Best-loved novel? J K Rowling, J R R Tolkien, Jane Austen novels vie for bragging rights

More than 4 million votes were cast over six months, with Austen's Pride and Prejudice, Tolkien's Lord of the Rings series and Rowling's Harry Potter saga making the top 10 on an alphabetical-order list

This combination photo shows J.R.R. Tolkien, author of "The Lord of the Rings," series in 1967, left, and J. K. Rowling, author of the "Harry Potter" series at  the "Harry Potter and the Cursed Child" Broadway opening in New York on April 22, 2018. The effort to discover America's best-loved novel - and promote reading - will end with the winner announced on Tuesday's finale of PBS' "The Great American Read." The series profiled the contenders and let bookworms, famous and not, advocate for their pick. (AP Photo)
Powered by automated translation

The results are in for an impassioned national election that put the popularity of candidates Jane Austen, J R R Tolkien and J K Rowling on the line.

The effort to discover America's best-loved novel — and promote reading — ends with the winner announced on Tuesday's finale of PBS' The Great American Read. The series profiled the contenders and let bookworms, famous and not, advocate for their pick.

More than 4 million votes were cast over six months, PBS said, with Austen's Pride and Prejudice, Tolkien's Lord of the Rings series and Rowling's Harry Potter saga making the top 10 on an alphabetical-order list that was released as voting wrapped last week.

The other front-runners were Charlotte's Web by E B White; The Chronicles of Narnia series by C S Lewis; Gone with the Wind by Margaret Mitchell; Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte; Little Women by Louisa May Alcott; the Outlander series by Diane Gabaldon; and To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee.

Harry Potter was among the multivolume series that counted as a single entry. Given its hold on the modern imagination on the page, screen and stage, it might be the obvious winner.

Eliyannah Ysrael, who discovered Rowling's magic touch about 15 years ago as a Chicago State University student, was among its vocal boosters on The Great American Read and beyond.

"Listen, me and Harry Potter are going to take this thing to the end. I want to be victorious," Ysrael told a TV critics' gathering last summer.

Series host Meredith Vieira didn't spill the beans in a recent interview. But she was glad to tout the initiative's ripple effect, including a nearly 50,000-member online book club and more than 5 million views for series-related video content across PBS platforms, Facebook and YouTube.


"We forget the power of a book, not just on individuals but on groups of people. There's something wonderful about sitting down with your friends and talking about a book," Vieira said. "And ultimately with these novels you learn something more about yourself. They force you to question who you are, your values as an individual, your values as a society."

About a fifth of the 100 books were provocative enough that they've been censored in some manner, said series executive producer Jane Root, who called that number "astounding."

"We were expecting it to be two or three. But a huge number of books, I think because of their potency and the power of the relationship that you have with a really great book, they upset people," she said. "They disturbed the waters. They make people fearful."

Some popular books simply have a whizz-bang story to tell, with top 100 titles Fifty Shades of Grey and The Da Vinci Code making the point.

The list was based on an initial survey of about 7,000 Americans, with an advisory panel of experts organising the 100-contender list. Books had to have been published in English but not written in the language, and one book or series per author was allowed.

A fair amount of regional partisanship emerged. Louisiana voters were alone in ranking native son John Kennedy Toole's A Confederacy of Dunces in the top 10, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn was No 6 in New York and Mark Twain's The Adventures of Tom Sawyer was a front-runner with readers in his home state of Missouri.

Voters also went big for sci-fi and fantasy both past and present, with representatives including Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and George R R Martin's Game of Thrones epic.

The point of The Great American Read initiative has been made no matter what work ends up as No 1, Vieira said.

"Getting people to vote in a way is a gimmick," she said, a way to reinvigorate the love of reading and to foster discussions about why and how certain books resonate with people.

But while readers' passions may run high, she said, the divisiveness so rampant in politics is happily absent.

"It doesn't matter where you fall. People I've spoken to who liked books I didn't have inspired me to take second look at them, like Game of Thrones," Vieira said. "I don't leave a project like this and not feel optimistic."


Read more: