After another US school shooting, 'Why?' is the wrong question to ask

Alanna De Leon writes the name of her friend, Annabelle Rodriguez, who died in the shooting. AFP

Pallbearers carry the coffin of Amerie Jo Garza into Sacred Heart Catholic Church. AP

Pallbearers carry the coffin of Amerie Jo Garza, who died in the mass shooting at Robb Elementary School. AFP

A memorial in Town Square, Uvalde, Texas, for victims of the Robb Elementary school shooting. Reuters

A woman places a rose on Layla Salazar’s memorial cross, who was one of the victims that died in the shooting. Reuters

Bags with brisket sandwiches and a snack that will be sold at a fundraiser for families of the victims. Reuters

Ashtyn Leigh, 18, hands a man a brisket meal. Reuters

A choir sings in front of the memorial. Reuters

People pray in front of memorial crosses. Reuters

Nineteen children and two adults were killed in the shooting. AFP

People visit a memorial for the victims. AFP

Flowers are left outside the school. AFP

Twenty-one empty chairs are seen outside of a daycare center as a memorial for the victims. AP Photo

Football teammates of Tess Mata, who died in the Texas school shooting, cry as they visit a makeshift memorial outside the Uvalde County Courthouse. AFP

A football teammate of shooting victim Tess Mata cries, supported by her mother. AFP

Texas police faced angry questions over why it took an hour to stop the gunman who murdered 19 children and two teachers in Uvalde, as video emerged of desperate parents begging officers to storm the school. AFP

Activists join Senate Democrats outside the Capitol, in Washington, to demand action on gun control legislation after the killings at the Texas elementary school this week. AP

The George R Brown Convention Centre, site of the National Rifle Association annual convention. Days after the deadliest mass school shooting in Texas history, the gun lobbyist group is meeting in Houston, from Friday until Sunday. Reuters

Pastor Carlos Contreras preaches to his congregation as photos of some of the children killed in the mass shooting at Robb Elementary flash on the screen at Primera Iglesia Bautista, in Uvalde. Reuters

People march after a vigil held to stand with the Uvalde families and demand an end to gun violence in Newtown, Connecticut. AP

A woman holds up a banner at the end of the vigil in Newtown, Connecticut. AP

Newtown was the scene of the 2012 attack at Sandy Hook Elementary School, when 20 pupils and six teachers were killed by a gunman. AP

Candles are lit for each victim as people pray at St Philip's Episcopal Church. EPA

A makeshift memorial in front of Robb Elementary School. AFP

Omahar Padillo with his son Omahar Jr, 12, during a community prayer, in Pharr, Texas, for the shooting victims at Robb Elementary School. AP

Omahar Padillo Jr, 12, and his sister Samantha, 9, with their mother, Silvia Padillo, write messages in support of the victims at Robb Elementary School. AP

A vigil for the victims of the mass shooting at Robb Elementary School. AFP

A young mourner at the vigil in Uvalde, Texas. AFP

Families at the vigil. AFP

A woman holds a photo of Nevaeh Bravo, who was killed in the mass shooting, during a vigil for the victims of the massacre in Uvalde, Texas. AFP

Uvalde County Sheriff Ruben Nolasco is comforted by Senator Ted Cruz during a vigil at the Uvalde County Fairplex Arena. AP

Diana Karau of Uvalde with a therapy dog named Tritan before a vigil to honour those killed at Robb Elementary. AP

Gun-control advocates Dana Cibulski, left, and Judi Giannini attend a vigil outside the National Rifle Association headquarters in Fairfax, Virginia after the mass shooting in Uvalde, Texas. AFP

Uziyah Garcia, 8, was among those killed in the shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas. AP

Pastor Jaime Cabralez, the uncle of shooting victim 10-year-old Eliahana Cruz Torres, is surrounded in prayer at his church in Uvalde, Texas on Wednesday. Reuters

A woman embraces a child outside Willie de Leon Civic Centre, in Uvalde, where pupils were taken after the school shooting. Bloomberg

Gun-control advocates hold a vigil outside the National Rifle Association (NRA) headquarters in Fairfax, Virginia. AFP

A woman and child leave the Civic Centre. Reuters

Why? Again. Another school massacre in the US by a gunman armed with an automatic weapon. This time in Uvalde, Texas – a pleasant, rural town midway between San Antonio, America’s fastest-growing city, and the border with Mexico. Uvalde’s prior claim to fame was as the birthplace of film star Matthew McConaughey.

These events have become so common that the response to them has become ritualised. Politicians say something must be done, but nothing ever gets done. News media analysts seek patterns, as if knowing what caused a shooting, what the environment was where it occurred might allow planning to prevent another one.

