• BRIGHTON RATINGS: Jason Steele 8: Good saves from Rashford, Antony and Martial in first half. And again after break from Fernandes. Excellent night’s work from goalkeeper. AP
    BRIGHTON RATINGS: Jason Steele 8: Good saves from Rashford, Antony and Martial in first half. And again after break from Fernandes. Excellent night’s work from goalkeeper. AP
  • Moises Caicedo 7: Midfielder started at right-back due to injuries and grew into the role as match went on. Left for dead by Rashford in first half and needed Steele to produce decent stop. Booked for foul on Fernandes late on but was then denied injury-time goal by De Gea save. AFP
    Moises Caicedo 7: Midfielder started at right-back due to injuries and grew into the role as match went on. Left for dead by Rashford in first half and needed Steele to produce decent stop. Booked for foul on Fernandes late on but was then denied injury-time goal by De Gea save. AFP
  • Adam Webster 7: Saw header from corner saved by Ge Gea inside 20 minutes as defender looked to score first goal since February 2022. Booked for late tackle on Fernandes which was correct call despite his protests. Getty
    Adam Webster 7: Saw header from corner saved by Ge Gea inside 20 minutes as defender looked to score first goal since February 2022. Booked for late tackle on Fernandes which was correct call despite his protests. Getty
  • Lewis Dunk 7: Captain was nutmegged by Rashford early doors who then created chance for Fernandes who could only fire well over. Booked for confronting Antony after United winger chopped down Mac Allister. Immense in the air when United put crosses into box. AFP
    Lewis Dunk 7: Captain was nutmegged by Rashford early doors who then created chance for Fernandes who could only fire well over. Booked for confronting Antony after United winger chopped down Mac Allister. Immense in the air when United put crosses into box. AFP
  • Pervis Estupinan 8: One magnificent recovery challenge to take ball off Rashford with United attacker almost through on goal which summed up Ecuadorian’s impressive performance at the back. AP
    Pervis Estupinan 8: One magnificent recovery challenge to take ball off Rashford with United attacker almost through on goal which summed up Ecuadorian’s impressive performance at the back. AP
  • Billy Gilmour 6: Caught in possession in first couple of minutes which nearly resulted in Antony scoring. Mixed bag distribution wise from midfielder, some lovely balls to feet at times, but also guilty of over-hitting passes and wasting counter-attacks. Certainly no faulting his workrate. AP
    Billy Gilmour 6: Caught in possession in first couple of minutes which nearly resulted in Antony scoring. Mixed bag distribution wise from midfielder, some lovely balls to feet at times, but also guilty of over-hitting passes and wasting counter-attacks. Certainly no faulting his workrate. AP
  • Julio Enciso 8: Paraguayan teenager is enjoying run in starting XI and is real livewire in possession. Struck a nice effort just wide in first half, but fired another shot high and wide after skipping easily past Casemiro. Getty
    Julio Enciso 8: Paraguayan teenager is enjoying run in starting XI and is real livewire in possession. Struck a nice effort just wide in first half, but fired another shot high and wide after skipping easily past Casemiro. Getty
  • Alexis Mac Allister 8: Argentine, who has been linked with move to United, curled shot just after half-hour mark. On receiving end of some poor tackles from Casemiro and Antony. Denied late winner by fine De Gea save but then calmly smashed penalty into top corner nine minutes into injury-time. AP
    Alexis Mac Allister 8: Argentine, who has been linked with move to United, curled shot just after half-hour mark. On receiving end of some poor tackles from Casemiro and Antony. Denied late winner by fine De Gea save but then calmly smashed penalty into top corner nine minutes into injury-time. AP
  • Kaoru Mitoma 7: Clean through in opening five minutes but shot straight at De Gea’s face. Side-footed another chance just wide not long after cutting inside from left. Shot cleared off line in injury-time. Could be a world-beater if he learns to shoot with his left peg as he is ridiculously right footed. AFP
    Kaoru Mitoma 7: Clean through in opening five minutes but shot straight at De Gea’s face. Side-footed another chance just wide not long after cutting inside from left. Shot cleared off line in injury-time. Could be a world-beater if he learns to shoot with his left peg as he is ridiculously right footed. AFP
  • Facundo Buonanotte 7: Produced a lovely curling strike from an acute angle that flew wide of target but had De Gear at full stretch just before half-time. Given standing ovation for his efforts when he came off after break. Getty
    Facundo Buonanotte 7: Produced a lovely curling strike from an acute angle that flew wide of target but had De Gear at full stretch just before half-time. Given standing ovation for his efforts when he came off after break. Getty
  • Danny Welbeck 6: Striker has scored four goals in last six league games but never had sight of goal against former club until just before hour mark when his struck first-time shot wide. Some decent link-up play in second half. AP
    Danny Welbeck 6: Striker has scored four goals in last six league games but never had sight of goal against former club until just before hour mark when his struck first-time shot wide. Some decent link-up play in second half. AP
  • SUBS: Solly March (On for Buonanotte 63’) 7: Missed key penalty in League Cup final shoot-out defeat against United but was nearly the hero here with one sensational run forward that ended with him thumping shot wide. AP
    SUBS: Solly March (On for Buonanotte 63’) 7: Missed key penalty in League Cup final shoot-out defeat against United but was nearly the hero here with one sensational run forward that ended with him thumping shot wide. AP
