US State Department staffer who resigned over Gaza says colleagues urged her to speak out


Jihan Abdalla
  • English
  • Arabic

Live updates: Follow the latest on Israel-Gaza

Annelle Sheline initially planned to resign "quietly” from her job as a US foreign affairs officer in protest against Washington's unconditional support for Israel and the war in Gaza.

But after several of her colleagues – who also disapprove of President Joe Biden's handling of the conflict – urged her to speak up, she decided to resign publicly last week in an op-ed carried by CNN.

“Trying to promote human rights in the Middle East had just become so difficult as a result of US policy and US support for what Israel is doing in Gaza,” Ms Sheline told the National.

“I wasn't really able to do my job any more, the job I'd been hired to do. And on the other hand, I didn't want to be associated with this government any more."

Ms Sheline's resignation is the latest example of dissent among government employees over the Biden administration's refusal to put conditions on military aid to Israel, or use its significant influence to bring about a permanent ceasefire in Gaza and allow more aid into the besieged enclave.

Josh Paul, a State Department official involved in handling arms transfers, resigned in October, saying he could no longer back continued military assistance to Israel.

He earlier told The National that he was “in awe” of Ms Sheline's courage.

Ms Sheline, 38, began working for the State Department a year ago in the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labour, where her focus was North Africa.

'Trying to promote human rights in the Middle East had just become so difficult as a result of US policy,' said Annelle Sheline. Ahmed Issawy / The National
'Trying to promote human rights in the Middle East had just become so difficult as a result of US policy,' said Annelle Sheline. Ahmed Issawy / The National

Growing up in North Carolina, Ms Sheline became interested in the Middle East after the 9/11 attacks. She studied Arabic at university and moved briefly to Egypt. She then went on to obtain a doctorate and worked in academia for several years.

The work of her office at the State Department, she said, was directly affected by US support for Israel, because key partners refused to work with Washington owing to its arms policies regarding Israel.

“Members of civil society didn't want to be in touch with the US government, or it would just be extremely dangerous for them to be in touch with the US government,” she said.

About 33,000 Palestinians have been killed in the enclave since the start of the war, according to Gaza's health authorities.

War leaves Gazans hopeless during Ramadan - video

Amid Israel's refusal to ease the entry of humanitarian aid into the enclave, the UN says famine is imminent. At least 30 people, most of them children, have died of starvation in recent weeks, according to health authorities in the enclave.

On Tuesday, an Israeli air strike on Deir Al Balah killed seven aid workers, forcing the non-profit World Central Kitchen and at least one other organisation supplying critical food assistance to pause their operations in Gaza.

The staggering death toll and the worsening humanitarian crisis have caused intense anger around the world, including in the State Department.

Since the start of the conflict, dozens of staff members from various US agencies have signed dissent cables, written letters and planned walkouts in protest.

Feds United for Peace, a group that represents federal workers from 30 US government agencies and departments, has demanded a permanent ceasefire in Gaza.

“There were certainly many people inside the State Department who are so distraught by what's happening,” Ms Sheline said.

Many of her former colleagues have worked on accountability measures that could be introduced, should the Biden administration decide to change course, she added.

“The hypocrisy of ongoing US support for Israel against the civilian population of Gaza, really, has just been very difficult for people who want to believe in what the US says it's supposed to stand for,” she said.