People all over the US ask: “Why?”

But those looking for a pattern to answer “Why?” are deluding themselves.

The only pattern is the shootings themselves. They keep happening. Uvalde, which by chance I’ve been to while reporting on the midterm election in 2018, is in an empty quarter of vast cattle ranches and small towns with businesses catering to agricultural needs.

The town is entirely different from where the first massacre in this era of school shootings took place. Nearly a quarter of a century ago, 15 people were killed at Columbine High School, which was in an affluent suburb of Denver, Colorado. Sandy Hook, Connecticut, is in the exurbs of New York. In 2012, 26 people were killed in the elementary school there. Twenty of them were six and seven-year-old children. In 2018, Parkland, Florida, a part of the endless development of communities in that state, north of Miami, neither suburban nor exurban, created because there is land, sunshine, and people who want to live there. Seventeen were killed.

And that’s just the double-digit death tolls in schools. Shooters walk into schools and college campuses and try to commit mayhem with such regularity that it barely makes the local news, but the list fills up a Wikipedia page.

And, of course, school shootings are just a subset of mass shootings in the US. Two weeks ago at a supermarket in Buffalo, New York, 10 African Americans were shot dead in a racist attack by a white supremacist. The attack mimicked a 2019 shooting at a WalMart store in El Paso, Texas, in which 23 people, including Mexican Americans, were killed by a white supremacist.

Last year according to FBI statistics, there were 61 “active shooter” attacks in which 103 people were killed.

The only pattern is the pattern. Americans own more guns – more than 300 million firearms are in private hands, nearly one for every man, woman and child in the country. And despite the fact that the US has more gun deaths than any other country in the world, after every incident of mass violence such as the Uvalde school massacre there is a spike in gun sales. One month after the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting, 2 million guns were sold.

What kind of guns? Any kind of guns, from military grade assault rifles to derringers.

It is not a surprise that some of these weapons, particularly assault weapons, find their way into the hands of troubled young men who use them. Broadcast news will be full of stories about the young man who committed the Uvalde atrocity. They will find out about his alienation, his difficulties at home, his being bullied at school, the hours he spent playing violent games on his computer. It is not news, really. No one would walk into an elementary school and open fire with an assault rifle who wasn’t in some way disturbed.

But still people will look for a pattern, a reason, an answer to “Why?”

The reason, the pattern, if there is one, lies in the hopeless divisions of American society. These divisions are exploited by politicians of one party, the Republicans, their donors who support the National Rifle Association – or the NRA – and their media supporters such as Fox News and on the fringe Alex Jones, who broadcasts conspiracy theories about Sandy Hook from his studio in Austin, Texas, a couple of hours drive from Uvalde.

People such as Jones regularly tell their large and credulous audience that school shootings are false flag operations staged by gun control advocates in the hope of creating a political climate for legislation to curb gun ownership. And the reason the government wants to curb your right to bear arms? Well, so they can impose their liberal agenda on you and you won’t be able to fight back.

If that seems crazy, it is. But American society has been more than a little crazy for a while now.

And on the sane side are the Republican politicians who know there are votes in playing on gun-owner fears that the government might take away their right to own military weapons.

Jones offered his endorsement to former president Donald Trump in 2016 and Mr Trump eagerly accepted. In 2015, Texas Governor Greg Abbott tweeted out his disappointment that his state was only number 2 in America for gun ownership. We should be number 1.

Everyone knows what needs to be done. Restrictions on the type of weapons that people can own. The standard for dealing with mass shootings was set in Britain. In the summer of 1987, a man went on a rampage in rural Hungerford, Berkshire, killing 16 people. Within a year, Parliament had passed a new law restricting the type of weapons and ammunition that could be in private hands. The more serious guns could be owned but had to be kept at gun clubs.

It didn’t stop the occasional incident, but after each one, including the Dunblane massacre at a primary school in Scotland in which 16 people were killed, the law is swiftly amended and restrictions on guns tightened.

That won’t happen in America. President Joe Biden vented his pain and frustration in remarks about Uvalde yesterday: “They have mental health problems, they have domestic disputes in other countries. They have people who are lost. But these kinds of mass shootings never happen with the kind of frequency that they happen in America. Why?”

Mr President, here is your answer: there are votes in exploiting divisions. Power comes from the barrel of the gun, or at least the vote of a gun-owner who is convinced he is going to lose the right to own a couple of M16 and AK47s for protection from his own government.

If you think my thesis is off: the NRA’s annual meeting is this weekend in Houston, Texas. Mr Trump is one of the keynote speakers. Listen closely to what is said, Mr President.