Egypt fears Israeli assault on Rafah will push Palestinians over the border

Israel's threatened offensive on overcrowded border city could leave more than a million Palestinians with nowhere to go

More than one million displaced Palestinians are living in makeshift camps in Rafah, only metres from the border fence with Egypt. Reuters

Displaced Palestinian children play with a non functioning electricity cable near the border fence between Gaza and Egypt, on February 16, 2024 in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip, amid the ongoing conflict between Israel and the Palestinian Hamas militant group. Nearly 1. 5 million displaced Palestinians are trapped in Rafah -- more than half of Gaza's populations -- seeking shelter in a sprawling makeshift encampment near the Egyptian border. (Photo by MOHAMMED ABED / AFP)

Conditions on the border are dire as Palestinians living in tents not only face starvation, but also lack fuel and electricity. Reuters

Egyptian authorities fear that an Israeli assault on the border city could force increasingly desperate Palestinians to seek safety by entering Egypt. AFP

More than half of Gaza's population of 2.3 million people is already pushed up against the border. AFP

Rafah is the main entry point for aid into Gaza, as the enclave's only border crossing that does not involve travel to or from Israel. Reuters

Large convoys of lorries carrying aid are frequently stuck at Rafah as a result of Israeli restrictions on how much aid can enter Gaza since the outbreak of the war in October. EPA

Egyptian authorities have ordered the construction of a logistics zone they say is to receive aid in Rafah. Reuters

A satellite image shows earth grading works along the Egypt-Gaza border near Rafah, February 10, 2024. Maxar Technologies/Handout via REUTERS THIS IMAGE HAS BEEN SUPPLIED BY A THIRD PARTY. NO RESALES. NO ARCHIVES. MANDATORY CREDIT. DO NOT OBSCURE LOGO.

Sources say authorities are constructing a walled area on the Egyptian side of the border to prepare for a potential influx of Palestinians. Reuters

A satellite image shows the construction of a new wall along the Egypt-Gaza border. Maxar Technologies via Reuters

Egyptian President Abdel Fattah El Sisi has repeatedly said that Egypt will not readily accept the displacement of Palestinians into Egypt. Reuters

Live updates: Follow the latest news on Israel-Gaza

If there's one thing that encapsulates Egypt's predicament over the fallout from the Gaza war, it is the fate of Rafah, the battered enclave's southernmost city on the Egyptian border.

Rafah looks set to be the next stop in Israel’s military campaign to eradicate Hamas, with pleas from Egypt, the US, the UN, and most of the international community not to launch a full-scale ground offensive in the city falling on deaf ears.

At stake are the lives of about half of Gaza's 2.3 million residents who have sought shelter in Rafah, a city cut in half by the border separating Egypt from the Gaza Strip.

The UN has bluntly warned that invading the city “could lead to a slaughter” that would add significantly to the more than 29,300 Palestinians killed in the war so far.

In a telephone call with French President Emmanuel Macron at the weekend, Egyptian President Abdel Fattah El Sisi warned of “disastrous humanitarian consequences” for the Palestinians in Rafah if Israel launches a ground offensive in the city.

In a wider context, the fallout from a possible attack in Rafah has the potential of destabilising Egypt, a nation of 105 million, jeopardising its milestone 1979 peace treaty with Israel and creating a formidable hurdle to any future peace negotiations to end the Palestinian-Israeli conflict.

With nowhere to go

Topping the list of Egypt's concerns is that Palestinians could be forced to try to storm Gaza's 13km border into Egypt, where they would be entering the Sinai Peninsula, the rugged, mountainous and sparsely populated region sandwiched between the Mediterranean and Red Sea.

With Israel unlikely to allow the Palestinians to return to Gaza, their resettlement in Sinai would lead to the further “liquidation” of the Palestinian cause, or another Nakba, the Arabic word for calamity used widely to refer to the estimated 700,000 Palestinians who fled or were forced to leave their homes around the time of Israel's creation in 1948.

It would also bring the Palestinian-Israeli conflict on to Egyptian territory. Mr El Sisi recently said militants would invariably infiltrate the displaced Palestinians flooding into Egypt and later launch cross-border attacks on Israel from their new base. That, he added, would give Israel licence to carry out retaliatory strikes targeting militants on Egyptian soil.

The influx of Palestinians into Sinai from Rafah appears to be neither far-fetched nor a figment of the imagination of Egyptian authorities.

Already, displaced Palestinians in Rafah are living in makeshift camps merely metres from the border fence. Their children play on improvised swings using the fence's metal poles.

Images and footage posted online show Palestinians conversing with Egyptian soldiers guarding the frontier. In some cases, children ask why they cannot be allowed to cross into Egypt.

If Israel makes good on its threat to invade Rafah, those images could be transformed into Palestinians jammed against the border fence, begging to be allowed through into Egypt to escape death or injury.

Not allowing them to do so would cast Egypt in a very negative light: a heartless country, indifferent to the plight of the very people – the Palestinians – whose cause it has long claimed to champion.

Preparations on the border

Egyptian authorities are already working on what security sources describe as an “incubator” – a walled enclosure on a 25 sq km stretch of land in Sinai next to the Gaza border.

Sources familiar with the project say the aim is for Egypt to be able to absorb Palestinians who might rush across the border fleeing an Israeli offensive, and thereby spare Egypt any harmful publicity that could come from Palestinians being killed in Rafah while the borders remain shut.

It would also allow the containment of the Palestinians who arrive in Egypt in one place where authorities can exercise maximum control, the sources said.

Egypt has officially denied it is building such a facility and says satellite photos of the site released by monitoring groups show work to construct a logistics centre for aid to Gaza.

The sources who spoke to The National said this official denial was aimed at discouraging suggestions that Egypt has resigned itself to allow Palestinians to flee over the border, and countering accusations that Cairo is indirectly aiding Israel's war effort.

“It's a legitimate precautionary measure by the armed forces to have this area as a first line of defence if the Palestinians storm across the border to escape Israeli fire in Rafah,” said one source.

Egypt has meanwhile been building a concrete wall only 10 metres from the barbed wire and barriers on the border with Gaza, the sources added.

Construction, they explained, followed an Israeli barrage on the Gaza side of the Rafah border crossing in the early days of the war.

Residents of the Egyptian side of Rafah were evicted from the city between 2015-2017, a time when security forces were engaged in near daily battles against insurgents in north-east Sinai.

A government decree in 2021 enshrined the evacuation of Rafah – as many as 3,000 families are thought to have been affected – offering residents monetary compensation and housing in nearby cities, towns and villages. The area has since been placed under direct military control.

Under the provisions of their 1979 peace treaty, the number of troops that could be deployed in the border area is severely restricted. However, both Egypt and Israel have been ignoring the letter of the treaty's security appendix, with Egypt beefing up its forces in the area and Israel amassing troops not far from the Gaza side of the border.

The presence of forces on either side, said the sources, could create a volatile situation if a major military operation is under way in Rafah. That in turn could be conducive to the possibility of inadvertent shelling of Egyptian troops or death and injury as a result of nearby bombardment, they said.

“The overarching command for our forces there is the exercise of extreme restraint,” said one of the sources.