US reporters' families plea for mercy

The families of two US journalists, sentenced to 12 years in a labour prison, urge the North Korean government to grant them clemency.

South Koreans watch a news broadcast about two American journalists detained in North Korea at the Seoul Railway Station, in South Korea, on June 8 2009.
Powered by automated translation

SEOUL, SOUTH KOREA // The families of two American journalists, sentenced to 12 years in a North Korean labour prison, urged the North Korean hard-line government to grant them clemency, amid hopes the US government would send an envoy to negotiate their release. The sentencing of Laura Ling and Euna Lee yesterday is a new challenge for the US president Barack Obama who last week warned he would take a "very hard look" at tougher measures against North Korea for failing to end its nuclear programme and testing a second atomic device on May 25.

"We remain hopeful that the governments of the United States and North Korea can come to an agreement that will result in the release of the women", said a joint statement by their families. "We ask the government of North Korea to show compassion and grant Laura and Euna clemency and allow them to return home to their families." The statement expressed concern about the women's health, noting that Ms Ling, 32, has a serious medical condition, a reference to her ulcer, and that Ms Lee's four-year-old daughter is showing "signs of anguish over the absence of her mother."

Ms Lee, 36, and Ms Ling - who work for former vice president Al Gore's Current TV - were arrested on March 17 near the China-North Korea border where they were reporting about the trafficking of women. It is unclear whether they tried to sneak into the North or if aggressive border guards crossed into Chinese territory and grabbed them, as has happened before. The North accused the reporters of unspecified "hostile acts" and illegally entering the country, but the formal charges against them were unclear. Their trial, which was closed to foreigners, began last Thursday and they were sentenced yesterday to 12 years of "reform through labour."

Analysts doubt that Pyongyang is interested in having them sent to jail or one of its gulags, where poorly fed inmates often do back-breaking work in factories, coal mines and rice paddies. Rather, the sentence is a way for Pyongyang to maximise its leverage with Washington, said Roh Jeong-ho, the director of the Center for Korean Legal Studies at Columbia Law School. He said: "I don't think the reporters will do hard labour. It's simply not in the North Koreans' interests to make them go through that." He said the whole case appears to be a calculated move by Pyongyang to get Washington's attention.

By not accusing the women of espionage it has offered a "face-saving way of resolving the issue. "Essentially, it's a whole package of brinkmanship," he said. "They want to say to the Obama administration 'take us seriously and, in turn, we'll resolve this issue for you."' North Korea wants to be recognised as a legitimate nuclear state, but Washington has so far refused to endorse such a status for the unpredictable nation, which has a history of terrorism, ripping up agreements and sharing its nuclear know-how with nations hostile to America.

The UN is debating a new resolution to punish the North for its second nuclear test last month. Pyongyang followed the test with a barrage of missile launches, and is believed to be preparing another long-range missile test at a new launch pad. Asked yesterday if Washington will send an envoy to the North, the US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said the Obama administration is "pursuing every possible approach that we can consider in order to persuade the North Koreans to release them and send these young women home." She stressed that the reporters' case and Washington's efforts to punish North Korea for its recent nuclear test are "entirely separate matters." She did not elaborate but a senior Obama administration official said New Mexico Gov Bill Richardson and Mr Gore had been in contact with the White House and State Department about potential next steps, including possibly sending an envoy to try to negotiate the release of the two women. Mr Richardson, who helped win the release of Americans from North Korea in the 1990s, said he was "ready to do anything" the Obama administration asked.

* AP