How Wall Street helped secure a $30bn lifeline for First Republic Bank

Eleven banks, including Bank of America, Citigroup, JP Morgan Chase and Wells Fargo, deposited billions of dollars to support the distressed lender after a flurry of calls

Wall Street's biggest lenders and the US government came to the aid of First Republic Bank after its share price fell by 60 per cent over the past week. AFP
Powered by automated translation

Jamie Dimon and Janet Yellen were on a call on Tuesday, when she floated an idea: What if the nation’s largest lenders deposited billions of dollars into First Republic Bank, the latest company getting nudged toward the brink by a depositor panic.

Mr Dimon was game — and soon the chief executive of JP Morgan Chase was reaching out to the heads of the next three largest US lenders: Bank of America, Citigroup and Wells Fargo.

All month, the nation’s biggest banks have been raking in deposits from nervous customers at smaller lenders — and now those behemoths would be taking some of their own money and handing it to a San Francisco bank in distress, trying to staunch a widening crisis.

Over two days of frantic phone calls, meetings and some arm-twisting, the chief executives of 11 banks agreed to chip in a total of $30 billion for First Republic, promising to park the money there for at least 120 days.

The hope is that is enough to save First Republic, known for its outsize business catering to wealthy technology executives. Or perhaps, at the least, the cash will give the lender enough time to find another solution, such as a sale.

Such is the new-new-new line in the sand as the authorities in the US and Europe try to quell the panic of 2023.

Already the rescue spearheaded by Mr Dimon is sparking comparisons to the panic of 1907, when J. Pierpont Morgan — who built up the company that Mr Dimon now leads — corralled Wall Street financiers into his private library and browbeat them into propping up the Trust Company of America, seeking to stop a string of bank runs that threatened to upend the industry.

One reason strong banks stepped forward then was that US authorities had little ability to do so, which led to the creation of the Federal Reserve.

This time, regulators were already scrutinising First Republic, raising the prospect of emergency government intervention — and political blowback for years to come.

“If this works, it is a brilliant 'two-fer',’” said Todd Baker, a senior fellow at Columbia University’s Richard Paul Richman Centre for Business, Law, and Public Policy.

Big banks already were coming under fire for soaking up deposits from smaller lenders. Now they can show they are part of the solution while the Biden administration worries about one less bank, he said.

Regulators took their own shot at assuaging US banking customers last weekend, promising to fully pay out uninsured deposits after the failure of two US lenders — SVB Financial Group and Signature Bank.

The Fed also made a pair of credit facilities available to help other banks keep up with any demands for withdrawals.

But that is not guaranteed to work. And there already are signs that the strains in the financial system have yet to abate.

Early on Thursday in Zurich, the Swiss National Bank offered Credit Suisse a $54 billion liquidity lifeline to keep the lender in business as it tries to overhaul operations.

Then, later on Thursday, the Fed published data showing how heavily banks are drawing on its assistance.

They borrowed a combined $164.8 billion from two backstop facilities in the most recent week ended March 15. That includes a record $152.85 billion from the discount window, the traditional liquidity support for banks. The previous record was $111 billion, which was reached during the 2008 financial crisis.

Against that backdrop, most big US banks were eager to show their interest in pitching in, according to sources.

Ms Yellen discussed the idea early on with senior officials, including Fed Chairman Jerome Powell and FDIC chairman Martin Gruenberg.

The flurry of phone calls among bankers kept widening on Wednesday as more lenders agreed to join the group.

Still, some chief executives required cajoling, questioning the necessity of the rescue or whether it would be enough to work.

Ms Yellen spoke to some directly, also keeping White House chief of staff Jeff Zients and National Economic Council director Lael Brainard in the loop.

By Thursday, much of the group was taking shape. It is possible that at least some laggards were invited late, or simply needed more time to get internal approvals. Goldman Sachs was among the last few.

Another call on Thursday morning between regulators and chief executives helped to finalise the plan.

“This show of support by a group of large banks is most welcome, and demonstrates the resilience of the banking system,” Ms Yellen, Mr Powell, Mr Gruenberg and acting Comptroller of the Currency Michael Hsu said in a joint statement.

In some ways, the rescue resembles the 1998 plan devised to bail out Long Term Capital Management without using public money, after the hedge fund made disastrous wrong-way bets.

Back then, the Fed convened a meeting of Wall Street executives from Merrill Lynch, Goldman Sachs and about a dozen others. They agreed to pump $3.65 billion into the fund to keep it afloat and avert a collapse in financial markets.

As with LTCM, the banks considered saving First Republic as, ultimately, in their best interests as it is better than risking a widening panic that might engulf more of them, one source said.

“This is the banking system taking care of itself,” said Todd Phillips, a former Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation lawyer now at the Roosevelt Institute.

One delicate aspect of the $30 billion lifeline is portioning out the credit.

Although Mr Dimon played the role of J. Pierpont Morgan behind the scenes, the banks crafted a joint statement, sorting their names into a groups based on the size of their contributions, and then listing them alphabetically.

That put Bank of America at the front.

Then in a chaotic rush of press releases, Citigroup’s happened to go out first.

Updated: March 17, 2023, 9:36 AM