Gaza protests in Washington - in pictures

  • Pro-Palestinian demonstrators take part in a protest against the continuing war in Gaza outside Union Station in Washington on February 1. EPA
    Pro-Palestinian demonstrators take part in a protest against the continuing war in Gaza outside Union Station in Washington on February 1. EPA
  • Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been killed since the militant group Hamas launched an unprecedented attack on Israel from the Gaza Strip on October 7. EPA
    Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been killed since the militant group Hamas launched an unprecedented attack on Israel from the Gaza Strip on October 7. EPA
  • Israeli has responded with a military onslaught in the Palestinian enclave. EPA
    Israeli has responded with a military onslaught in the Palestinian enclave. EPA
  • The rally in the US capital drew protesters from far and wide. EPA
    The rally in the US capital drew protesters from far and wide. EPA
  • Meanwhile, US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin has said Joe Biden's administration must do more to address the issue of the besieged Palestinian people. EPA
    Meanwhile, US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin has said Joe Biden's administration must do more to address the issue of the besieged Palestinian people. EPA
  • Mr Austin said in regular talks with Israel he has stressed the need to protect civilian lives and provide humanitarian aid to the Palestinians. EPA
    Mr Austin said in regular talks with Israel he has stressed the need to protect civilian lives and provide humanitarian aid to the Palestinians. EPA
  • Demonstrators block a junction near the US Capitol as President Joe Biden attends the National Prayer Breakfast. Getty Images
    Demonstrators block a junction near the US Capitol as President Joe Biden attends the National Prayer Breakfast. Getty Images
  • Protesters in Washington call for a ceasefire in Gaza. Reuters
    Protesters in Washington call for a ceasefire in Gaza. Reuters
  • Pro-Palestine demonstrators shut down interstate ramps on the street on Capitol Hill, Washington. Reuters
    Pro-Palestine demonstrators shut down interstate ramps on the street on Capitol Hill, Washington. Reuters
  • Gaza protests in Washington. The National
    Gaza protests in Washington. The National
  • A person participates in the protest in Washington. The National
    A person participates in the protest in Washington. The National
  • Metropolitan Police Department officers as members of the anti-Zionist Jews group Neturei Karta join pro-Palestinians people blocking a street close to the US Capitol in Washington DC. AFP
    Metropolitan Police Department officers as members of the anti-Zionist Jews group Neturei Karta join pro-Palestinians people blocking a street close to the US Capitol in Washington DC. AFP
  • Members of the anti-Zionist Jews group Neturei Karta join pro-Palestinians people blocking a street close to the US Capitol in Washington. AFP
    Members of the anti-Zionist Jews group Neturei Karta join pro-Palestinians people blocking a street close to the US Capitol in Washington. AFP

She added that many of her former colleagues were considering resigning but felt they could not due to personal, professional or financial reasons.

Spokesman Matthew Miller said State Department respected diverging opinions and that Secretary of State Antony Blinken has instructed his team to make sure that people had an opportunity to make their views known.

"There is a broad diversity of views inside the State Department about our policy with respect to Gaza, just as there is a broad diversity within the State Department about our policy in a number of important foreign policy issues, as there is a broad diversity of views and opinions throughout American society about this issue and others,” Mr Miller said at a news briefing last week.

Washington gives $3.8 billion a year in military assistance to Israel, its closest ally in the Middle East.

Mr Biden, a staunch supporter of Israel, twice bypassed Congress to facilitate additional arms sales to Israel. In February, the Senate passed a major supplemental package deal that includes $14 billion in additional aid.

In recent days, US media have reported that the Biden administration is pressing Congress to approve the transfer of $18 billion worth of F-15 fighter jets to Israel.

Ms Sheline said she wanted the US to follow its own legal provisions, known as Leahy Laws, that bar Washington from providing military assistance to foreign security forces if they are violating human rights.

This would mean "cutting off military assistance to Israel," she said.

Ms Sheline added that she has been encouraged by the many forms of protests in the US over its Gaza policy, which have included efforts by Arab and Muslim Americans in Michigan to get more than 100,000 voters to cast “uncommitted” ballots in the Democratic primary elections in February.

Activists in other states, including Minnesota, Illinois and Wisconsin, were later able to convince tens of thousands of voters to join the movement.

“I do think there's a shift happening,” Ms Sheline said. “I worry, it may be too little too late, given the numbers of people being killed, the fact that those numbers are likely to just keep going up, the levels of starvation and the likely impending invasion of Rafah.

“I hope that by my going public, I have contributed to some of this public pressure. But I don't think it's enough.”

