Game review: the meeting of two Mario franchises in Paper Jam falls a bit flat

The new role-playing game also tests your patience as some of the fights drag on well past the half-hour mark.

Some of the fights in Paper Jam drag on well past the half-hour mark. Courtesy Nintendo
Powered by automated translation
Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam


For Nintendo 3DS

Two-and-a-half stars

Role-playing games such as Fallout 4 and The Witcher 3 are beloved for their complexity, ambition and overwhelming variety of things to do. But those same traits scare some players away, particularly grown-ups who may not have 100 hours free to really dig in.

Nintendo's light-hearted Mario & Luigi adventures are a good fix for people who prefer their role-playing in more digestible chunks. They are essentially RPG-lite, simplifying the character building and inventory management of more complicated epics. They make great introductory RPGs – and are challenging enough to keep even genre veterans on their toes.

Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam finds the brothers dealing with a threat from a different series of games: Paper Mario, in which all the familiar denizens of the Mushroom Kingdom are flattened into two dimensions.

When Luigi cracks open an arcane book in his 3D world, the 2D characters start dropping from the skies. That means two Marios, two Princess Peaches and, unfortunately, two Bowsers.

Paper Jam follows the usual formula from Japanese studio AlphaDream. The boys roam around the kingdom, fighting monsters and solving puzzles as they try to stop whatever nefarious plans Bowser has hatched.

The action freezes whenever a battle begins, then Mario, Luigi and Paper Mario take turns jumping on enemies or hitting them with hammers. The heroes can also team up, two or three at a time, to unleash more-powerful attacks. It’s an appealing design, mixing old-school, turn-based strategy with occasional arcade bits that test your reflexes.

Unfortunately, however, the merger of the two franchises doesn't bring out the best in either. The Paper Mario games are most notable for clever puzzles that played off the need to shift your perspective between 2D and 3D. Such challenges are absent from Paper Jam and they are sorely missed. Indeed, the "paper" aspect only really comes into play when the two sides build giant paper-craft versions of the heroes and villains, then set them loose in battle arenas. These boxing matches are tedious battles of attrition that drag on and on until one of the behemoths collapses.

Then again, all of the boss battles in Paper Jam will try your patience. No matter how well-equipped or versatile your guys are, some of these fights drag on well past the half-hour mark – which is way too long for a portable game. You may want to switch to easy mode during the boss fights just to get them over with more quickly.

Despite such roadblocks, much of Paper Jam is enjoyable. There's a sprawling world to explore and plenty of the droll, off-kilter comedy the Mario & Luigi franchise is celebrated for.

It's not the most satisfying M&L adventure – that would be 2009's Bowser's Inside Story – but it's a pleasant enough break from the apocalyptic gloom of most RPGs.

* Lou Kesten / Associated Press