Violence, bribery and delays at ports strangle Nigeria's economy

Country loses $19 billion annually, or about 5 per cent of gross domestic product, from bottlenecks, traffic jams, illegal charges and insecurity

EDITORS NOTE: Graphic content / People wait next to their cars on the Abuja - Nasarawa road due to clashes between Nigerian soldiers and members of Islamic Movement of Nigeria (IMN) during a demonstration of supporters of the movement, to protest against the imprisonment of a Shiite cleric, in Abuja, on October 29, 2018. The army and police confronted members of the Islamic Movement of Nigeria (IMN), the group's spokesman Ibrahim Musa told AFP, amid reports of casualties. Rights groups have accused Nigeria's military of killing more than 300 IMN supporters and burying them in mass graves during the 2015 confrontation, a charge the military strongly denies. / AFP / Sodiq ADELAKUN
Powered by automated translation

The lines of ageing blue, red and yellow trucks begin almost 10 kilometres from the gates of Nigeria’s main port of Apapa.

Valentine, a 34-year-old driver, has been queuing outside the Lagos site for two weeks. He’s had to deal with policemen demanding bribes and fend off hoodlums known as "area boys". “This is the worst I’ve seen it,” he said, changing tyres in a grimy orange T-shirt. “Every year, it gets worse.”

The congestion outside and inefficiency within Nigeria’s ports is choking the economy, which vies with South Africa as the continent’s biggest, and causes havoc for businesses that use them to import everything from cars to computers, food and machinery.

Nigeria loses $19 billion annually, or about 5 per cent of gross domestic product, from the delays, traffic, illegal charges and insecurity that are increasingly prevalent at its ports, the Lagos Chamber of Commerce & Industry (LCCI) said in a report this year.

In the World Bank’s Trading Across Borders survey, which measures the time and expense involved with importing and exporting goods, Nigeria ranks 182nd out of 190 countries, below Syria and Afghanistan.

The problems at Apapa and other ports such as Calabar and Port Harcourt have been a headache for successive administrations, which have failed to fix decaying infrastructure, reduce stifling red tape and tackle corruption. Terminal operators, including APM Terminals, a unit of Denmark’s AP Moller-Maersk, rely on generators because power cuts are so frequent.

But it’s worsened in recent years, especially at Apapa. Crumbling roads have all but ground trucks to a halt. Once they do manage to enter, drivers and businesses have to contend with a plethora of customs, immigration and security agents before they can pick up containers. It can take 20 days to clear products, compared with 48 hours in neighbouring Benin and Ghana, according to the LCCI.

In June exasperated truckers downed tools after the Nigerian Ports Authority decided to take over the control of traffic in and out of the port area from the Nigerian Navy.

One driver told local media: “They [NPA] just suddenly came and said that all trucks must first go to a shipping company’s loading bay from where they are to be called into the port. Unfortunately, this is contrary to the arrangement being implemented by the Nigerian Navy, which has worked very well and has eliminated the Apapa gridlock."

The cost of moving a container from Apapa to other parts of Lagos has soared to as much as 700,000 naira (Dh7,087) from about 150,000 naira two years ago as trucking firms put up their prices to make up for the delays, according to the Nigerian Shippers’ Council.

“We have to pay the area boys and the police also want money,” said David, a 40-year-old driver who’s been travelling to Apapa for almost 20 years. “We can pay 80,000 naira in bribes per trip. If you don’t, it can take weeks to get in. Sometimes they will beat you if you don’t give them money.”


Read more:

Nigerian oil company to be investigated over alleged $3.5bn subsidies purchase

Africa courts investors with reforms, but challenges remain


It’s taken a toll on the companies of Aliko Dangote, Africa’s richest man. Dangote Cement, Nigeria’s biggest listed firm, may cancel plans to build an export terminal at Apapa because of the congestion, chief executive Joe Makoju told investors last month. Dangote Sugar Refinery blamed a fall in third-quarter profit partly on the bottleneck there, which it said was leading to more smuggling of sugar through Nigeria’s land borders.

In this photo released by the Nigeria State House, Nigeria's President Muhammadu Buhari looks on during a broadcast to the Nation at the Presidential palace in Abuja, Nigeria, Monday, Aug. 21, 2017. Nigeria's President Muhammadu Buhari said his government will reinvigorate its campaign against the Islamic extremist insurgency in the country's northeast as he spoke to the nation for the first time Monday after returning from London where he spent more than three months for medical treatment. (Bayo Omoboriowo/Nigeria State House via AP)
Nigeria's President Muhammadu Buhari. AP

President Muhammadu Buhari, running for reelection in February, said in October the situation was “a major concern” and the government will urgently repair roads and build more railways to the ports. The 75-year-old leader says modernising infrastructure is vital to diversify the Opec member from oil and gas and revive an economy still struggling after the 2014 crash in crude prices.

Getting goods through Nigeria’s ports more smoothly and cheaply would also help to curb inflation, which has been above 10 per cent for almost three years.

Vice President Yemi Osinbajo visited Apapa in May 2017 and directed officials to start working around the clock and all agencies to locate their operations in one place to ease delays.

It’s been to little avail. Many people prefer to use more efficient ports in Benin, Ghana and Togo, according to Mike Onulide, who runs a business exporting food including noodles and garri, a cassava-based staple popular in West Africa.

“You don’t face the same kinds of frustration there that you do in Nigeria,” he said, recalling how a fellow businessman still hasn’t received compensation after one of his containers was dropped into the sea early this year.

“There’s been no improvement.”