality Foundation has called for a government inquiry into the impact of the coronavirus.

"We published an analysis shortly after the start of the lockdown, which noted that while the majority of [minority] communities were comparatively younger, the impact of discrimination [higher rates of poverty, overcrowding and less access to health care] increased the risk of the impact of Covid-19," Mr Butt said in a letter published on Wednesday.