  • Deniz Undav (On for Welbeck 75’) 6: One shot deflected wide for corner by Shaw. Getty
    Deniz Undav (On for Welbeck 75’) 6: One shot deflected wide for corner by Shaw. Getty
  • Levi Colwill (On for Gilmour 75’) 6: Chelsea loan man booked for tripping Sabitzer within two minutes of coming on. AFP
    Levi Colwill (On for Gilmour 75’) 6: Chelsea loan man booked for tripping Sabitzer within two minutes of coming on. AFP
  • MAN UNITED RATINGS: David De Gea 7: Saved from Mitoma with his face on three minutes and looked out for the count. No chance for Mac Allister’s penalty. In between, he made several fine saves and was about to register his eighth clean sheet in United’s last 11 league games until late spot-kick. Getty
    MAN UNITED RATINGS: David De Gea 7: Saved from Mitoma with his face on three minutes and looked out for the count. No chance for Mac Allister’s penalty. In between, he made several fine saves and was about to register his eighth clean sheet in United’s last 11 league games until late spot-kick. Getty
  • Aaron Wan-Bissaka 7: Usually excellent in one v ones, but work cut out against Mitoma in a fascinating battle. Cleared a 21st minute cross away. Left his position to attack at the end of the first half. Nutmegged by Gilmour. AFP
    Aaron Wan-Bissaka 7: Usually excellent in one v ones, but work cut out against Mitoma in a fascinating battle. Cleared a 21st minute cross away. Left his position to attack at the end of the first half. Nutmegged by Gilmour. AFP
  • Victor Lindelof 7: Playing well and he did again but gave the ball away to Mitoma on three minutes and was fortunate Brighton didn’t take the chance. AP
    Victor Lindelof 7: Playing well and he did again but gave the ball away to Mitoma on three minutes and was fortunate Brighton didn’t take the chance. AP
  • Luke Shaw 7: Another who is playing well. Harshly received a yellow card in injury-time after a nothing challenge on Encisco, but his handball in the final moments of the game led to a Brighton penalty … and another United away defeat against a top ten side. PA
    Luke Shaw 7: Another who is playing well. Harshly received a yellow card in injury-time after a nothing challenge on Encisco, but his handball in the final moments of the game led to a Brighton penalty … and another United away defeat against a top ten side. PA
  • Diogo Dalot 7: Played at left-back away from his natural position and lost the ball after 54 minutes to set up Mitoma. Booked. Then he got the ball caught under his feet. All inside six minutes. Atrocious ball saw him concede possession and an attack break down on 71. AP
    Diogo Dalot 7: Played at left-back away from his natural position and lost the ball after 54 minutes to set up Mitoma. Booked. Then he got the ball caught under his feet. All inside six minutes. Atrocious ball saw him concede possession and an attack break down on 71. AP
  • Casemiro 6: Fired 10th minute effort towards Gatwick Airport, then dispossessed by Gilmour, then gave the ball away on 14. Headed over just before half-hour mark, then did his usual heavy tackle on Mac Allister. Got away with a second booking in the second half and also curled a shot over. Getty
    Casemiro 6: Fired 10th minute effort towards Gatwick Airport, then dispossessed by Gilmour, then gave the ball away on 14. Headed over just before half-hour mark, then did his usual heavy tackle on Mac Allister. Got away with a second booking in the second half and also curled a shot over. Getty
  • Fred 5: Easily dispossessed on 67 by Caidedo, the man he was outclassed by. AFP
    Fred 5: Easily dispossessed on 67 by Caidedo, the man he was outclassed by. AFP
  • Antony 6: Put a clear chance wide in second minute and again on 20. Couldn’t get into the game and faded in the second half. Lost his head and was booked in second half for a swinging challenge on Mac Allister. United don’t score enough goals. It’s a major problem. PA
    Antony 6: Put a clear chance wide in second minute and again on 20. Couldn’t get into the game and faded in the second half. Lost his head and was booked in second half for a swinging challenge on Mac Allister. United don’t score enough goals. It’s a major problem. PA
  • Bruno Fernandes 6: Wonder ball forward to Rashford in opening 20 minutes. Was in space as Rashford broke before half time. Heavily challenged by Webster, who was booked. Shot on in second half. Reuters
    Bruno Fernandes 6: Wonder ball forward to Rashford in opening 20 minutes. Was in space as Rashford broke before half time. Heavily challenged by Webster, who was booked. Shot on in second half. Reuters
  • Marcus Rashford 6: Lovely play in the build-up to a 10th minute attack. Beautiful as he went past Caiciedo and shot on target just before half-hour. Rapid but should have passed to Fernandes in the first half. PA
    Marcus Rashford 6: Lovely play in the build-up to a 10th minute attack. Beautiful as he went past Caiciedo and shot on target just before half-hour. Rapid but should have passed to Fernandes in the first half. PA
  • Anthony Martial 5: His manager didn’t feel like he was doing enough, but there were moments – a well-timed run to set up Antony on 20 minutes. Worked a move well with Fred before firing a shot at Steele later in half. A couple of fleet-footed moments in the second half, but his boss was right. Reuters
    Anthony Martial 5: His manager didn’t feel like he was doing enough, but there were moments – a well-timed run to set up Antony on 20 minutes. Worked a move well with Fred before firing a shot at Steele later in half. A couple of fleet-footed moments in the second half, but his boss was right. Reuters
  • SUBS: Jadon Sancho (On for Antony 76’) N/A. Getty
    SUBS: Jadon Sancho (On for Antony 76’) N/A. Getty
  • Marcel Sabitzer (On for Fred 76’) N/A. PA
    Marcel Sabitzer (On for Fred 76’) N/A. PA
  • Wout Weghorst (On for Martial 83') N/A. PA
    Wout Weghorst (On for Martial 83') N/A. PA