Latest from the Israel-Gaza war - in pictures

  • Displaced Palestinians hold a white flag as they pass an Israeli tank position while fleeing the Hamad Town district of Khan Younis. Bloomberg
    Displaced Palestinians hold a white flag as they pass an Israeli tank position while fleeing the Hamad Town district of Khan Younis. Bloomberg
  • A Palestinian woman cuts material to be used for sewing nappies at a workshop in Rafah. AFP
    A Palestinian woman cuts material to be used for sewing nappies at a workshop in Rafah. AFP
  • Smoke rises following an explosion in Gaza, as seen from southern Israel. AP
    Smoke rises following an explosion in Gaza, as seen from southern Israel. AP
  • Parachutes carrying relief for Palestinians drop from an Egyptian Air Force cargo plane over central Gaza. Bloomberg
    Parachutes carrying relief for Palestinians drop from an Egyptian Air Force cargo plane over central Gaza. Bloomberg
  • A Palestinian boy who is suffering from malnutrition is treated at a healthcare centre amid widespread hunger. Reuters
    A Palestinian boy who is suffering from malnutrition is treated at a healthcare centre amid widespread hunger. Reuters
  • Palestinian children attend an English class in the library of the school housing displaced people in Rafah, the southern Gaza Strip. AFP
    Palestinian children attend an English class in the library of the school housing displaced people in Rafah, the southern Gaza Strip. AFP
  • An UNRWA-run school housing displaced Palestinians in Rafah. AFP
    An UNRWA-run school housing displaced Palestinians in Rafah. AFP
  • Palestinians search for bodies and survivors in the rubble of a residential building destroyed in an Israeli air strike in Rafah. AP
    Palestinians search for bodies and survivors in the rubble of a residential building destroyed in an Israeli air strike in Rafah. AP
  • A wounded Palestinian man who lost his wife and daughter walks past a neighbours' house destroyed by Israeli bombing in Rafah. AFP
    A wounded Palestinian man who lost his wife and daughter walks past a neighbours' house destroyed by Israeli bombing in Rafah. AFP
  • An injured man is rescued from the rubble after an Israeli air strike on the Rafah camp in Gaza. EPA
    An injured man is rescued from the rubble after an Israeli air strike on the Rafah camp in Gaza. EPA
  • Palestinians walk amid the rubble of houses destroyed by the Israeli bombardment of Gaza city. AFP
    Palestinians walk amid the rubble of houses destroyed by the Israeli bombardment of Gaza city. AFP
  • Aid is dropped into Gaza from US military aircraft. Reuters
    Aid is dropped into Gaza from US military aircraft. Reuters
  • Palestinians gather at air lorries in Gaza. More than 100 were killed when Israeli troops opened fire. AP
    Palestinians gather at air lorries in Gaza. More than 100 were killed when Israeli troops opened fire. AP
  • The sun sets behind destroyed buildings in Gaza. AFP
    The sun sets behind destroyed buildings in Gaza. AFP
  • A Palestinian man enters a heavily damaged house following an Israeli strike in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip. AFP
    A Palestinian man enters a heavily damaged house following an Israeli strike in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip. AFP
  • A wounded Palestinian is assisted at the site of an Israeli strike in Deir Al Balah, in the central Gaza Strip. Reuters
    A wounded Palestinian is assisted at the site of an Israeli strike in Deir Al Balah, in the central Gaza Strip. Reuters
  • Palestinians gather in the hope of getting bags of flour carried by air lorries near an Israeli checkpoint in Gaza city, as the enclave's residents face crisis levels of hunger. Reuters
    Palestinians gather in the hope of getting bags of flour carried by air lorries near an Israeli checkpoint in Gaza city, as the enclave's residents face crisis levels of hunger. Reuters
  • Palestinian children wait to receive food cooked by a charity kitchen as the conflict between Israel and Hamas continues in Gaza. Reuters
    Palestinian children wait to receive food cooked by a charity kitchen as the conflict between Israel and Hamas continues in Gaza. Reuters
  • A displaced Palestinian child holds a crying baby in a camp in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip. Reuters
    A displaced Palestinian child holds a crying baby in a camp in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip. Reuters
Updated: April 04, 2024, 5:29 PM