The opening Test between England and Pakistan gave both teams plenty to think about heading into the second Test in Southampton on Thursday.
England eked out a tense three-wicket win chasing 277, after being reduced to 117-5; a win that was achieved through fifties from Jos Buttler (75) and Chris Woakes (84 not out).
England will admit they were behind the game for a big part of the Test, while Pakistan would be lamenting the failure of their bowling attack to finish things off after taking out the top order cheaply.
As the teams prepare for the second Test of the three-match series, here are the main talking points.
Stokes-sized hole in England line-up
He had not been bowling his full quota of overs due to a thigh injury but Ben Stokes the batsman is worth his weight in gold. England will miss his services for the remainder of the series after the all-rounder travelled to New Zealand to be with his family.
He failed with the bat in both innings in Manchester but managed to pick two wickets in four overs in Pakistan's second innings to help bowl the visitors out cheaply for 169 and set the stage for a manageable chase of under 300.
England have a decision to make – beef up the batting line-up through Zak Crawley, or bring in wicketkeeper Ben Foakes and use Buttler as a pure batsman. Buttler has struggled with the gloves, and Foakes is considered the best wicketkeeper in the country, but Joe Root might go with an additional batsman.
________________
England v Pakistan 1st Test ratings
-
ENGLAND TEST RATINGS: Rory Burns – 4. Similar dismissals in either innings – lbw – might point to a deficiency, but Burns has proved himself adept at solving problems quickly so far in his Test career. Reuters -
Dom Sibley – 5. Outfoxed by Mohammad Abbas’ new-ball brilliance on the first morning. Battled doggedly in the second innings, but lapsed when driving against Yasir. Getty -
Joe Root – 6. England’s captain would not mind having that issue with converting 50s to tons at the moment. For now he’s struggling to turn starts into scores. Reuters -
Ben Stokes – 6. A rare off game with the bat, thanks largely to two unplayable deliveries. At least he played a role with the ball in Pakistan’s second innings. AP -
Ollie Pope – 7. England would have been sunk if not for his counter-attacking half-century on the second day. The ball that got him in the second innings was unplayable. AP -
Jos Buttler – 7. In a huge amount of debt after twice letting off Masood while in the 40s, but he repaid that when it mattered with the bat. Reuters -
Chris Woakes – 9. Deserved more than the four wickets he took with the ball, and he played the seminal hand with the bat with his last-innings 84 not out. Reuters -
Dom Bess – 6. Still just sort of existing in the side. Two wickets on a pitch that favoured spin, and was also at the wicket when victory was sealed – on nought not out. AFP -
Jofra Archer – 6. Three wickets in the first innings – including two in two balls – and relatively underemployed in the second. Reuters -
Stuart Broad – 7. Continues to threaten with the ball, with three wickets in each innings, and another couple of important cameos with the bat, too. PA -
James Anderson – 5. Just the lone wicket in the match, and he was relatively expensive by his lofty standards, too. Getty -
PAKISTAN RATINGS: Shan Masood – 9. Got the fairytale return to England that he craved with a brilliant first-innings century. The fact he reached it off James Anderson will have felt all the sweeter. Getty -
Abid Ali – 5. Made starts in both innings without being able to convert. After his fine start in Test cricket, he might find opening in England more of a challenge. AP -
Azhar Ali – 4. Struggled with the bat, with a duck and 18, and was unable to press home the advantage when his side were in a winning position on the fourth afternoon. Getty -
Babar Azam – 7. “Bobby” batted like a prince on the opening day, and looked set for a ton, only to fall straight away on the second morning. Made just five in the second. Reuters -
Asad Shafiq – 5. Undone by Broad cheaply in the first innings, and fell to a rare run out in the second. Reuters -
Mohammed Rizwan – 8. Provided a wicketkeeping demo against the turning ball on worn wicket. Stood up to Abbas at important times, too. AFP -
Shadab Khan – 7. Picked up two quick wickets having been under-bowled in the first innings, and played a crucial hand with the bat in alliance with Masood. AFP -
Yasir Shah – 7. Unfair that he had the burden of bowling Pakistan to the win in the last innings. Could not have battled much harder, as he took eight wickets in the match. Reuters -
Mohammed Abbas – 7. It feels remarkable he only took three wickets in the match, given that he always seemed to be a threat. PA -
Shaheen Afridi – 6. Might have deserved more wickets, as he challenged both edges of the bat frequently. He needs to be mindful of the no-balls he is bowling. AP -
Naseem Shah – 6. Had a lot to live up to given all the hype pre-match. He did not exactly steal the show, but he still showed glimpses of his great promise. AFP
Anderson approaches milestone
England veteran James Anderson is 10 away from 600 Test wickets. That should be the talk of the town, but instead the focus is on his dwindling returns; Anderson has just six wickets in three Tests this summer at an average of 41.17.
The 38-year-old asked England to "keep faith" in his abilities and stated retirement is the last thing on his mind.
"Hopefully I can show people I've still got what it takes to play Test cricket. I'll keep my fingers crossed that the captain and coach keep faith with me for the next game," Anderson said.
"I think the frustration for me was that after one bad game the whispers go around. I don't think that's really fair. I'm still hungry to play the game and I'll work hard to try and put things right if I get a chance."
Will Fawad play?
Pakistan have a few issues of their own. Leg-spinner Shadab Khan was selected to provide some lower-order runs and useful overs on what was clearly a pitch conducive for spinners at Old Trafford.
He did score 45 and 15, but bowled just eight overs for 34 runs in the fourth innings. Captain Azhar Ali seemed reluctant to give him overs when the pressure was on, which raises questions about his place in the team as the Southampton pitch is unlikely to warrant two wrist spinners.
A section of Pakistan supporters are keen to see domestic cricket stalwart Fawad Alam get an opportunity to play Test cricket again; he last played Tests for the country 11 years back.
Despite being the most prolific batsman at the domestic level in Pakistan – he has scored more than 12,000 runs at an average of more than 56 – Alam has been found himself out of the squad or the playing XI. Now seems a good opportunity to draft him in, especially because captain Ali looks out of touch.
