EU energy chiefs delay decision on gas price cap

Energy ministers hope to agree on the price level for triggering the cap next week

France's Energy Minister Agnes Pannier-Runacher speaks with the media before a meeting of EU energy ministers in Brussels. AP
Powered by automated translation

EU energy ministers meeting in Brussels on Tuesday failed to strike a final deal on a bloc-wide cap on natural gas prices, after months of debate over whether the measure would ease Europe's energy crisis.

Following repeated requests from some countries, the European Commission proposed a gas price cap last month to manage the economic upheaval caused by Russia cutting natural gas deliveries to Europe, which has led to energy price spikes.

Tuesday's meeting did not yield a final decision, as some countries were still split over the details of the cap — leaving EU energy ministers to try again for an agreement at another meeting on December 19.

“We have made progress, but we are not done yet. Not all questions could be answered today,” German Economy Minister Robert Habeck said after the meeting, which overran by hours as ministers hunted for a compromise.

Czech Industry Minister Jozef Sikela, who led the meeting, said he had “a good feeling” that countries could next week agree on the price level for triggering the cap, which he said was the only issue still unresolved.

“I think we are almost there, but now we need to get together and show that unity is not an empty word,” he told a news conference.

He added that countries had agreed on other details, including that the cap would not initially apply to private gas trades outside energy exchanges.

Paris Christmas lights to be switched off early to save energy — in pictures

Germany, Austria and the Netherlands have warned against a gas price cap, which they fear could divert much-needed gas cargoes away from Europe and disrupt the functioning of energy markets.

Other states, including Greece, Belgium, Italy and Poland, have demanded a cap, which they say would shield their economies from high energy prices.

“European citizens are in agony, European businesses are closing and Europe has been needlessly debating,” Greek Energy Minister Konstantinos Skrekas said on Tuesday before the meeting.

The Czech Republic — which holds the EU's rotating presidency — drafted a new compromise proposal on Tuesday that would trigger the cap if prices exceed €200 ($213) per megawatt hour over three days on the front-month contract in the Dutch Title Transfer Facility gas hub.

The contract price would also need to be €35 higher than a reference price based on existing liquefied natural gas (LNG) price assessments for three days.

The latest proposal is lower than the €275/MWh price cap proposed by the European Commission, but some pro-cap countries said it was still too high.

Green energy sources — in pictures

“Having a trigger with a high value will not calm the markets,” Maltese Energy Minister Miriam Dalli said.

The pro- and anti-cap camps could each have enough votes to block a deal.

France could prove decisive in the final negotiations.

It initially backed a price cap, but last week expressed concern over its possible impact on financial markets, three diplomats said.

EU Energy Commissioner Kadri Simson said some energy ministers had asked for more time to discuss the proposal with their finance ministers, without naming specific countries.

Last week, the European Central Bank warned that the proposed EU price cap could jeopardise financial stability.

The EU has already agreed on emergency energy measures this year, including gas storage requirements. But other policies are being held up by the price cap rift.

Countries on Tuesday opted to again delay the approval of measures including faster permits for renewable energy projects without a deal on the gas price cap first.

Updated: December 14, 2022, 12:09 AM