Brighton v Manchester United player ratings: Mac Allister 8, Mitoma 7; De Gea 7, Martial 5


Alexis Mac Allister's penalty deep into injury-time earned Brighton a 1-0 Premier League win over Manchester United at the Amex Stadium on Thursday.

A highly entertaining game on the south coast looked set to finish goalless when Luke Shaw handled the ball in the box and the Seagulls were awarded a spot-kick after a VAR review.

Argentine World Cup winner Mac Allister calmly stepped up to blast the penalty into the top corner giving Brighton & Hove Albion some revenge after losing in the FA Cup semi-finals to United following a shoot-out at Wembley.

“There is a god of football because we deserved to win in the semi-final and we lost on penalties,” Brighton manager Roberto de Zerbi told Sky Sports. “But in both games I think we played better than United. The last result was unfair.

“We dominated the game against one incredible team, but we have to play another six very tough games.

“Monday we play the first game against Everton and we have to win, because if we don’t we lose these three points.”

Albion's 1-0 win moves them up to sixth in the table, above Tottenham Hotspur and Aston Villa, while United are left looking over their shoulders at fifth-placed Liverpool.

The Seagulls sit just four points behind Jurgen Klopp's Reds with two games in hand thanks to the last-gasp winner.

Antony and Anthony Martial wasted golden opportunities for United, who still have work to do to seal their Champions League spot next term following a painful defeat.

Before Mac Allister's last-gasp breakthrough, Kaoru Mitoma missed the Seagulls' best opening of a feisty encounter, thumping the ball into the head of David de Gea during a rapid start.

United keeper De Gea was visibly dazed by the unconventional stop but was deemed fit to carry on following on-field treatment.

You can see the player ratings from Thursday's game in the gallery above. To move on to the next photo, click on the arrows or swipe if using a mobile device.

Updated: May 05, 2023, 2:33 AM