Northern Ireland Protocol Bill 'threatens human rights protections'

Measures contained in the Belfast-Good Friday Agreement would be eroded by British government, says new study

Parliament Buildings at Stormont, Belfast, Northern Ireland, home to the Northern Ireland Assembly PA
Beta V.1.0 - Powered by automated translation

There is a “significant threat” to human rights if the proposed legislation to override parts of the Northern Ireland Protocol takes effect, a new report says.

The Northern Ireland Protocol Bill is making its way through the British Parliament as negotiations between UK and EU officials resumed last week.

The bill would allow the UK government to effectively tear up parts of the protocol and is set to be debated in the House of Lords in the coming weeks.

Prime Minister Liz Truss, who drafted the bill as foreign secretary in May, insisted it is “consistent with our obligations in international law and in support of our prior obligations in the Belfast-Good Friday Agreement”.

But this has been challenged in a joint report produced by academics at the Human Rights Centre in Queen’s University Belfast and the Donia Human Rights Centre at the University of Michigan.

They said that despite assurances from the government the legislation “empowers ministers to undermine hard-won human rights protections contained in the Belfast-Good Friday Agreement and protected in the Northern Ireland Protocol negotiated with the European Union”.

US President Biden warns UK not to damage Northern Ireland peace over Brexit - video

One of the authors of the report, Professor Christopher McCrudden of Queen’s University Belfast, urged the House of Lords to act.

“The House of Lords has the opportunity to fix this unacceptable and reckless unpicking of the protections that the EU and the UK agreed in the protocol to safeguard the human rights protections in the Northern Ireland peace agreement,” he said.

The Good Friday Agreement includes a section on rights, safeguards and equality of opportunity.

In the study, the academics have voiced concern that the UK’s exit from the EU would weaken these human rights and equality mechanisms in Northern Ireland.

Nancy Pelosi warns the UK to respect the Good Friday Agreement - video

The report also finds that the UK government is “acting contrary to international law” through the introduction of the bill, unless it can offer a justification for this breach.

The authors contend the attempt to ground such a justification in “necessity” fails, providing no justification.

“There are neither political nor legal justifications for these actions. In particular, the UK government’s claim of necessity has no legal basis in general and none in respect of Article 2 (of the European Convention on Human Rights),” the report concluded.

Updated: October 09, 2022, 11:07 PM